Adam Lenhardt
Senior HTF Member
I just got back from seeing it at a sold out show. I continue to hate assigned seating; even though we were there an hour before the showtime, we ended up having to sit in the bottom section, craning our necks up at the screen. Meanwhile, the stadium seating is only three-quarters full when the movie started, with the remainder of the audience trickling in during the first 10-15 minutes of the movie.
That NEVER used to happen with big movies before assigned seating. You waited in line, had a nice communal experience, and the people who showed up first got the best seats.
But the movie itself I enjoyed quite a bit; I'd put it near the top of the second-tier Marvel movies.
With special resonance for Monica of course, because she knows Carol and can see herself in Carol in a way that wouldn't resonate the same with Superman.
This looked like a nineties mid-budget blockbuster, which is probably just what the doctor ordered.
That NEVER used to happen with big movies before assigned seating. You waited in line, had a nice communal experience, and the people who showed up first got the best seats.
But the movie itself I enjoyed quite a bit; I'd put it near the top of the second-tier Marvel movies.
Captain Marvel largely takes place in 1995. No, Fury couldn't have known that Captain Marvel would survive Thanos's universe-wide culling. But he had 50/50 odds, so it was worth making the attempt.Yes, and if that's true, CM must take place largely BEFORE that moment. From the first moment I saw Fury send that distress call, I assumed CM was somewhere untouched by what Thanos did. Then again, Fury had no grasp of the 50% obliteration.
It was a beautiful tribute. Lots of "awwww"s in my audience.Be sure to pay attention to the opening Marvel Studios logo as it is completely different than it is in the other Marvel films.
Agreed. Stole every scene it was in.The Cat is awesome.
I thought they did an excellent job with Samuel L. Jackson; I never even noticed the effect. Coulson on the other hand did have a bit of that weird uncanny valley effect that we've seen with previous applications of that de-aging technology. Partly I think that's because they didn't try to capture what Clark Gregg actually looked like in 1995; instead they tried to capture what they thought Coulson would have looked like in 1995 -- much more g-man than Gregg looked back then.I disagree with the critics raving about the de-aging technology being excellent as it largely looks like it does when excessive DNR is applied and the people look like wax.
It wouldn't surprise me if the mid credit scene was lifted directly from End Game.
I think that's exactly what they did, much like Coulson in New Mexico at the end of Iron Man 2. There's no way the contemporary re-introduction of Captain Marvel only occurs in a mid-credits sequence scene. The cinematography also matched similar scenes in the Endgame trailer.
I did too, and the trailers and TV spots didn't lead me to think I would. Carol Danvers has a dry sense of humor that came off as flat out of context but plays beautifully in the film itself. Her and Samuel L. Jackson have a wonderful buddy cop movie chemistry in their scenes together. They've worked together on other projects as well, and you can really tell that they enjoy each other's company.I did think Brie Larson was fantastic though. I loved her performance.
I know you're kidding, but:Liked it, it was ok. Regarding the cat:
Are we sure the final after credits is in the 90s, not Endgame timeline? =p
We know it takes place before 2012, because the tesseract is out of the cat and in S.H.I.E.L.D.'s custody when the first Avengers movie begins. This movie essentially fills in the blanks between Stark retrieving the tesseract from the ocean floor at the end of Captain America: The First Avenger and the events of The Avengers.
Aside from the Guardians of the Galaxy movies and Thor: Ragnarok that were essentially action comedies, this was among the most fun of the Marvel movies, and took itself among the least seriously.Also, the film had plenty of humor throughout the film so I don't understand that criticism by some outside posted review that it needed more humor.
I thought Larson was solid the entire way through, but those scenes were her best. Akira Akbar was wonderful as eleven-year-old Monica, and Larson's performance softened when Carol and Monica shared the screen together. Even after a six-year separation, you can feel how much these two adore each other.I loved that she showed many sides of Carol. She made the friendships with Maria and Monica real.
Captain Marvel is basically the MCU's Superman and that moment captured the awe of being in the presence of Superman when he does something extraordinary.When Monica sees Carol zoom off into the sky, it's like the moment when Picard's nephew dreams of captaining a starship in The Next Generation. Thrilling.
With special resonance for Monica of course, because she knows Carol and can see herself in Carol in a way that wouldn't resonate the same with Superman.
Loved Ben Mendleson. Everything that's been said about him stealing his scenes is true. So nice not to have a mustache-twirling villain.
His performance is so likable, and then when the big twist is revealed, it makes sense why he's so likable: because he's not really the bad guy.
