Not at all. However, there are two threads designated for format war talk, and this isn't one of them. I originally recommended this thread be closed because there was already one opened on this very subject, and I knew it would be impossible to discuss it without straying into the format war. The original thread was beaten to death, just as this one is being, with the same predictable results. Do you really think you are contributing any new insights here with respect to why these titles are being withheld on BD? I've come to enjoy having format war talk restricted to two threads. It reduces clutter and the membership tends to get along better outside those threads when we talk about the HDM we actually can buy and enjoy. The mods seem to be willing to give us some rope with posts that touch on the format war, though I'm never surprised by our knack for hanging ourselves with it.