Father John A
Stunt Coordinator
- Joined
- Jul 22, 2002
- Messages
- 146
OK, some of you are going to laugh at this and my mistakes but....if it's a bad idea I guess it will just die a quick death.
This thread should be done by a whole slew of individuals more knowledgeable than me, but it hasn't been done and I for one would (will?) find it helpful for a newbie to get started. I will edit out the mistakes as I get corrections. I'll also add technologies I haven't listed yet.
I feel like I'm stepping out on a ledge, but here goes....
RP LCD (Rear Projection LCD):
Pros:
Dollar value
Excellent picture
Good contrast
Good blacks
Decent SD display
Cons:
Bulb life
Size consideration (12+ inches deep)
SSE (Silk Screen Effect)
SDE (Screen Door Effect)
Off angle viewing
RP DLP (Rear Projection DLP)
Pros:
Dollar value
No burn-in
Excellent picture
Good contrast
Good blacks
Decent SD display
Cons:
Bulb life
Size consideration (12+ inches deep)
SSE (Silk Screen Effect)
SDE (Screen Door Effect)
RE (Rainbow effect)
Off angle viewing
May require periodic cleaning of the mirrors due to dust build-up
RP DLP-LED (Rear Projection DLP with LED)
Pros:
No bulb!
No Rainbow Effect
Decent Dollar value
No burn-in
Excellent picture
Decent blacks
Decent SD display
Cons:
Size consideration (12+ inches deep)?
Weak contrast & brightness, not for bright locations
Reported poor color accuracy
SSE (Silk Screen Effect)?
SDE (Screen Door Effect)?
Off angle viewing?
May require periodic cleaning of the mirrors due to dust build-up
LCoS (Liquid Crystal on Silicon)
Pros:
Decent dollar value
Excellent picture
Good contrast
Good blacks
Better SD display
Cons:
Bulb life
Size consideration (12+ inches deep)?
SSE (Silk Screen Effect)
SDE Consideration (Screen Door Effect), marginal at 1080p
Off angle viewing
Possible panel geometry problems in some instances
LCD
Pros:
Flat Screen
Decent Dollar value (getting better)
Good picture
Good contrast
Off angle viewing
Cons:
Average blacks
Motion artifacts
Can suffer from excessive brightness levels
SD display poor
Half-life consideration
Plasma
Pros:
Excellent picture, film like
Flat screen
Good contrast
Excellent blacks
Off angle viewing
Cons:
Dollar value
Possible burn-in (Image Retention), more often reversible now
Half-life consideration
CRT Tubes
Pros:
Excellent on/off CR
Minimal display structure visibility
Resolution flexibility
Relative Value
Cons:
Poor ANSI CR
Size & weight
Phosphor wear
Potential depends heavily on setup, especially with projection CRTs.
Possible geometry issues
Antiquated (most manufacturers phasing out of this arena)
Front projection:
Pros:
Huge dollar value
Huge size potential
Most theater like
Cons:
Room must be light controlled i.e. don't even try it in a well lit room
Mounting can be problematic
Wiring can be problematic
Bulb replacement
Rainbow Effect for DLP projectors (unless they are 3 chippers)
Short Glossary:
SDE - Screen Door Effect: the pixels give the appearance of looking througha screen, especially at close ranges
SSE - Silk Screen Effect: the appearance of a "shimmery" or canvas like quality to the screen, especially notable in bright/white scenes
RE - Rainbow Effect: The potential for the red, green or blue colors of the color wheel in a Single-chip DLP projector to become visible to some individuals, especially in bright scenes.
This thread should be done by a whole slew of individuals more knowledgeable than me, but it hasn't been done and I for one would (will?) find it helpful for a newbie to get started. I will edit out the mistakes as I get corrections. I'll also add technologies I haven't listed yet.
I feel like I'm stepping out on a ledge, but here goes....
RP LCD (Rear Projection LCD):
Pros:
Dollar value
Excellent picture
Good contrast
Good blacks
Decent SD display
Cons:
Bulb life
Size consideration (12+ inches deep)
SSE (Silk Screen Effect)
SDE (Screen Door Effect)
Off angle viewing
RP DLP (Rear Projection DLP)
Pros:
Dollar value
No burn-in
Excellent picture
Good contrast
Good blacks
Decent SD display
Cons:
Bulb life
Size consideration (12+ inches deep)
SSE (Silk Screen Effect)
SDE (Screen Door Effect)
RE (Rainbow effect)
Off angle viewing
May require periodic cleaning of the mirrors due to dust build-up
RP DLP-LED (Rear Projection DLP with LED)
Pros:
No bulb!
No Rainbow Effect
Decent Dollar value
No burn-in
Excellent picture
Decent blacks
Decent SD display
Cons:
Size consideration (12+ inches deep)?
Weak contrast & brightness, not for bright locations
Reported poor color accuracy
SSE (Silk Screen Effect)?
SDE (Screen Door Effect)?
Off angle viewing?
May require periodic cleaning of the mirrors due to dust build-up
LCoS (Liquid Crystal on Silicon)
Pros:
Decent dollar value
Excellent picture
Good contrast
Good blacks
Better SD display
Cons:
Bulb life
Size consideration (12+ inches deep)?
SSE (Silk Screen Effect)
SDE Consideration (Screen Door Effect), marginal at 1080p
Off angle viewing
Possible panel geometry problems in some instances
LCD
Pros:
Flat Screen
Decent Dollar value (getting better)
Good picture
Good contrast
Off angle viewing
Cons:
Average blacks
Motion artifacts
Can suffer from excessive brightness levels
SD display poor
Half-life consideration
Plasma
Pros:
Excellent picture, film like
Flat screen
Good contrast
Excellent blacks
Off angle viewing
Cons:
Dollar value
Possible burn-in (Image Retention), more often reversible now
Half-life consideration
CRT Tubes
Pros:
Excellent on/off CR
Minimal display structure visibility
Resolution flexibility
Relative Value
Cons:
Poor ANSI CR
Size & weight
Phosphor wear
Potential depends heavily on setup, especially with projection CRTs.
Possible geometry issues
Antiquated (most manufacturers phasing out of this arena)
Front projection:
Pros:
Huge dollar value
Huge size potential
Most theater like
Cons:
Room must be light controlled i.e. don't even try it in a well lit room
Mounting can be problematic
Wiring can be problematic
Bulb replacement
Rainbow Effect for DLP projectors (unless they are 3 chippers)
Short Glossary:
SDE - Screen Door Effect: the pixels give the appearance of looking througha screen, especially at close ranges
SSE - Silk Screen Effect: the appearance of a "shimmery" or canvas like quality to the screen, especially notable in bright/white scenes
RE - Rainbow Effect: The potential for the red, green or blue colors of the color wheel in a Single-chip DLP projector to become visible to some individuals, especially in bright scenes.