Sutjahjo Ngaserin
Stunt Coordinator
- Joined
- Jun 30, 1997
- Messages
- 133
I have been spending a lot of time listening to both DVD-Audio and Multichannel SACD in the last 2 weeks. and I am more than happy to say that both formats presents an obvious and significant improvements over normal Audio CD or any variations of CD like HDCD or XRCD
I was exposed to DVD Audio earlier using Toshiba SD9200 connected to Denon AVC-A1SE (equivalent to 5800 in US) to 6
identical B&W SNT-CNT speakers (only 5 used in the case of DVD-Audio) and Sunfire Subwoofer.
Recently I have the chance to play with Pioneer DV-S733A (equivalent to 47A in US and 747A in Europe) DVD Audio and
multichannel SACD players and I have been asking every help I can get, to collect the maximum number of software I can find on both formats.
and here is the softwares I have tried listening to:
Multichannel SACD
Jacintha - Lush Life
Ginuwine - The Life
Earth Wind and Fire - Gratitude
Billy Joel - The Stranger
Billy Joel - 42nd. Street
Chrisy Baron -Steppin'
Jeff Beck - Blow by Blow
Steve Tyrell -Standard Time
Roger Waters - In the Flesh
Charlotte Church -Enchantment
James Taylor - Hour Glass
Sony SACD Two-Channel and Multichannel demonstration disc
Joe Beck & Aly Ryerson -Django
Chris Botti - Night Sessions
The Isley Brother - 3+3 featuring that lady
Alice in Chains - Greatest Hits
Ana Caram - Blue Bossa
Hacken Lee - Live
Celine - All the way, a decade of Songs
DVD-Audio
Christy Byron -Steppin'
Fleetwood Mac -Rumours
Alice Cooper - Welcome to my Nightmare
Alice Cooper - Billion Dollar Babies
Toy Matinee - Toy Matinee
Dave Koz - The Dance
Al Green - Greatest Hits
George Benson - Breezin
Miss E - So Addictive
Foreigner - Foreigner
Foreigner - 4
Carly Simon - No Secret
Joni Mitchel - Both Sides Now
Bird3 - Bird 3
America - Homecoming
Eric Clapton - Reptile
Eric Clapton - Riding with the King
Eagles - Hotel California.
Deep Purple - Machine Head
Inside the Music, New Wave
Inside the Music, Classic Country
Rambient - So Many Worlds
Inside the Music,Women on Top
Natalie Merchant - Tigerlily
Neil Young, Friends & Relatives - Road Rock
K.D. Lang - Invincible Summer
Stone Temple Pilots - Stone Temple Pilots
Aaron Neville - Devotion
Take 6 - Doo Bee Doo Wop Bop
Larisa Stow - Moment by Moment
Willie Nelson - Night and Day
Emerson, Lake & Palmer - Brain Salad Surgery
Studio Voodoo
Barenaked Ladies - Maroon
olivia - One woman's Live Journey
Glen Phillips - Abulum
Steely Dan - Two against nature
David Alan - Live Music
Paul Gilbert - Aligator Farm
Steve Stevens - Flamenco Agogo
Luis Miguel - Romances
DV-S733A is connected to AVC-A1SE by the 6 RCA cables (analogue out in player and analogue in in amp), speakers are 6 Blueroom Minipods (only 5 used in both formats) and a Sunfire Subwoofer in a small bedroom with good acoustics.
DVD Audios are impressive in its immediate expansive sounds and wide dynamic range. In many pop recordings like
Eagles' Hotel California or the 2 Eric Claptons Albums, it has very tight impressive sounds with a lot of amazing details that we have not heard elsewhere.
My general impressions are that good SACD are extremely lush, warm, smooth and sweet, making a generally mid-end
system like this sounds high-end without paying the exhorbitant entrance fee. Nothing sounds smoother and more
realistic than Jacintha's Lush Life, James Taylor's Hourglass or Hacken Lee's Life (3 best recorded SACD, in my opinion). The good tonal qualities of SACD however lacks the required dynamic ranges. In most of the Pop recording, e.g. Alice in Chains (well recorded) or 2 Billy Joel's albums, or Roger Water's In the Flesh (and other SACD), In most SACD the dynamic range felt compressed. while SACD can sounds very good, no albums can be as impressive as the Eagles and Eric Clapton's DVD Audio's detail (I am well aware of SACD's specification of better dynamic range, especially to the sky high frequencies).
The respecitve strengths of both formats become obvious when Christy Byron's Steppin' DVD-Audio and SACD are tried
in the 733A, with the SACD sounding warmer and smoother while (DVDA) with more tonal details and better dynamic range in the DVD Audio version(my Car DVD-Audio shows Chrysty Byron DVD-Audio as a 24bit/48Khz recording, even when the 96Khz track is chosen)
Personally, I think both formats are a great gifts to audiophiles, with SACD of simple audiophile recording (not too complicated, trio and quartet, vocals with cello, piano etc) sonding much better and the DVD Audio of pop and rock recording sounding superior.
Let us hope more and more DVD Audio and SACD will be issued! and left fans of both formats with little to complain.
