What's new

Building A Home Theater? Start Here. (1 Viewer)

Bob Bielski

Second Unit
Joined
May 29, 2016
Messages
484
Location
MA.
Real Name
Robert Bielski
I just want to know if the sound would improve mounting the speakers with the tweeters closer to the walls, to get reflections off the walls and increase the sense of space, or with the tweeters all together into the center of the room. My first guess would be tweeters on the outside of the 4 speaker circle, but before I make a grave mistake maybe someone with acoustic training could shed some light on the proper set up and explain why one way is better than the other. Brian your forum is so thorough with information that I thought this bit of information might help others as well as me. Thanks for continually adding to the treasure of information for the entire site, very much appreciated.
 

JohnRice

Bounded In a Nutshell
Supporter
Ambassador
Senior HTF Member
Joined
Jun 20, 2000
Messages
15,497
Location
A Mile High
Real Name
John
I have a general question. I am winding down on my home construction and almost ready to attempt to ceiling mount very large speakers in an Atmos system. I know it is overkill to many but I want the best sound I can get. I have ADS L1290/2 speakers, 5 of them ear level and want to mount 4 on the ceiling to match. These are rather large for ceiling mounts but Dolby states that the best sound comes from total matching of all speakers. All the channels, and I know it is object based not channels, but all speakers receive full bandwidth signals and to put small speakers that are different on the ceiling is not the best way to go sound wise.
My question is should I mount them with the tweeters all pointing to the center of the room, or the woofers towards the center? I know high frequencies beam straight down and was wondering if the spatial qualities would sound better with the tweeters on the outer side near the walls to get some reflections off the walls.
I am not an acoustic engineer and don't want to have to experiment using both setups, tweeters in and tweeters out to hear the difference, since these are heavy and it would be a pain in the ass. Not sure if Dolby would comment or not. The speakers are the usual set up for a three way, with double woofers on the bottom then the midrange then the tweeter on top when standing upright on the floor. Any input would be greatly appreciated. I will post my findings and pictures when the project is complete. Thanks ahead of time to all and Happy New year to Brian.
Interesting.

My main thought is about phase problems and orienting the speakers (as close as possible) to how they are designed, relative to the listener. The drivers, especially the tweeter and midrange, are suppose to be spaced perpendicular to your ears to avoid phase problems in the crossover range. In other words, they are spaced vertically, because your ears are spaced horizontally. There's a reason for that due to the distance between your ears, when those drivers are spaced vertically, both drivers reach both ears at the same time. So, my point is, I suspect the best orientation is for the speakers to be oriented front to back of the room, not side to side.

Have you considered that despite the logic you're using, you intend to use the speakers for a radically different installation than they are designed for? They simply aren't designed to be installed on a ceiling, and their driver layout it is not created for that use. Depending on the height of the ceiling, I can envision the results just not being exactly ideal.
 

Brian Dobbs

Ambassador
Joined
Jul 1, 2001
Messages
1,354
Location
Maryland
Real Name
Brian Dobbs
Let's take just two of these speakers, say for a front row. If you were to mount them tweeter in, is there sufficient space between the tweeters so that there is some semblance of separation? If so, then go that way. I'm not a fan of reflections that make the sound difficult to localize.

If you have to go tweeter out, then I would say install some sound dampening near the speaker on the wall closest to it so that you minimize reflections.

https://www.hometheaterforum.com/co...-home-theater-start-here.334769/#post-4204566
 

Bob Bielski

Second Unit
Joined
May 29, 2016
Messages
484
Location
MA.
Real Name
Robert Bielski
Both responses are very interesting. John I was unaware of the phase issue. Maybe I should build custom cabinets like my center channel, using all OEM crossovers and drivers, making the cabinets TS parameter correct, and do woofer mid tweeter woofer as a layout. I have several options to get it done but wish I got the proper information from someone trained in acoustics before I commit. I have ARC for room correction and I am sure it may correct some phase issues but it works better with correct layout.
Brian the ceiling is 8 feet high and I would be willing to pay a contractor to recess the cabinets into the ceiling. My empty attic is above. There is plenty of space to maintain separation.
And John I always trust your judgement as I have seen many posts helping others with accurate information, but please clarify what front to back not side to side of the room relates to the seating position. Unfortunately my living room is my theater room and instead of the proper way of setting up, long length speakers placement, it is set up short length because one end has a big picture window. I have to compromise in order for the room to function. I have to do some research, but I am sure this issue has been addressed by now since object based surround has been out long enough. Thanks for the info from both of you gentlemen.
 

JohnRice

Bounded In a Nutshell
Supporter
Ambassador
Senior HTF Member
Joined
Jun 20, 2000
Messages
15,497
Location
A Mile High
Real Name
John
Bob, think about it this way. From the perspective of the viewer, the tweeter and midrange should be vertical not horizontal. This is really getting into the weeds of sonics, but when certain frequencies come from two sources, especially when they're close together, they tend to cancel themselves out when the two sources are horizontally spaced. This is because there is a crossover between the sound from each source to each ear. Anyway, it's why midranges and tweeters are always aligned vertically to each other, but not necessarily directly above woofers.

