A few words about…™ Tunes of Glory – in Blu-ray

Oh, I am pleased. I was hoping this disc would be something special because the film certainly is, so I'm delighted that it meets RAH's very high standards.

Two points seldom mentioned regarding this film: Dennis Price is in it and the novelist Anthony Burgess (A Clockwork Orange) thought it one of the best films ever made.

Ages ago, I'm sure I read that Alec Guinness & John Mills flipped a coin as to which part to play. I don't know how true that is, but it would have been just as effective if they'd swapped, I can really see John Milles giving it large as the Major & Alec Guinness as the uptight Lt Col. Two great film actors.

One of Alec Guinness best roles and a great film too.

atcolomb said:

One of Alec Guinness best roles and a great film too.

Click to expand...

I've never seen this movie. I pre-ordered it back in late September as part of a "Buy 2, Get 1 Free" sale.

Robert Crawford said:

I've never seen this movie. I pre-ordered it back in late September as part of a "Buy 2, