And if you truly believe that I'd like to sell you a "DVD Rewinder"! For Clair to get on the helicopter and be rescued the "switch" needed to be pushed. Now they made it sound like the only way that could happen was if Charlie died in the process, fine. However, the way they wrote the scene...
Who's to say the child isn't dead, or was even born at all? And let's say the child is alive, who's to say that the child even had a relationship with Juliet... Perhaps the child hated her or they had a falling out?
I'll say it for the 2nd time now (said it before on page 90 of this thread), the person in the coffin is... "Juliet"! Nobody likes her so nobody goes to her service, except Jack who likes her fine. As for her sister, she's died by then or has already died as we speak.
The show has worked fine for me right up to this dissapointing episode that was (in my opinion) either rushed or just really badly writen! It's only my opinion of course but like all of you here, I have a right to it!
For the most part, I didn't like it either... I don't see why idiot Charlie closed the door? The blast from the grenade didn't kill him therefor it wouldn't have killed Desmond either. He still could have flicked the switch, it would have taken more time to flood the place and both could have...
I'm still watching and have been since the first episode in 93 but the show is now a pale shadow of it's former self... The show has lasted long enough, it's time for it to go!
I don't have the "Criterion" but I do have the SE of this movie and have to date been quite satisfied with both the movie and the bonuses... Is it worth double dipping for this new edition? Keep in mind that I double dipped already on movies like "Gladiator" & "Kingdom of Heaven".