Yep.
And here's a review of the recent French BD (with screenshots at the bottom)
https://www.cinefaniac.fr/dvd/testdvd.php?i=1284
As I suspected: an ancient double-decade old master slapped on BD, riddled in scanner noise with detail looking akin to 'mush'.... Low-pass filtered from Rimini...
Well, I guess the chances are even more slim now with the whole Disney annexing/acquisition...
It's a shame none of the indie labels like Criterion, Twilight Time, Olive, Kino, or even Arrow thought about licensing/releasing it in recent years -- as Fox *did* do a new 4K DCP sometime around...
It's very minicsule and I doubt you'd notice unless you watch/pause BDs on your PC like me. Personally, I can't abide discs with poor authoring/compression jobs.
I can say without reservation the Japanese BD release is the best in the world at this current juncture, as all the other European BDs are littered with banding / artifacting due to anemic / poorly optimized encodes. (Yes - even the French BD which has a hellaciously low bitrate.) The JP BD is...
So someone posted caps of the new Kino disc and am a bit befuddled on where this quote stems from:
Do we have a source for that anywhere? I didn't see it in their initial presser and after looking at them side by side it's clearly taken from same DVD master, though without the DNR as seen on...
Precisely correct. It's now pick your poision as far as TCAT goes. What's more is, the untold amount of DNR that's utterly destroyed what could've been a reference quality VV transfer, has only helped but make the old BD that much better.
This is all the more sad, really.... when you find...
You could the say same about this site -- choosing to live in denial and being completely ignorant of the facts that have come to light about this BD: being one of the most overwhelming scrub jobs of the decade.
And the fact that people on here seem to think "lossless" screenshots are snakeoil...
Sorry -- meant to say The Ten Commandments (always get them mixed up).
In ANY event -- to compound the issue at hand even more -- why they felt the need to add any amount of DNR here (let alone the shocking amount ) is bewildering; VistaVision has a low-grain amount to begin with! There's...
https://i.slow.pics/P0l5cmmw.png
This might be the most grotesque amount of DNR I've seen on the format, up there with Predator, et al.
What makes it worse? We could've had something very similar to Ben-Hur had they left the grain "untouched" and not prepped for display at Madame Tussauds.
The degradation to the picture is insane here. How any reputable studio in 2020 could put out something like this monstrosity is beyond me. There's actually DNR artifacts/ringing in certain scenes if you look close enough. "Paramount Presents - how to ruin a VistaVision transfer" is what they...
I'm not entirely sure what you're getting at. You do realize those lossless screenshots don't lie, right? Especially when it comes to caps-a-holic's software... What you see is a like-for-like of what's on your BD disc.
Now whether or not you notice the anomalies when viewing in motion is a...