Andrew Bunk
Screenwriter
- Joined
- Nov 2, 2001
- Messages
- 1,825
Hi all,
I've been searching on this topic for a while and I'm having a hard time coming away with a distinct conclusion, so I thought I'd just ask.
I just got my 57H83 this week, I have a progressive scan player set to progressive. My 57H83 is set to Film mode. All the movies I've watched so far look fine.
I was just watching the Simpsons Treehouse of Horror DVD, and I noticed what matches the description of "combing" on three episodes. Oddly enough, the fourth episode, which is from 2001, did not have this issue.
I switched the 57H83 from Film to Video and saw no difference. I then set the player to interlaced, and the combing went away in both Film and Video mode.
Same thing with Babylon 5 on DVD. While the combing wasn't as evident, whenever the camera panned or someone moved fast, it seemed very "jerky", to put it in a non-scientific term.
I again switched the player to interlaced, and this helped dramatically. I assume that this means Babylon 5 was also sourced from video rather than film.
So far, in either progressive or interlaced mode on my player, I have yet to see the Film or Video settings produce any noticeable different on the TV. Very strange.
I'm trying to come to grips with the exact chain of events here. I've read that by leaving the player on progressive, the player is doing the 3:2 pulldown. If on interlaced, the set does the pulldown. I've also read this has to do with whether or not the source is film or video based. I got the impression that there should be some sort of auto detection for this, but it would seem like that's not happening.
Is there any hard and fast rule for determining the best modes to use with the Toshibas? Do all TV shows on DVD tend to have this issue as many are video rather than film based?
If there are any web docs or faq's on this please post a link.
Thanks!
Andrew
I've been searching on this topic for a while and I'm having a hard time coming away with a distinct conclusion, so I thought I'd just ask.
I just got my 57H83 this week, I have a progressive scan player set to progressive. My 57H83 is set to Film mode. All the movies I've watched so far look fine.
I was just watching the Simpsons Treehouse of Horror DVD, and I noticed what matches the description of "combing" on three episodes. Oddly enough, the fourth episode, which is from 2001, did not have this issue.
I switched the 57H83 from Film to Video and saw no difference. I then set the player to interlaced, and the combing went away in both Film and Video mode.
Same thing with Babylon 5 on DVD. While the combing wasn't as evident, whenever the camera panned or someone moved fast, it seemed very "jerky", to put it in a non-scientific term.
I again switched the player to interlaced, and this helped dramatically. I assume that this means Babylon 5 was also sourced from video rather than film.
So far, in either progressive or interlaced mode on my player, I have yet to see the Film or Video settings produce any noticeable different on the TV. Very strange.
I'm trying to come to grips with the exact chain of events here. I've read that by leaving the player on progressive, the player is doing the 3:2 pulldown. If on interlaced, the set does the pulldown. I've also read this has to do with whether or not the source is film or video based. I got the impression that there should be some sort of auto detection for this, but it would seem like that's not happening.
Is there any hard and fast rule for determining the best modes to use with the Toshibas? Do all TV shows on DVD tend to have this issue as many are video rather than film based?
If there are any web docs or faq's on this please post a link.
Thanks!
Andrew