So many songs that I heard way too many times on the radio in the nineties.Nice soundtrack too (now, release it, Disney!).
That was a very effective beat, that did a nice job of tying this movie into the larger mythology of the MCU.Also loved Fury's scene whenhe notices that Carol's callsign was "Avenger." Just brilliant.
That was great. One of my few criticisms is that I wished the movie had been more ambitious with the nonlinear storytelling. I would have liked more and longer scenes from Carol's childhood, and her time in the Air Force.I hope every little girl - and little boy - sees this and remembers that small montage of scenes where Carol keeps getting up and doesn't quit.
The story went to some unexpected places (for me anyway, this may be old hat to fans of the original comics).
Making the Kree the bad guys and the Skrulls the good guys was a Mandarin-level twist, but in keeping with the backstory of the Kree-Skrull war from the comics, in which the Skrulls were a fairly peaceful mercantile civilization that expanded its reach through commerce, and the Kree were vicious barbarians.
In the case of this movie, I was expecting the twist just based on what I'd seen in the trailers, and the fact that the Kree were the primary antagonists for the most recent season of "Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D."
In the case of this movie, I was expecting the twist just based on what I'd seen in the trailers, and the fact that the Kree were the primary antagonists for the most recent season of "Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D."
That might have been my favorite moment of the entire movie. Just perfect.Loved LOVED Stan Lee’s 90’s era cameo.
Hilarious!!!
It's probably in the bottom third of the MCU movies for me in terms of cinematography, but it's definitely the best looking MCU movie shot by Davis. I thought the first Guardians of the Galaxy was too garish, and his other movies were dreary and, as you say, dull.Ben Davis was the cinematographer, and the visual palette wasn’t as dreadfully dull as the one he used for Avengers: Age Of Ultron and Doctot Strange, thankfully.
This looked like a nineties mid-budget blockbuster, which is probably just what the doctor ordered.
The pacing for the first third of the movie was pretty rough. Everything from Pegasus on played smoothly for me, though.I thought pacing was off - I checked my watch a bunch of times and that normally doesn’t happen with MCU movies.
The weird thing is that this is essentially a prequel to Endgame, even though it came out first. Larson shot all of her scenes for Endgame before they even had a locked script for this. So even though this is an origin movie that introduces the character to the MCU, the writers had to reverse engineer the character as portrayed in Endgame. So Larson didn't have the luxury of building on what worked and avoiding what didn't work on this movie for Endgame.Here’s the thing, though - I bet I’ll love Captain Marvel in Avengers: Endgame. The writers and directors for Endgame have been so good at developing characters in this universe and making me care for them, and I think they’ll be able to bring out whatever was missing in the solo movie.
My preliminary ranking puts it 11th out of 20. It didn't really do anything especially daring or groundbreaking, but it did the same old things about as good as one could hope for.I thought Captain Marvel was fantastic. Not tier 1 (which for me includes Iron Man, Winter Solder, Guardians 1, Infinity War, Ragnarok), but solidly at the tier 2 rank for me. I would give it a solid 8 or 8.5 out of 10.
Movies I love:
- Avengers: Infinity War
- Marvel's The Avengers
- Captain America: The First Avenger
- Captain America: The Winter Soldier
- Thor: Ragnarok
- Black Panther
- Iron Man 2
- Iron Man
Movies That I Really Like:
- Guardians of the Galaxy
- Ant-Man
- Captain Marvel
- Captain America: Civil War
- Spider-Man: Homecoming
- Iron Man 3
Movies That Are Fine:
- Thor
- Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2
- Avengers: Age of Ultron
- Doctor Strange
Movies I Disliked:
- The Incredible Hulk
- Thor: The Dark World
One thing that I appreciated is that they didn't waste any time on fish out of water jokes. She was a highly trained special forces soldier from an advanced extraterrestrial civilization. She might not remember her time on Earth, but she would still competently pursue her objectives.The audience is meant to be many steps ahead of Carol. Usually this gets old quickly, the audience shouting at the screen over how stupid the main character is. Here, however, her rediscovery was not belaboured.
I loved the tip of the hat to the Superman movies, with Carol suspended over Earth. I also loved:I also thought the movie struck a few nice emotional chords. During the final space sequence where Carol is smashing through the missiles--her powers on full display (just shy of going binary)--I was oddly moved by the thought that "damn, maybe the heroes do have a hope against Thanos..."
Her Raiders of the Lost Ark moment, when Jude Law's character is trying to goad her into a fist fight and she instead proton blasts him.