haineshisway
Senior HTF Member
Which link did you use?
The direct e-mail link from Digital Bits - the other website link didn't work at all.
Which link did you use?
Omitting an audio track is a picture quality problem? I think that’s a stretch.The omission error is a PQ issue in my opinion. My question are they’re any other PQ issues?
I'm always amazed that the studios would seem to rather repress discs and have these replacment programs instead of simply taking a couple extra quality assurance steps and checks to just get it right in the first place.
As noted here, it seems like it would cost a lot of money to redo the discs again and mail them out.
Even short of that, they could just send some discs out to fans or experts for review before the units are shipped to retailers and then to customers. At least then replacement would be easier and you wouldn't have the PR nightmare all over social media and web forums.
Two big UHD boxsets (Sony Classics and Universal Hitchcock) and two costly blunders - not good. I am sorry for the studios but it will pay off in the long run that they both did the right thing.
Chaos doesn’t even touch upon the reality.I doubt Sony's inclusion of the wrong supplements disc for Lawrence of Arabia was too big of a hassle between it just being a BD-25, clearly a manufacturing error, and I'd imagine a lot of people already had the big gift set where it wouldn't matter. Mainly got the replacement so I could gift the Blu-rays for LoA to a friend who doesn't have a 4K setup yet.
No idea what a BD-100 replacement would cost by comparison. Though, I already know a person or two who aren't bothering with a replacement since they're happy with the remixes. Good for Universal taking care of this, though.
I'm surprised we're not having more releases with issues this year given all the chaos.
I define PQ as Product Quality, not Picture Quality.Omitting an audio track is a picture quality problem? I think that’s a stretch.
I can see where HTF members could see it differently. PQ=Picture Quality; AQ=Audio Quality; QC=Quality Control; and your definition: PQ=Product Quality. Alphabet soup.I define PQ as Product Quality.
Haven't we all.Entire staff has been working from home for months.
My definition of PQ analogy stands for "Product Quality" comes from my retired automotive managerial career.I can see where HTF members could see it differently. PQ=Picture Quality; AQ=Audio Quality; QC=Quality Control; and your definition: PQ=Product Quality. Alphabet soup.
I was about to pull the trigger on this set. Now I’m pondering either waiting for new sets with corrected audio. Or buy the set now and ask for the replacement disc. Or I’m even wondering if there is a 4K Hitchcock Masterpiece Collection Box set down the road that would include the same titles as the 2012 box set.
It is great news that Universal will take care of the error.
Yet, I think the set will be cheaper in late November and by then, we should know if the corrected discs are in stores. This mono audio issue has sealed it for me to wait until later this year.If you buy now and exchange the defective disc, you can skip the whole roulette wheel of figuring out whether or not the set you're eventually ordering is the corrected version or not.
Yes, the roulette wheel is exactly a concern of waiting for a fixed set! I’m still waiting out the Creature from the Black Lagoon box set to be sure it’s good. ( That set I’m guessing should be ok now. ).