The French one sounds fantastic, but the picture is a little grainier with more compression artifacts than the r1. The Japanese version has an improved picture plus a full bitrate DTS track, best version of the two. The French version has better packaging though, nice embossed thinpack.
I find it hilarious that people with component input only HD sets are now being labeled 'early adopters'. These sets have been around for over 10 years now! The fact that component has been the most visible standard for delivering HD video for all consumer HD products until now would make many...
Not to mention the attraction of modding an xbox to run Xbox Media Center. I use mine as my mp3/aac library, and I convert all my HD recordings to DivX 720p format which the xbox handles beautifully! It upscales dvd to 720p and 1080i nicely as well, dvd support isn't perfect but is almost...
I have the Hong Kong r3 version. It's uncut, anamorphic, English subbed and DTS. It's as definitive as you're going to get at the moment. @ Jon Z: The version you mention is from Thailand
@ MuneebM: You don't need to change the drive in your xbox for 1080i and 720p dvd playback. 1) Get the newest version of XBMC 2) In the options disable Post Processing. This is broken with 1080i for some reason (but may have been fixed by now). I've heard reports that the xbox using...
Just picked up the Hong Kong 2 Disc release and can confirm the DTS-ES (Matrixed) track is full bitrate! It comes in a nice foil slipcase with a folder inside containing a cd-rom game (The Flying Legion Interactive Game) and a cardboard DIY 3D Model Plane.
My only dissapointment with PGR2 is with all the added polish on the cars and environments they had to drop down the framerate to 30fps (The original game was 60fps). Don't get me wrong I love both games, but I'm a firm believer that where applicable the added detail is less important than a...
Something I'd like to add to this conversation is to those that have only watched the film on the Asian dvd releases, I bought the Edko R3 over a year ago and absolutely loved the film, so much so I had to see it on the big screen again when it finally came out. Something I will say about the US...
For the record the Australia r4 release carries a full bitrate DTS track. How this compares in sound quality to the other regions I don't know though as I've not had them to compare.
I have a different perspective in all of this, in that I knew of the more popular songs on the White Album, but had never heard the album as a whole. After hearing The Grey Album I became fascinated with how it was put together and ended up buying The White Album to listen to the source for the...
It looks to me that it may be lacking sharpness due to underexposure in the cinematography. If you thought the dvd looks bad you should see the laserdisc! Frankly though if it's the source material that's problematic I'd rather it be left blurry than them adding edge enhancement to try and...
Something of note about the current r2/r4 'Definitive Edition', this release carries a full bitrate DTS track... pretty rare for a PAL release, especially a recent one.
The reason player generated subs appear pixelated is that when authoring the sub stream, you only have a choice of 4 colours at once for the subs. Without a large colour pallette there's no way to implement anti-aliasing on the text (unless the player itself is capable of that, and that would...
To answer your question, there is no definite answer. Sometimes the the r1 is better, sometimes it is inferior. You just have to research the particular title once it's released. I wouldn't expect them to screw up a release like Kill Bill however.
I have the Japanese release as well as the region 4 with DTS... I can say that although the pic and sound is better on the region 4, it isn't by much. The Japanese wins hands down for having the unrated version. Unless someone else rereleases it (and it won't be uncut r1 ever it seems due to...
PGR2 runs at 30fps as well??!! My god, Xbox games running at anything less than 60 is a joke these days, I don't care how slick they look. When effects and detail are piled on at the expense of framerate (and consequently accuracy of control) , especially for racing games this is inexcusable.
The only time it would be a problem really is if the original soundtrack doesn't have stereo surrounds (and some are labelled 5.1 even if they aren't sometimes, namely films from the early days of digital sound in the theatres) as that would force the rear channels into the rear center only.
For the record it would be actually 'downconverting' the signal, as 1080i is interlaced, and therefore is only displaying around 540 real lines per field, and those fields are alternated to give the illusion of 1080 lines. It should still look much better than 480p though.
Interesting that EA would allow the demo to go out if it was so bad, you'd think word of mouth could have hurt sales, kinda like The Hulk Superbowl trailer.
15 titles or not, I have about the same amount of Anchor Bay titles and have encountered numerous problems with those in the past. To write off the entire catalog is unfair to the company.