cafink
Senior HTF Member
- Joined
- Apr 19, 1999
- Messages
- 3,044
- Real Name
- Carl Fink
You asked, "where did I say my opinion was more valid or special?" You did so in saying thigs like:
I don't know what your "it's not about YOU" comment is even supposed to mean. I said before that I recognize that some compromise had to be made and that there was no ideal solution. I said that the Blu-ray was pretty good and that re-dubbing the voice was acceptable. I didn't claim that there is only one valid way of presenting Fantasia, or describe others' preferred way as "butchery."
Originally Posted by Russell G
To ask for scenes to be cut that have been re-instated due to an audio issue? Yes, I shake my head at it and consider it butchery over compromise since it is unnecessary on the whole. It may be necessary for YOU, but Disney didn't make this for YOU and it's not about YOU. There are many more people out there that would prefer the original length Fantasia over an edited one. The Bluray allows you to skip over the Deems Taylor parts your so offended by, so get over your self and skip past them (or continue to not buy it) instead of supporting that video companies release edited versions over restored versions.
I don't know what your "it's not about YOU" comment is even supposed to mean. I said before that I recognize that some compromise had to be made and that there was no ideal solution. I said that the Blu-ray was pretty good and that re-dubbing the voice was acceptable. I didn't claim that there is only one valid way of presenting Fantasia, or describe others' preferred way as "butchery."