If anyone wishes to ask questions regarding the hardware setups or my opinions on any of the discs mentioned, please let me know either in this thread or Email me...
I was exposed to DVD Audio earlier using Toshiba SD9200 connected to Denon AVC-A1SE (equivalent to 5800 in US) to 6
identical B&W SNT-CNT speakers (only 5 used in the case of DVD-Audio) and Sunfire Subwoofer.
Recently I have the chance to play with Pioneer DV-S733A (equivalent to 47A in US and 747A in Europe) DVD Audio and
multichannel SACD players and I have been asking every help I can get, to collect the maximum number of software I can find on both formats.
and here is the softwares I have tried listening to:
Multichannel SACD
Jacintha - Lush Life
Ginuwine - The Life
Earth Wind and Fire - Gratitude
Billy Joel - The Stranger
Billy Joel - 42nd. Street
Chrisy Baron -Steppin'
Jeff Beck - Blow by Blow
Steve Tyrell -Standard Time
Roger Waters - In the Flesh
Charlotte Church -Enchantment
James Taylor - Hour Glass
Sony SACD Two-Channel and Multichannel demonstration disc
Joe Beck & Aly Ryerson -Django
Chris Botti - Night Sessions
The Isley Brother - 3+3 featuring that lady
Alice in Chains - Greatest Hits
Ana Caram - Blue Bossa
Hacken Lee - Live
Celine - All the way, a decade of Songs
DVD-Audio
Christy Byron -Steppin'
Fleetwood Mac -Rumours
Alice Cooper - Welcome to my Nightmare
Alice Cooper - Billion Dollar Babies
Toy Matinee - Toy Matinee
Dave Koz - The Dance
Al Green - Greatest Hits
George Benson - Breezin
Miss E - So Addictive
Foreigner - Foreigner
Foreigner - 4
Carly Simon - No Secret
Joni Mitchel - Both Sides Now
Bird3 - Bird 3
America - Homecoming
Eric Clapton - Reptile
Eric Clapton - Riding with the King
Eagles - Hotel California.
Deep Purple - Machine Head
Inside the Music, New Wave
Inside the Music, Classic Country
Rambient - So Many Worlds
Inside the Music,Women on Top
Natalie Merchant - Tigerlily
Neil Young, Friends & Relatives - Road Rock
K.D. Lang - Invincible Summer
Stone Temple Pilots - Stone Temple Pilots
Aaron Neville - Devotion
Take 6 - Doo Bee Doo Wop Bop
Larisa Stow - Moment by Moment
Willie Nelson - Night and Day
Emerson, Lake & Palmer - Brain Salad Surgery
Studio Voodoo
Barenaked Ladies - Maroon
olivia - One woman's Live Journey
Glen Phillips - Abulum
Steely Dan - Two against nature
David Alan - Live Music
Paul Gilbert - Aligator Farm
Steve Stevens - Flamenco Agogo
Luis Miguel - Romances
DV-S733A is connected to AVC-A1SE by the 6 RCA cables (analogue out in player and analogue in in amp), speakers are 6 Blueroom Minipods (only 5 used in both formats) and a Sunfire Subwoofer in a small bedroom with good acoustics.
DVD Audios are impressive in its immediate expansive sounds and wide dynamic range. In many pop recordings like
Eagles' Hotel California or the 2 Eric Claptons Albums, it has very tight impressive sounds with a lot of amazing details that we have not heard elsewhere.
My general impressions are that good SACD are extremely lush, warm, smooth and sweet, making a generally mid-end
system like this sounds high-end without paying the exhorbitant entrance fee. Nothing sounds smoother and more
realistic than Jacintha's Lush Life, James Taylor's Hourglass or Hacken Lee's Life (3 best recorded SACD, in my opinion). The good tonal qualities of SACD however lacks the required dynamic ranges. In most of the Pop recording, e.g. Alice in Chains (well recorded) or 2 Billy Joel's albums, or Roger Water's In the Flesh (and other SACD), In most SACD the dynamic range felt compressed. while SACD can sounds very good, no albums can be as impressive as the Eagles and Eric Clapton's DVD Audio's detail (I am well aware of SACD's specification of better dynamic range, especially to the sky high frequencies).
The respecitve strengths of both formats become obvious when Christy Byron's Steppin' DVD-Audio and SACD are tried
in the 733A, with the SACD sounding warmer and smoother while (DVDA) with more tonal details and better dynamic range in the DVD Audio version(my Car DVD-Audio shows Chrysty Byron DVD-Audio as a 24bit/48Khz recording, even when the 96Khz track is chosen)
Personally, I think both formats are a great gifts to audiophiles, with SACD of simple audiophile recording (not too complicated, trio and quartet, vocals with cello, piano etc) sonding much better and the DVD Audio of pop and rock recording sounding superior.
Let us hope more and more DVD Audio and SACD will be issued! and left fans of both formats with little to complain.
If anyone wishes to ask questions regarding the hardware setups or my opinions on any of the discs mentioned, please let me know either in this thread or Email me...