Search results

Mark I love the 2009 version!

Lol!

Probably as a 65th Anniversary Edition.

This poor movie has never had a complete, definitive version. The blu rays suffer from some weird encoding problem. Almost every scene has annoying jumps that aren't caused by film damage. Once you notice it, it is impossible to ignore.

The 1938 version on blu restores the halo-like effect over several scenes, missing from the previous release. The contrast is much better, allowing that special glow to come through again.

Of every movie in my "Christmas Carol" collection, the 1999 Stewart version is my absolute least favorite. Something about the production design isn't to my liking.

If you go into the 1938 version just looking for a cozy Christmas experience, and enjoy it for that, it will become one of your favorites. If you are looking at it critically, examining its faithfulness to the story, you are likely to be disappointed. It's probably my favorite version (followed...

Maybe the missing line is not really missing. Perhaps it was from the U.S. version?

So, her dialogue is missing on the 2012 blu-ray as well?

Yeah, when Scrooge is in the chair (when Marley appears), the floor behind him starts popping in and out. I would like to know if this was fixed for the 2012 version.

So does the 2012 version have the frame skipping in every scene? This is an encode problem, not actual missing frames.