- Joined
- Feb 8, 1999
- Messages
- 18,407
- Real Name
- Robert Harris
Ask any knowledgeable cinephile for a list of what they consider to be the greatest silent films, and you can bet that The Gold Rush is on it.
Produced in 1925, it was Sir Charles Chaplin's first feature length silent comedy. He followed it up with The Circus (1928), City Lights (1931), and finally Modern Times (1936), before he entered totally talking pictures.
These are all great films, but while his later works saw occasional reissues, the silent version of The Gold Rush literally disappeared after he created a 1942 version with inter-titles removed, and additions of a score and speaking narrative. Public domain versions blossomed in the 1950s, and remained the only real means of seeing anything akin to the original version of the film for decades.
Kevin Brownlow's Photoplay Productions, originally partnered with David Gill, and now Patrick Stanbury, created a reconstructed version, with the blessing of the Chaplin estate, and it is essentially that version, digitized, cleaned and adapted, that is the "extra" on Criterion's new Blu-ray of the film.
It is the 1942 (Chaplin's preferred version) that takes first position, and is in better overall condition.
My preference has always been the original, and I'm thrilled with what I'm seeing and hearing on this new Blu-ray.
For those unfamiliar, don't read reviews. Do yourself a favor. Just get a copy of this Blu-ray, and enjoy.
One of the greatest films in the history of cinema.
Image - 3 (silent version)
4 (1942 re-issue)
Highly Recommended.
RAH
Produced in 1925, it was Sir Charles Chaplin's first feature length silent comedy. He followed it up with The Circus (1928), City Lights (1931), and finally Modern Times (1936), before he entered totally talking pictures.
These are all great films, but while his later works saw occasional reissues, the silent version of The Gold Rush literally disappeared after he created a 1942 version with inter-titles removed, and additions of a score and speaking narrative. Public domain versions blossomed in the 1950s, and remained the only real means of seeing anything akin to the original version of the film for decades.
Kevin Brownlow's Photoplay Productions, originally partnered with David Gill, and now Patrick Stanbury, created a reconstructed version, with the blessing of the Chaplin estate, and it is essentially that version, digitized, cleaned and adapted, that is the "extra" on Criterion's new Blu-ray of the film.
It is the 1942 (Chaplin's preferred version) that takes first position, and is in better overall condition.
My preference has always been the original, and I'm thrilled with what I'm seeing and hearing on this new Blu-ray.
For those unfamiliar, don't read reviews. Do yourself a favor. Just get a copy of this Blu-ray, and enjoy.
One of the greatest films in the history of cinema.
Image - 3 (silent version)
4 (1942 re-issue)
Highly Recommended.
RAH