- Joined
- Feb 8, 1999
- Messages
- 19,975
- Real Name
- Robert Harris
Arrow releases some beautiful discs, both 2 and 4k.
I was in the slightly awkward position of checking out both their new Hellraiser 4k UHD set almost concurrent with the AMC/Acorn Blu-ray of the recent Interview with the Vampire series - Season 1 & 2.
And once again, the ugly question of "should everything be in 4k" will be raised.
Hellraiser in 4k UHD has no 4k information that I can discern, but IS a gorgeous representation of what's on the OCN.
What you're getting is a very nice image, with excellent colors, nice blacks and a whole lot of grain.
This is great, but it would have made a terrific Blu-ray.
Interview with the Vampire, with 25% of Hellraiser's resolution is FAR more highly resolved, and an overall far superior image.
So...
Where does this leave us?
My vote is for new, high-end 4k image harvests toward an archival attribute, and a down-rez to 2k for the Blu-ray, as nothing of consequence is being lost.
I just think the industry is spending far too much time, effort and investment on 4k releases for which there is very little rationale for their being.
How much different would Hellraiser be in 2k?
I'm betting not a whole lot, aside from a bit more rich black.
Image
Forensic - 6.5
NSD - 9
Audio – 10 (DTS-HD MA 5.1)
Pass / Fail – Pass
Plays nicely with projectors - Yes
Makes use of and works well in 4k - 5
Worth your attention - Yes
Slipcover rating - I did not receive final production goods
Recommended
RAH
I was in the slightly awkward position of checking out both their new Hellraiser 4k UHD set almost concurrent with the AMC/Acorn Blu-ray of the recent Interview with the Vampire series - Season 1 & 2.
And once again, the ugly question of "should everything be in 4k" will be raised.
Hellraiser in 4k UHD has no 4k information that I can discern, but IS a gorgeous representation of what's on the OCN.
What you're getting is a very nice image, with excellent colors, nice blacks and a whole lot of grain.
This is great, but it would have made a terrific Blu-ray.
Interview with the Vampire, with 25% of Hellraiser's resolution is FAR more highly resolved, and an overall far superior image.
So...
Where does this leave us?
My vote is for new, high-end 4k image harvests toward an archival attribute, and a down-rez to 2k for the Blu-ray, as nothing of consequence is being lost.
I just think the industry is spending far too much time, effort and investment on 4k releases for which there is very little rationale for their being.
How much different would Hellraiser be in 2k?
I'm betting not a whole lot, aside from a bit more rich black.
Image
Forensic - 6.5
NSD - 9
Audio – 10 (DTS-HD MA 5.1)
Pass / Fail – Pass
Plays nicely with projectors - Yes
Makes use of and works well in 4k - 5
Worth your attention - Yes
Slipcover rating - I did not receive final production goods
Recommended
RAH