Scott McGillivray
Supporting Actor
- Joined
- Sep 20, 1999
- Messages
- 932
Hi Gang!
Growing up, I was a big fan of comics. In my teens I was able to read the Frank Miller 4-part epic "Batman: The Dark Knight Returns". This was, for me, a defining story in my life. I have read those over and over again. The pacing, the mood, the philosophy and politics...it was all there and it was all engrossing. I tried to get others to read it and see what brilliance lay in these pages.
So, when I saw that they were bringing it out as an animated feature, I was very excited...and nervous.
I am happy to say that this is a very good adaptation, so far, of the books. They have taken the 4 books and made them into 2 movies. Part 1 really does nail the mood and effect of the graphic novels. The animation is spot-on. It looks very much like the comic, but enhanced enough to make it modern and very watchable. The script changes are minimal and I can see where they were necessary in transferring this to a movie. I really did miss hearing the inner monologue of Batman/Bruce. There is absolute gold in some of those and people that only watch the animated movie are missing out.
My disappointment is in the voice acting. I dont have a problem with Peter Weller playing the part, but in how he and others deliver some of their lines. He still sounds "robotic" in some scenes. I half expected him to say "Dead or alive creep...your coming with me." Granted, that may be due to the fact that I KNOW it is Robocop saying the lines or it may just be that it doesnt match up to the voice I heard in my head as I read this book so many times. Still, I think several actors have been directed to REALLY over enunciate their lines. It just makes it come across too much like they are reading their script as opposed to being in the moment.
Still, I highly recommend seeing this. It is a lot of fun. But if you havent read the graphic novels, do yourself the favour and run out to get a copy. Simply the best Batman material on the market.
4 out of 5 stars.
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt2313197/
Growing up, I was a big fan of comics. In my teens I was able to read the Frank Miller 4-part epic "Batman: The Dark Knight Returns". This was, for me, a defining story in my life. I have read those over and over again. The pacing, the mood, the philosophy and politics...it was all there and it was all engrossing. I tried to get others to read it and see what brilliance lay in these pages.
So, when I saw that they were bringing it out as an animated feature, I was very excited...and nervous.
I am happy to say that this is a very good adaptation, so far, of the books. They have taken the 4 books and made them into 2 movies. Part 1 really does nail the mood and effect of the graphic novels. The animation is spot-on. It looks very much like the comic, but enhanced enough to make it modern and very watchable. The script changes are minimal and I can see where they were necessary in transferring this to a movie. I really did miss hearing the inner monologue of Batman/Bruce. There is absolute gold in some of those and people that only watch the animated movie are missing out.
My disappointment is in the voice acting. I dont have a problem with Peter Weller playing the part, but in how he and others deliver some of their lines. He still sounds "robotic" in some scenes. I half expected him to say "Dead or alive creep...your coming with me." Granted, that may be due to the fact that I KNOW it is Robocop saying the lines or it may just be that it doesnt match up to the voice I heard in my head as I read this book so many times. Still, I think several actors have been directed to REALLY over enunciate their lines. It just makes it come across too much like they are reading their script as opposed to being in the moment.
Still, I highly recommend seeing this. It is a lot of fun. But if you havent read the graphic novels, do yourself the favour and run out to get a copy. Simply the best Batman material on the market.
4 out of 5 stars.
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt2313197/