If you have a problem with a Universal product, take it up with them. Don't just pass the problem on to an unsuspecting third party. Didn't we all learn the Golden Rule in Kindergarten? This has been a well-known problem for a number of years. Identical threads pop up on a near monthly basis. The outrage has long since died as Universal has acknowledged the problem and replaced the discs upon request. As I noted, many stores will do same title exchanges without a receipt, especially if it's a defective title. Why you would want to bother with the hassle of an Ebay auction when you can make a 5-minute exchange at the local store is beyond me.