From what I can tell, the most important aspect of Atmos speakers is that they have wide dispersion. They're supposed to, ideally, be in the ceiling, aimed straight down. So, the wide dispersion eliminates the need to aim them. Think of the sound of rain hitting a roof. That is what Atmos is designed to reproduce. The sound of the rain isn't directed at you, so it sounds a little different when you are directly under it than it does if it's in front of or behind you. That's what Atmos is trying to reproduce. At least, that's a way of looking at it. So, it seems to me that the ideal Atmos speaker design probably has coincident tweeter and midrange (with 3-way) and extremely wide dispersion.
 

Bob Bielski

Second Unit
Joined
May 29, 2016
Messages
484
Location
MA.
Real Name
Robert Bielski
Most of the layouts have the height speakers directly above the front L and R and surround L and R. My speakers have a wide dispersion pattern the mids and tweeters are domes, and I just got off the Dolby site and sent them my inquiry about whether or not to aim the tweeters in or out and whether to change the driver layout to woofer mid tweeter woofer or not. I hope they will let me know. Some sites suggest wall mounting half way up the wall from floor standers to the ceiling. You would think by now they have hard and fast rules with explanations as to why.
 

JohnRice

Bounded In a Nutshell
Supporter
Ambassador
Senior HTF Member
Joined
Jun 20, 2000
Messages
15,497
Location
A Mile High
Real Name
John
Most of the layouts have the height speakers directly above the front L and R and surround L and R.
In line with them, yes, but I find an awful lot of people locate them on the wall or on/in the ceiling far too close to the wall, or directly over the viewers' heads.

You've probably seen THIS from Dolby, which shows that they should be in line with the front speakers, and roughly 45 degrees in front of and behind the viewer.
 

Bob Bielski

Second Unit
Joined
May 29, 2016
Messages
484
Location
MA.
Real Name
Robert Bielski
Just an update on my research for heavy duty ceiling mounts. I have bumped into a company that supplies commercial installers, and they have a bracket that looks very heavy duty. I had to register in order to buy and now I am waiting for an approval. I have done a lot of reading and what I have gathered is that reflections are not advised from the height speakers. The brackets that I have my eye on can swivel and tilt. I will leave the link, and will update with new information as I have some. Hopefully this will help other DIYs who are crazy enough to mount floorstanders on their ceilings LOL.
http://www.zuummedia.com/
 

Jeffreybomb

Stunt Coordinator
Joined
Dec 7, 2010
Messages
61
Real Name
Jeff
If it is not possible to do so, the use of isolation clips and resilient channel are the next best thing.

Our home theater is being built in the basement. I think the room-within-a-room build would be overkill, since the basement doesn't see nearly the amount of use as the ground floor.

However, I'd like to keep the noise from getting through drywall and joists in the ceiling. Would I benefit from mounting drywall on resilient channel around the entire room, or would it only really be beneficial if I installed it in the ceiling and attached the drywall to the wall studs as normal?

I would assume I'd need resilient channel around the entire room, but I've been surprised before.
 
Last edited:

Bob Bielski

Second Unit
Joined
May 29, 2016
Messages
484
Location
MA.
Real Name
Robert Bielski
I would just do the ceiling with resilient channel and double drywall, like quiet rock. The walls I assume are concrete since it is the basement. How high is the ceiling? Also I would stuff the cavity between the joists with Rockwool, https://www.rockwool.com/?utm_sourc...oppKW3HYvunRHyHcV7yA14bcEqRJaCvUaAg-WEALw_wcB
I would also put a nice thick rug in the room above the theater. There is a material called Acoustibloc I hope the spelling is close enough, and you could put that down first, then a pad, then a nice super thick rug and with all that you should be good. I used safe and sound but if you have the room or the depth in between the joists I would go with a higher R factor, that is the same stuff as safe and sound just a lot thicker thus better sound reduction. Good luck and let the forum know how you make out. And please post some pics for everyone.
 

Brian Dobbs

Ambassador
Joined
Jul 1, 2001
Messages
1,354
Location
Maryland
Real Name
Brian Dobbs
Our home theater is being built in the basement. I think the room-within-a-room build would be overkill, since the basement doesn't see nearly the amount of use as the ground floor.
The question is, would anyone potentially be walking around above the home theater while you're in there? Wife who stomps around? Kids? Dogs? My neighbor across the street has mentioned a number of times how his ceiling-mounted projector always needs realignment after his kids upstairs stomp around directly above.

If you truly want to minimize noise pollution, mechanical separation should not be considered overkill, but rather paramount. I have a room within a room, plus mass loaded vinyl, plus cellulose insulation and I can still hear activity upstairs.

If there is wood that is screwed to other wood, even just with one screw, and that wood is part of a wall, you will hear noise from upstairs.

