Jim Ogilvie
Stunt Coordinator
- Joined
- Dec 31, 1998
- Messages
- 59
Hi!
Let me preface this by saying that I am very pleased with my DVD library, and have no complaints whatsoever about the material to date. My message here is to see what can be done to help us get typical DVD consumers and the general public into the 21st century.
Many of the general public believe that a widescreen presentation of a film is bad, due to the "black bars" that run on the top and bottom of the screen. Until I was educated as to why widescreen is almost always the best format for presenting a film, then I thought "full screen" was best also. Darn, those bars are annoying!
I believe this problem is not difficult to solve. Studios could quite easily create a five minute video segment (call it "What are these black bars for?" or something like that). This clip could appear on the main menu of any widescreen movie you put on the market on DVD (or bury it in the extra menu if you must, but the main menu screen would be ideal).
The clip would be designed to do nothing more than educate the viewer as to the benefit of the OAR presentation, of which there are many. The clip could also contain a little education as to how easy it is to get used to the black bars if you turn down the lights on your living room, etc.
I expect this would go a LONG way to not only minimizing complaints and returns of DVD movies, but it would have the added benefit of educating the public and making them more accepting of widescreen in general.
For the studios, the long term benefit would be a greater demand for catalog titles in the future when widescreen hardware becomes more popular, demanded and accepted in the mainstream.
There are already examples of clips on DVD that do this, indirectly. Leonard Nimoy included an explanation of widescreen/full screen on one of this commentaries on a Star Trek movie that he directed.
In any case, this could be made cheaply, and included on all of your widescreen DVD's. The general public would be educated, and would gain a new appreciation for the movies they see.
thanks for listening!
Jim
Let me preface this by saying that I am very pleased with my DVD library, and have no complaints whatsoever about the material to date. My message here is to see what can be done to help us get typical DVD consumers and the general public into the 21st century.
Many of the general public believe that a widescreen presentation of a film is bad, due to the "black bars" that run on the top and bottom of the screen. Until I was educated as to why widescreen is almost always the best format for presenting a film, then I thought "full screen" was best also. Darn, those bars are annoying!
I believe this problem is not difficult to solve. Studios could quite easily create a five minute video segment (call it "What are these black bars for?" or something like that). This clip could appear on the main menu of any widescreen movie you put on the market on DVD (or bury it in the extra menu if you must, but the main menu screen would be ideal).
The clip would be designed to do nothing more than educate the viewer as to the benefit of the OAR presentation, of which there are many. The clip could also contain a little education as to how easy it is to get used to the black bars if you turn down the lights on your living room, etc.
I expect this would go a LONG way to not only minimizing complaints and returns of DVD movies, but it would have the added benefit of educating the public and making them more accepting of widescreen in general.
For the studios, the long term benefit would be a greater demand for catalog titles in the future when widescreen hardware becomes more popular, demanded and accepted in the mainstream.
There are already examples of clips on DVD that do this, indirectly. Leonard Nimoy included an explanation of widescreen/full screen on one of this commentaries on a Star Trek movie that he directed.
In any case, this could be made cheaply, and included on all of your widescreen DVD's. The general public would be educated, and would gain a new appreciation for the movies they see.
thanks for listening!
Jim