- Joined
- Feb 8, 1999
- Messages
- 18,397
- Real Name
- Robert Harris
While I would have preferred the original 1938 cut of Abel Gance's J'Accuse, we have what we have, as delivered by Gaumont and Olive.
We have some extra footage, and some original footage missing, but it serves the purpose, as the many important bits are generally intact. The downside of the re-issue is a happy ending, and the loss of Diaz rejoining his long-dead allies.
It was released in a heavily cut version in the U.S. in late 1939.
J'Accuse is one of the great anti-war films. In a very different way, but right up there with Renoir's Grand Illusion and Kubrick's Paths of Glory.
Different, in that it appears more fragmented, possibly less professional, and uses horror to make it point. Think the progenitor of Night of the Living Dead.
The elements have been nicely restored, with picture generally appearing quite beautiful, and audio, which was a pastiche at the time, still showing some of its rough assemblage.
Gance not only used a great deal of stock footage for the re-make of his own 1918 film (available, but apparently out of print, from Flicker Alley), but also quite a bit of stock footage. Of necessity, image quality can change from shot to shot, but that's what it looked like originally.
An extremely important film, I'm thrilled that Olive has stepped up to the plate and released this one. Once you see it, you'll never lose the images.
Victor Francen's performance, as Jean Diaz is one of the great ones! After leaving France, he went on to have a very respectable career in Hollywood.
Before anyone asks, I have no idea why the re-issue version was used.
Image - 3.5
Audio - 3.5
4k Up-rez - 3.75
Pass / Fail - Pass
Very Highly Recommended
RAH
We have some extra footage, and some original footage missing, but it serves the purpose, as the many important bits are generally intact. The downside of the re-issue is a happy ending, and the loss of Diaz rejoining his long-dead allies.
It was released in a heavily cut version in the U.S. in late 1939.
J'Accuse is one of the great anti-war films. In a very different way, but right up there with Renoir's Grand Illusion and Kubrick's Paths of Glory.
Different, in that it appears more fragmented, possibly less professional, and uses horror to make it point. Think the progenitor of Night of the Living Dead.
The elements have been nicely restored, with picture generally appearing quite beautiful, and audio, which was a pastiche at the time, still showing some of its rough assemblage.
Gance not only used a great deal of stock footage for the re-make of his own 1918 film (available, but apparently out of print, from Flicker Alley), but also quite a bit of stock footage. Of necessity, image quality can change from shot to shot, but that's what it looked like originally.
An extremely important film, I'm thrilled that Olive has stepped up to the plate and released this one. Once you see it, you'll never lose the images.
Victor Francen's performance, as Jean Diaz is one of the great ones! After leaving France, he went on to have a very respectable career in Hollywood.
Before anyone asks, I have no idea why the re-issue version was used.
Image - 3.5
Audio - 3.5
4k Up-rez - 3.75
Pass / Fail - Pass
Very Highly Recommended
RAH