John P Grosskopf
Second Unit
- Joined
- Jan 21, 2001
- Messages
- 313
How does everyone feel about Anchor Bay's continued DVD difficulties, which seem to have become more like a string of bad luck than simple quality control issues.
It started with the missing audio channel on the Black Hole and went downhill from there.
The latest problem with DVD content is on their Timerider DVD. Here is the e-mail I sent them and the response received regarding the issue:
quote: I just bought your Timerider DVD, and was horified to find that it has a missing few seconds at the film's climax, totally ruining the end of the film.
Spoiler:Originally, Peter Coyote's character is killed when the tail rotor of the helicopter chops him up, leaving only bloody boots. On your DVD, stock footage of Peter Coyote ducking to the ground replaces the death and bloody boots, while the soundtrack plays the out the death (including nasty squishing noises of the rotors slicing through Peter Coyote's body).
To make matters worse, the director's commentary refers to the Spoiler:death scene, so when William Dear was recording the commentary, he WAS watching the correct version, not the incorrect one on your DVD.
The total end of the movie (part of its set-piece) is now destroyed. I cannot watch it, having to go back to my well worn laserdisc to see the correct ending. Had I known this, I would not have purchased the DVD in the first place.
What gives? This is the second or third time I've bought a disc from your company that has similar problems.
I used to love hearing announcements that Anchor Bay was giving a disc the Special Edition treatment. Now when I hear the announcements, I wonder if it is going to have production problems. [/quote]
The reply from Anchor Bay:
quote: To: [email protected]
Subject: Re: Questions from ABE Website
The print used for TIMERIDER was the only existing print left for use. Michael Nesmith searched worldwide for elements for TIMERIDER, however both the domestic and International releasing companies for the film had gone bankrupt long ago, and the original negative has been lost.
This was his only remaining print from his vault. Apparently a slight change had been made to the ending on his print, for reasons no one can recall. Unfortunately this is, like I said, the only remaining print left for the film that was usable. The title had actually been delayed
for six months because we couldn't find audio for it. [/quote]
Okay, this is a very reasonable explanation, however, it does not explain director William Dear's commentary refering to the correct ending (I assume he was watching the film as the commentary was being recorded). Also, knowing in advance that their print was not the theatrical cut, why didn't Anchor Bay put some kind of disclaimer on the packaging pointing that out.
At the very least Anchor Bay could have been up front about the deletion/substitution. Footage from the laserdisc (or video master of the LD) could have been added as a supplement or through seemless branching (actually non-seemless branching due to source differences) to explain the problem.
Thoughts?
[Edited last by John P Grosskopf on October 31, 2001 at 11:09 AM]
[Edited last by John P Grosskopf on October 31, 2001 at 11:16 AM]
It started with the missing audio channel on the Black Hole and went downhill from there.
The latest problem with DVD content is on their Timerider DVD. Here is the e-mail I sent them and the response received regarding the issue:
quote: I just bought your Timerider DVD, and was horified to find that it has a missing few seconds at the film's climax, totally ruining the end of the film.
Spoiler:Originally, Peter Coyote's character is killed when the tail rotor of the helicopter chops him up, leaving only bloody boots. On your DVD, stock footage of Peter Coyote ducking to the ground replaces the death and bloody boots, while the soundtrack plays the out the death (including nasty squishing noises of the rotors slicing through Peter Coyote's body).
To make matters worse, the director's commentary refers to the Spoiler:death scene, so when William Dear was recording the commentary, he WAS watching the correct version, not the incorrect one on your DVD.
The total end of the movie (part of its set-piece) is now destroyed. I cannot watch it, having to go back to my well worn laserdisc to see the correct ending. Had I known this, I would not have purchased the DVD in the first place.
What gives? This is the second or third time I've bought a disc from your company that has similar problems.
I used to love hearing announcements that Anchor Bay was giving a disc the Special Edition treatment. Now when I hear the announcements, I wonder if it is going to have production problems. [/quote]
The reply from Anchor Bay:
quote: To: [email protected]
Subject: Re: Questions from ABE Website
The print used for TIMERIDER was the only existing print left for use. Michael Nesmith searched worldwide for elements for TIMERIDER, however both the domestic and International releasing companies for the film had gone bankrupt long ago, and the original negative has been lost.
This was his only remaining print from his vault. Apparently a slight change had been made to the ending on his print, for reasons no one can recall. Unfortunately this is, like I said, the only remaining print left for the film that was usable. The title had actually been delayed
for six months because we couldn't find audio for it. [/quote]
Okay, this is a very reasonable explanation, however, it does not explain director William Dear's commentary refering to the correct ending (I assume he was watching the film as the commentary was being recorded). Also, knowing in advance that their print was not the theatrical cut, why didn't Anchor Bay put some kind of disclaimer on the packaging pointing that out.
At the very least Anchor Bay could have been up front about the deletion/substitution. Footage from the laserdisc (or video master of the LD) could have been added as a supplement or through seemless branching (actually non-seemless branching due to source differences) to explain the problem.
Thoughts?
[Edited last by John P Grosskopf on October 31, 2001 at 11:09 AM]
[Edited last by John P Grosskopf on October 31, 2001 at 11:16 AM]