What's new

Burns & Allen TV Show best DVD? (1 Viewer)

Chas_Michael

Second Unit
Joined
Dec 12, 2000
Messages
441
any opinions on the best quality (with commercials, if possible included) Burns & Allen TV Show, and The Jack Benny Show on DVD?
 

Jeff#

Screenwriter
Joined
Jan 29, 2005
Messages
1,942
The video quality on those TV releases is generally fair because they are all public domain copies. Great sitcoms like The Jack Benny Program and The George Burns & Gracie Allen Show deserve first-class treatment, but on video they just never got it.

Ironically the radio versions of many Benny and Burns & Allen shows from the 1930s, 40s, and 50s are generally very good to excellent. The poorly-quality recordings are in the minority for both series. If you should download any of George & Gracie's episodes, they changed the show along with their sponsors a few times over the years. Originally they had a variety show with mostly banter between the regulars and the sketches were few and far between. It wasn't until 1942 (when Maxwell House became their sponsor for many years) that they permanently changed into the sitcom format which actually worked much better for them. Although some of the supporting cast changed, that would be the same form that would carry over to TV late in 1950.

Jack Benny's writers, meanwhile, took about 4 years to finally create the stingy character that was a reverse parody of himself. His early shows prior to that (1932 to 1936, before bandleader Phil Harris joined) are painful to listen to and not particularly funny because there are no self-deprecating jokes or witty insult humor that became Benny show trademarks.

Fortunately, audio sound recording technology improved a lot by 1936 and his format was solidified for the next 29 years, although the more talented Dennis Day didn't replace Kenny Baker (who went to work for Fred Allen) until 1939.
 

docdoowop

Second Unit
Joined
Aug 20, 2006
Messages
275
Real Name
Curt
Personally, I'd avoid Passport's 5-disc "George Burns & Gracie Allen Collection". Atrocious quality and highly over-packaged. Only two shows per disc, so it also takes up a good amount of space.

I do recommend the Madacy "Jack Benny Collection". Decent quality for a PD release, and 24 episodes on five DVDs. The recently released "Best of Jack Benny" from Mill Creek is similar in quality and offers 40 episodes on 4 discs.
 

odious_m

Auditioning
Joined
Feb 3, 2008
Messages
4
Real Name
Bill Cox
I own the "Best of Jack Benny" from Mill Creek and can highly recommend it. Of course the elements are very old and there are many kinescopes (filmed directly off television screens). But it is entirely watchable and very enjoyable. At around 10 dollars, quite a bargain.

I also have the Goodtimes release of "Best of Burns & Allen," consisting of 4 double sided discs. It's also very good.

BTW, both sets include many of the original commercials.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Forum Sponsors

Latest Articles

Forum statistics

Threads
351,892
Messages
4,968,596
Members
143,137
Latest member
ZeppelinDude93
Recent bookmarks
0
Top