moviebuff75
Screenwriter
I'd love to have the original version of "Star Wars" without the Episode IV subtitle
I love the idea of updating the OT but the execution so far has left a lot to be desired. They need to put the same care into it that Blade Runner: The Final Cut got, for example. That said, I'm reasonably happy with my Blu-rays. Most of the general public seems to be as well. How many people who already own the current Blu-rays will shell out again for a "despecialized" edition? I suspect not nearly as many as the hardcore fans would imagine. Particularly anyone 25 and under would be likely to give such a release a big "meh". Sent from my SCH-S738C using HTF mobile appMoe Dickstein said:So I guess I'm one of two people who prefers the new versions huh?
I'm under 25, as are a lot of the people I know who have been clamouring most for the original editions. Just because we're young and didn't see the films in theaters, doesn't mean we don't realise how absolutely idiotic say, the Anakin's ghost change was. I mean, it's right there on the screen. A young, modern day actor appearing as himself in a film from 1983 (when he was actually 2 years old). That's going to set alarm bells off for anyone of any age.Stephen Brooks said:Particularly anyone 25 and under would be likely to give such a release a big "meh".
I prefer some of the changes (the new effects shots in the space battle in Star Wars are great, the fixes to a number of effects in Return Of The Jedi are much better than the original shots) but some are lousy (the oft-cited Greedo shooting first in Star Wars, Vader saying "Nooooo" in Return Of The Jedi). I'm all for George Lucas getting his ever changing vision onscreen but I'd love to see all the versions of the movie available.Moe Dickstein said:So I guess I'm one of two people who prefers the new versions huh?
That change makes more sense than what was in the original movie. Anakin never looked like Sebastian Shaw (with a full head of hair, etc.) but he did look like Hayden Christensen at some point in his life.EddieLarkin said:Just because we're young and didn't see the films in theaters, doesn't mean we don't realise how absolutely idiotic say, the Anakin's ghost change was.
I too am happy enough with the newer versions. They're not perfect, but the original unaltered trilogy also has many weak points, like the human Jabba in Star Wars, the flickering faint white boxes around the green-screen-based space effects, etc. Frankly, I'm also not that bothered about whether Greedo shoots first or not; it is not the sole defining moment of the Han Solo character for me. In fact there's something to be said about Solo reacting in defense rather than coldly initiating deadly violence.Moe Dickstein said:So I guess I'm one of two people who prefers the new versions huh?
It's remarkable what effect a few billion dollars can have on someone's flexibility.TravisR said:I think the real question is can Disney release the originals? If they can, I'm 100% sure they will. When the Disney sale first happened, I figured that George Lucas would have made sure that the deal specified that the SEs would be the only thing that Disney could release but I've softened in that view a little bit.
Yeah, before it was changed, it was just a cool move that Han made and nothing more. Once it was changed, it suddenly became a character defining moment. I dislike that change because I think it looks goofy.Persianimmortal said:Frankly, I'm also not that bothered about whether Greedo shoots first or not; it is not the sole defining moment of the Han Solo character for me.
Sure but Lucas is the one with the product that Disney wanted so he could have also made that stipulation if he wanted to.JoeDoakes said:It's remarkable what effect a few billion dollars can have on someone's flexibility.
Jabba was actually not in the original Star Wars - that was a deleted scene which was inserted into the newer versions.Persianimmortal said:I too am happy enough with the newer versions. They're not perfect, but the original unaltered trilogy also has many weak points, like the human Jabba in Star Wars, the flickering faint white boxes around the green-screen-based space effects, etc. Frankly, I'm also not that bothered about whether Greedo shoots first or not; it is not the sole defining moment of the Han Solo character for me. In fact there's something to be said about Solo reacting in defense rather than coldly initiating deadly violence.
I saw these movies in the theater when I was young, and as magical as they were at the time, I think nostalgia is blinding a lot of people as to the faults of the originals. For me, the original trilogy as it current stands is perfectly fine, and the changes also help to better blend it with the prequels. I have all six movies and I won't be rebuying any of them until they come out in a better format than Blu-ray.
That said, I'm obviously not against the original trilogy being made available for those who want it in its unaltered form, and of course for the sake of history, the original versions should also be archived in the best possible form.