- Joined
- Feb 8, 1999
- Messages
- 18,409
- Real Name
- Robert Harris
I'm not a fan of 3D for 3D's sake.
I'm a fan of quality films, and if that film happens to have been photographed in 3D...
that's great.
Conversions are another story. Some work. Others don't. Some weren't designed to be seen in 3D, and the use of the format to sell discs isn't something to which I subscribe.
But give me a quality film, and quality 3D, and I'll buy it. Especially productions with more than simple depth. Atmosphere is what really is essential.
Avatar and Hugo are at the top of my short list.
When it comes to conversions, I normally don't get involved. But again, give me something special, and I'm in.
A decade ago, Pixar created Finding Nemo. An extraordinary entertainment for all ages. It had everything going for it, especially on Blu-ray. Within the gorgeous 2D image, 3D sat waiting to come to the surface. The dimensionality of the 2D was beautiful.
It was with a bit of trepidation, that I placed the new 3D disc of Finding Nemo in my player. How good would it be? Did they make a circus out of it? Does the 3D really work?
The answers: Terrific, Absolutely not, yes.
This is less of a conversion than a re-imagining of the original. The gang at Pixar went back to the original files, using them as the left eye, and creating the parallax for a right eye. The work appears to be have done with precision, delicacy and consummate respect for the original.
Colors and densities are true. Audio is now Dolby 7.1 TrueHD, with a beautiful spacial environment.
The film not only holds up, but plays every bit as it did a decade ago. A modern classic? I believe so.
Great film.
Great delicate 3D.
The new Finding Nemo in 3D is nothing short of a revelation. This is the kind of release that would push me toward 3D, if I were on the fence.
Very Highly Recommended.
RAH
I'm a fan of quality films, and if that film happens to have been photographed in 3D...
that's great.
Conversions are another story. Some work. Others don't. Some weren't designed to be seen in 3D, and the use of the format to sell discs isn't something to which I subscribe.
But give me a quality film, and quality 3D, and I'll buy it. Especially productions with more than simple depth. Atmosphere is what really is essential.
Avatar and Hugo are at the top of my short list.
When it comes to conversions, I normally don't get involved. But again, give me something special, and I'm in.
A decade ago, Pixar created Finding Nemo. An extraordinary entertainment for all ages. It had everything going for it, especially on Blu-ray. Within the gorgeous 2D image, 3D sat waiting to come to the surface. The dimensionality of the 2D was beautiful.
It was with a bit of trepidation, that I placed the new 3D disc of Finding Nemo in my player. How good would it be? Did they make a circus out of it? Does the 3D really work?
The answers: Terrific, Absolutely not, yes.
This is less of a conversion than a re-imagining of the original. The gang at Pixar went back to the original files, using them as the left eye, and creating the parallax for a right eye. The work appears to be have done with precision, delicacy and consummate respect for the original.
Colors and densities are true. Audio is now Dolby 7.1 TrueHD, with a beautiful spacial environment.
The film not only holds up, but plays every bit as it did a decade ago. A modern classic? I believe so.
Great film.
Great delicate 3D.
The new Finding Nemo in 3D is nothing short of a revelation. This is the kind of release that would push me toward 3D, if I were on the fence.
Very Highly Recommended.
RAH