bujaki
Senior HTF Member
Mrs. Jefferson could convince me to do ANYTHING!
Powell&Pressburger said:I can't get Airplane out of my mind now.
Joe Lugoff said:>>>>
For those who think 1776 could have been better filmed, just compare it to the film version of a stage musical that came out a month later, and count your blessings. As Leonard Maltin said of "Man of la Mancha, "Beautiful source material has been raped, murdered and buried." (Or was he referring to "Don Quixote"?)
HAIR -as a film is better than the stage play.Garysb said:"Fiddler" is a good film but I felt they removed too much of the humor that was in the stage version. Humor was needed to balance some of the other parts of the film. With the exception of the "Sound of Music" I am not aware of any film version of a musical the exceeded the stage original. Possibly Cabaret is another, but the film version's story line was much different from the stage original as the two are almost unrelated to each other. The story in the film "Cabaret " is closer to the movie and play " I Am A Camera" than the stage version of " Cabaret". All were based on the same source, "Berlin Stories."
The story lines of stage and movie versions of "Hair" are more different than "Cabaret" are. I had forgotten about that. The only thing in common the stories have is the names of characters. The movie version added a linear story which the stage version really didn't have. I saw the stage version of "Hair" during its last Broadway revival. I preferred the stage version to the movie. Just my opinion.trajan said:HAIR -as a film is better than the stage play.
I would say the "Music Man" is probably just as good as the stage version. It essentially is the same as the stage version with Robert Preston recreating his stage role. I don't think it improved on anything from the stage version except perhaps for the ending which couldn't have been done on a stage. Most importantly it didn't lose anything from the stage version except for a few song changes.Rob_Ray said:THE MUSIC MAN is a near-perfect adaptation of the stage original with a largely non-cinematic director at the helm. I can't imagine how that one could have been improved upon.
It appears the youtube poster made their own cut.Moe Dickstein said:I didn't know there was a 2010 DVD release.
No, The Music Man is a perfect stage to screen adaptation - it didn't lose a "few song changes" - it had ONE song change - My White Knight to Being in Love, which uses the bridge of My White Knight. That's it. Everything else is there. It's a wonderful movie, wonderfully adapted to the screen, well directed by its original stage director, Morton da Costa and Onna White's choreography (also from the stage version) is stellar. The cast could NOT be better, from Preston to Shirley Jones to the brilliant comic performances of Paul Ford and Hermoine Gingold.Garysb said:I would say the "Music Man" is probably just as good as the stage version. It essentially is the same as the stage version with Robert Preston recreating his stage role. I don't think it improved on anything from the stage version except perhaps for the ending which couldn't have been done on a stage. Most importantly it didn't lose anything from the stage version except for a few song changes.