I did do a search and read all of the posts that related to this question but most seemed quite old and it seems the providers keep changing on a monthly basis. So I appologize for yet another "which service" thread. I just moved into a new place. Before all I had was analog cable and OTA HD. But now I figure it is time to pay for digital cable with HD, or go with a satellite service. From looking at all the packages for everyone I would most likely go with the middle packages, more than the basic, but not every channel in the guide, nor any premiums. I'm also excited to finally get some real HD channels. So far Dish seems to have the most HD, but how is the quality? Hidden costs with satellite? Can I still use my Tivo? I see that everyone offers their own DVR service, but I've added a harddrive to my current Tivo to make it a 50 hour (max quality) DVR so I wouldn't want to lose that. Last requirement is that I need multiroom. HD could just be for one room, but if it is easy to put it into another without much cost I would do that as well. I know I'll use Comcast again for broadband internet, just throwing that out there. Any advice?