Yes, I know, but we probably shouldn't have been discussing them here. It is a Flower Drum Song thread. It's easy to get sidetracked, and they ARE both R&H shows, but I didn't want a moderator slapping our hands.
I would say it might be best to move such a discussion to this thread:
https://www.hometheaterforum.com/community/threads/the-rodgers-and-hammerstein-collection-blu-ray-review.331528/#post-4085517
It's kind of hard to understand how Otto Preminger could do such a great job directing the operatic Carmen Jones and yet do such a stiff and unimaginative job with Porgy and Bess. I wonder if he was intimidated with the significance of the material he was working with in the latter case.
Well, in most cases you're probably right, but when I saw Oklahoma! in a dinner theater setting in the 1980s, the ballet was naturally excised. There was nowhere to stage it!
I have an MP3 player that I use in my car to provide music since I prefer Broadway cast albums to whatever I can find to play on the radio. There are only two movie soundtracks I have on the player rather than their Broadway counterparts: Flower Drum Song and Carousel. I don't think it's any...