- Joined
- Feb 8, 1999
- Messages
- 18,411
- Real Name
- Robert Harris
There are far too many situations in which the word "restoration" is used in the same sentence with "film."
I'd go so far as to say that the majority that appear these days are manufactured in the publicity departments, and not in the post houses.
Not so with Columbia Pictures, and their beautiful new restoration of Frank Capra's 1938, You Can't Take it With You.
When you purchase your copy of the new Blu-ray, you'll receive as a part of the book-like packaging, an explanation of the situation by Columbia's Grover Crisp.
It all boils down to this.
Far too many prints were struck from cameras negatives during the the 1920s through 1950s, and consequently those original negatives, when they survive, are in less than stellar condition.
For many years YCTiWY appeared to have been taken, at least partially, from 16mm elements, especially for non-theatrical prints.
The original negative was presumed destroyed before 1950, with the finest presumed surviving element, a third generation nitrate dupe neg. Even that dupe had replacement sections cut in c. 1951 on safety stock.
An original 1939 print, struck from the dupe before the replacements were added, was discovered, and turned over to Columbia for future restorative efforts.
Two source elements were used for the restoration, which involved both image and audio.
Best to read the entire explanation, when you receive your disc, but suffice to say, this is the real thing.
Another, even more dire situation will be discussed for another real restoration, The Apu Trilogy, in a future Few Words.
Bottom line, it's wonderful to finally get to see YCTiWY in near prime condition.
Since the image comes from third and fourth generation elements, there is a bit of build-up in the blacks, affecting shadow detail, but it's not an extremely problematic situation.
Resolution holds true to the source, and audio is the best I've ever heard.
For those who may be discovering Mr. Capra's work for the first time, or only know of him from that Christmas picture, time to get involved.
While many American directors are respected for work, I can't think of another for whom the term "beloved" fits the bill.
A great classic comedy, finally available in quality befitting the subject, and at a street price of $15, a steal.
This appears to be the second release, in what will hopefully become a full-blown Capra Collection making its way from Columbia, as the films can be properly restored in 4k. I'm thrilled to have them appear slowly, one at a time, and as pristine as possible.
Image - 4
Audio - 5
4k Up-rez - 4.5
Pass / Fail - Pass
Very Highly Recommended
RAH
