Cinescott
Supporting Actor
I've been looking for a David Lean Blu-ray beyond Dr. Zhivago and The Bridge on the River Kwai that would tide me over until the release of Lawrence of Arabia. Well, having the first two films and A Passage to India is not a bad start.
I watched APTI yesterday for the first time in a long time, probably since its theatrical run in 1984. Seems like I've had a knack for discovering Blu-rays that have been out forever now. Part of the fun of Blu-ray admiration in general.
I've always had an interest in APTI, since it was Lean's last film and the fact that it was filmed in the more intimate 1.66:1 AR, which compared to his work from the previous 25 years, was certainly a departure.
The movie's well, pretty good. The only complaints I would have about it would be length (it could have been tightened up quite a bit, instead of 2 hours and 45 minutes) and the casting of Alec Guinness. How anyone could have cast him as a native Indian is beyond me. I understand the collaboration of Lean and Guinness went back a long ways, but even Sir David must have been aware of Guinness' popularity through his own films and the then-not-so-old Star Wars. I keep waiting for him to say "come with me to Alderaan." Tougher to suspend disbelief for sure.
Alec does his best, though and it kind of works. The rest of the cast, however is superb. Oscar-winner Peggy Ashcroft, Oscar-nominated Judy Davis, a Great Victor Banerjee as Aziz, James Fox, and others.
The story is a good one, although the whole time I kept thinking of it as a remake of "To Kill a Mockingbird" set in India. I loved the direction and the cinematography. It's fun, though, to revisit older movies that I just didn't "get" when I was younger. Seems like a lot of stuff is just easier to follow than it's ever been.
The Blu-ray itself is spectacular for anyone interested. Great transfer.
I watched APTI yesterday for the first time in a long time, probably since its theatrical run in 1984. Seems like I've had a knack for discovering Blu-rays that have been out forever now. Part of the fun of Blu-ray admiration in general.
I've always had an interest in APTI, since it was Lean's last film and the fact that it was filmed in the more intimate 1.66:1 AR, which compared to his work from the previous 25 years, was certainly a departure.
The movie's well, pretty good. The only complaints I would have about it would be length (it could have been tightened up quite a bit, instead of 2 hours and 45 minutes) and the casting of Alec Guinness. How anyone could have cast him as a native Indian is beyond me. I understand the collaboration of Lean and Guinness went back a long ways, but even Sir David must have been aware of Guinness' popularity through his own films and the then-not-so-old Star Wars. I keep waiting for him to say "come with me to Alderaan." Tougher to suspend disbelief for sure.
Alec does his best, though and it kind of works. The rest of the cast, however is superb. Oscar-winner Peggy Ashcroft, Oscar-nominated Judy Davis, a Great Victor Banerjee as Aziz, James Fox, and others.
The story is a good one, although the whole time I kept thinking of it as a remake of "To Kill a Mockingbird" set in India. I loved the direction and the cinematography. It's fun, though, to revisit older movies that I just didn't "get" when I was younger. Seems like a lot of stuff is just easier to follow than it's ever been.
The Blu-ray itself is spectacular for anyone interested. Great transfer.