Search results

I almost hope they never do it because I bet what gets released will please about 4 people with all the damn nitpicking over a million different things every different fan seems to have their own personal peeve over what they will degin to accept.I'm more than happy with whatever Lucas wishes to...

I have no interest in the original versions beyond a curiosity. I prefer the redone versions.

I just want them to go back to the Oneg for new scans of the SEs I prefer the version the director intends, but even they aren't up to modern standards.

So far as i know Gilliam just removed one line from Brazil from earlier versions. Sam's reaction to his mother's surgery mold "my god it works!" It's on the Universal Blu of the US cut.

I make no legal claims. These are moral rights.

Absolutely you can. Just because you like and want something doesn't mean you're entitled to it.

I'm saying it's his call. If he doesn't care now then that's his call. And just because some inferior version was released earlier, and people experienced it, that doesn't mean that people have a perpetual right to that version. They have the right to what the creator chooses to make...

No, they are still his films in the sense that he is the creator. Every creator of a film's rights in this area should be respected, regardless of what entity owns the negative.

As well he should flip. It's his film he can do anything he wants with it.

if the movies were "unLucasized" they wouldn't exist since I believe he did have some involvement with them back in the 70s and early 80s...

Hopefully.

Absolutely. I got confused when you mentioned the reason for not doing fixes as purity, where my reason is they aren't entitled to any improvements if they are ungrateful about all the improvements

You're mistaking the attitude of my posts. I say if people want to watch the inferior old versions then they don't get to pick and choose which fixes from the improved current versions they can keep.

I don't think they should get any fixes if they want "what came out in theaters", if you want the fixes you take them all or you take nothing.

I think they should have to take it warts and all. no fixes.

It does when it's a part of 6 and soon to be 9 films.

No need to end the discussion, as this is all based on speculation anyway

The first two weren't an issue to me (I mean he's a ghost is that supposed to look "real") and the last one is your own personal hangup.

It's apples and oranges. Those films you mentioned aren't meant to be a seamless "set" of films but rather are re-boots. They also don't share the same creative force behind them. Plus you take the argument to ridiculous lengths of replacing an actor for an entire film rather than basically a...

Oh I didn't know that it worked like we all got to pick our own personal Star Wars universe, like I said I'm not so well versed in SW fandom and foolishly assumed that the creator got to decide what was canon.

See and I never watched SW until I was older and around the time the prequels came out, so I actually enjoy the political intrigue aspects of the prequels more than some stuff in the later films, plus the changes to 4-6 to make them fit in with 1-3 better are improvements in my mind. If you're...

So I guess I'm one of two people who prefers the new versions huh?