If you can't mechanically separate the rooms, then you'll definitely need resilient channel everywhere, insulation, MLV (Acoustiblok) and the special sound dampening drywall.
 

Brian Dobbs

Ambassador
Joined
Jul 1, 2001
Messages
1,354
Location
Maryland
Real Name
Brian Dobbs
How well does Acoustiblock work with blocking out low bass frequencies?
https://www.acoustiblok.com/acoustiblok-noise-solutions/

Think of it this way. The more mass you can add to a wall, the better. Mass loaded vinyl turns sound waves into heat. It's just one tool in the bucket. A 1-2 foot thick wall filled with sand would be even more effective, but let's not get carried away...;)

p.s. more power to you if you choose to do this.
 

Bob Bielski

Second Unit
Joined
May 29, 2016
Messages
484
Location
MA.
Real Name
Robert Bielski
This one goes out to you Brian. i remember discussing room acoustics with you and complaining about the boom in the room. Many reasons, but I brought up https://isoacoustics.com/ and you added the information to your vast collection and we all benefit from that.
I was just surfing along on YouTube and came across this video and it seems like the same kind of product. i haven't navigated to their website as of yet, the night is young, but the vid is so simple and informative kind of in your face with the science, I just had to share it in this forum. These platforms seem to be a good way to make the sound clearer. The pursuit of better and better. It is but a tiny bit of information back at you Brian, compared to the library of info on the forum. I will always try to pay you back for the help and time you saved me in making my theater sound as good as it can, and as good as i can afford to make it sound LOl. I hope you enjoy the information half as much as i did.





 

Brian Dobbs

Ambassador
Joined
Jul 1, 2001
Messages
1,354
Location
Maryland
Real Name
Brian Dobbs
This one goes out to you Brian. i remember discussing room acoustics with you and complaining about the boom in the room. Many reasons, but I brought up https://isoacoustics.com/ and you added the information to your vast collection and we all benefit from that.
I was just surfing along on YouTube and came across this video and it seems like the same kind of product. i haven't navigated to their website as of yet, the night is young, but the vid is so simple and informative kind of in your face with the science, I just had to share it in this forum. These platforms seem to be a good way to make the sound clearer. The pursuit of better and better. It is but a tiny bit of information back at you Brian, compared to the library of info on the forum. I will always try to pay you back for the help and time you saved me in making my theater sound as good as it can, and as good as i can afford to make it sound LOl. I hope you enjoy the information half as much as i did.
Wow, this is great! I might get these podiums!
 

Bob Bielski

Second Unit
Joined
May 29, 2016
Messages
484
Location
MA.
Real Name
Robert Bielski
Been a long while Brian, but after the daughter moving home with a new addition to the family in the shape of a granddaughter, everything has been on hold. I have since got my hands on another 2 pairs of my model speakers. I have just reached out to 4 different fabricators to make custom ceiling mounts for me. At 75 lbs I figured I might as well draw what I need on paper. Have total swivel both ways to aim the front pair at the seating position, and the rear pair I am going to aim straight down. Both will be tweeter in towards the middle of the room. I will follow the Atmos guidelines and position them according to their suggestions. I will post pics when it is done. After this is done I can concentrate on tube traps for the corners. Never ends, and thanks for starting this post. Hope you are healthy and safe. Crazy times we live in lately.
 

Brian Dobbs

Ambassador
Joined
Jul 1, 2001
Messages
1,354
Location
Maryland
Real Name
Brian Dobbs
Been a long while Brian, but after the daughter moving home with a new addition to the family in the shape of a granddaughter, everything has been on hold. I have since got my hands on another 2 pairs of my model speakers. I have just reached out to 4 different fabricators to make custom ceiling mounts for me. At 75 lbs I figured I might as well draw what I need on paper. Have total swivel both ways to aim the front pair at the seating position, and the rear pair I am going to aim straight down. Both will be tweeter in towards the middle of the room. I will follow the Atmos guidelines and position them according to their suggestions. I will post pics when it is done. After this is done I can concentrate on tube traps for the corners. Never ends, and thanks for starting this post. Hope you are healthy and safe. Crazy times we live in lately.
Hey Bob, I was just thinking about your ceiling mounts! Glad to hear they are still in progress. Can't wait to see photos. Have you listened to any of the episodes of the HTF podcast I've been doing with Sam?
 

Bob Bielski

Second Unit
Joined
May 29, 2016
Messages
484
Location
MA.
Real Name
Robert Bielski
Hey Brian! I was unaware of them. Now that I know I will tune in. How do I get to the podcasts?
I got my first response back from one of the three fabricators that I asked for a quote. I will keep the forum posted and this will be a nice addition to the thread. Can't wait to catch one of your podcasts. Stay safe Brian and once again thanks for this thread that has no doubt helped thousands from all over the world. :popcorn:
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Forum Sponsors

Latest Articles

Forum statistics

Threads
349,550
Messages
4,883,959
Members
142,617
Latest member
StreetPreacher
Recent bookmarks
0
Top