Will Krupp
Senior HTF Member
I think it's just "one" peoplehaineshisway said:So some people are actually preferring an ancient non-anamorphic DVD transfer to this Blu-ray.
I think it's just "one" peoplehaineshisway said:So some people are actually preferring an ancient non-anamorphic DVD transfer to this Blu-ray.
And I, and I'm sure others, will say that the first disc THX Oklahoma! that WE have is NOT anamorphic.Joe Caps said:I will try this again.
I have the first Oklahoma, single disc on dvd. iot IS anaMORPHIC, THE DAY FOR NIGHT IS CORRECT, iT IS RESONABLY SHARP,, THE SOUND IS EXCELLENT, THE DAY FOR NIGHT IS CORRECT.
Enjoy your lovely edge enhanced picture.Joe Caps said:I am watching my single disc THX Oklahoma right now !!!!
Far Better sound than the blu.
More color too.
Thanks for clearing that up... Despite minor quibbles I think the blu-ray of OK! is gorgeous... but prior to that I DID prefer the first non-anamorphic dvd (for the Todd-AO) to the botch that was put on the double disc re-release. Imagine my surprise a few years back when I popped in that old disc to my (then) new region-free LG blu-ray player and it played as if it WERE anamorphic (except that the blow-up was a *mass* of artifacts) -- retrying it on my non-region free Samsung produced the same non-anamorphic tiny image I had sadly grown used to.Mark-P said:He only thinks it's anamorphic, I'm guessing because the disc is most likely flagged as letterbox and many Blu-ray players will automatically zoom DVDs flagged as such.
On my set, the scene following the intermission is MOST DEFINITELY brighter and looks like broad daylight compared to my old THX DVD. Even on the DVD it's clear the scene WAS shot in broad daylight (you can tell by the sharp shadows). But on the DVD the scene has been artificially darkened in post.If the TODD-AO Oklahoma in your set is truly darkened, just like the THX DVD, then perhaps Fox has made a correction to the next batch of discs?Dave MJ said:Watched this today (thanks to the $50 sale on Friday). The picture looks amazing. Such an incredible improvement over the DVD. I'm no expert on the film, but the sound is very good on my system in DTS-MA. I have a powerful Onkyo receiver and excellent Klipsch speakers. I Watched in 5.1 and the music sounded very good and dialogue and vocals weren't tinny at all. I had to turn it up maybe 8 clicks louder than most movies, but had plenty of volume to spare. I'm very happy with the entire presentation.
The color timing for the scene following the intermission looks the same as the DVD to me. The DVD may be slightly darker, but I think that is more due to bad quality than a difference in timing. It's definitely not day for night. Or am I missing something?
You'll have to verify how each of us have are displays set at? IMO, where we have our HT's calibrated at has great influence on why we see some scenes differently.Mark Booth said:On my set, the scene following the intermission is MOST DEFINITELY brighter and looks like broad daylight compared to my old THX DVD. Even on the DVD it's clear the scene WAS shot in broad daylight (you can tell by the sharp shadows). But on the DVD the scene has been artificially darkened in post.If the TODD-AO Oklahoma in your set is truly darkened, just like the THX DVD, then perhaps Fox has made a correction to the next batch of discs?
As new people receive the set from the latest Amazon sale prices, SOMEONE needs to post a screenshot of that scene to verify.
Mark