- Joined
- Feb 8, 1999
- Messages
- 18,422
- Real Name
- Robert Harris
I've been reading responses on line regarding some of Universal's recent catalog releases inclusive of Spartacus, on Blu-ray, and wanted to add a few thoughts to possibly clear up some misconceptions.
First, and possibly most important, problems with Spartacus and other titles should not dissuade potential new adopters from making the move to Blu-ray. This is a limited problem, and certainly not a Blu-ray problem. All that one need do is read reviews and commentaries from those that you trust before pre-ordering, and make your decisions based upon that information.
Second, the Spartacus problem is not something that affects USHE across the board. What seems to be occurring is that certain older masters, which are far below current spec, are being re-processed and re-purposed for Blu-ray. Many of these were acceptable for standard definition use, but should not be re-used for BD.
Third, any new releases coming from Universal, that have not been improperly processed should have no problems whatsoever. Inclusive would be anything derived from digital intermediates, such as The Wolfman, as well as any other more recent productions that have gone through an image harvest over the past few years.
Keep in mind that Spartacus is based upon a decade old HD master, that was never terribly good to begin with, especially when viewed in an HD environment.
The bottom line is that while I cannot support Universal's current ideology in re-using old HD masters for Blu-ray, it should not affect anyone's buying habits toward any other Universal releases. Anything based upon a digital intermediate should not only be a very safe pre-order, but a stellar Blu-ray presentation.
For catalog titles, do your research and safely purchase those which receive a clean bill of health from trusted reviewers.
What has occurred is an unfortunate situation, based upon what I perceive to be flawed decision making, but fortunately is very limited.
It would be unfair to Universal to have the public thinking that this was a larger, all-emcompassing problem.
I wanted to be very clear on this.
RAH
First, and possibly most important, problems with Spartacus and other titles should not dissuade potential new adopters from making the move to Blu-ray. This is a limited problem, and certainly not a Blu-ray problem. All that one need do is read reviews and commentaries from those that you trust before pre-ordering, and make your decisions based upon that information.
Second, the Spartacus problem is not something that affects USHE across the board. What seems to be occurring is that certain older masters, which are far below current spec, are being re-processed and re-purposed for Blu-ray. Many of these were acceptable for standard definition use, but should not be re-used for BD.
Third, any new releases coming from Universal, that have not been improperly processed should have no problems whatsoever. Inclusive would be anything derived from digital intermediates, such as The Wolfman, as well as any other more recent productions that have gone through an image harvest over the past few years.
Keep in mind that Spartacus is based upon a decade old HD master, that was never terribly good to begin with, especially when viewed in an HD environment.
The bottom line is that while I cannot support Universal's current ideology in re-using old HD masters for Blu-ray, it should not affect anyone's buying habits toward any other Universal releases. Anything based upon a digital intermediate should not only be a very safe pre-order, but a stellar Blu-ray presentation.
For catalog titles, do your research and safely purchase those which receive a clean bill of health from trusted reviewers.
What has occurred is an unfortunate situation, based upon what I perceive to be flawed decision making, but fortunately is very limited.
It would be unfair to Universal to have the public thinking that this was a larger, all-emcompassing problem.
I wanted to be very clear on this.
RAH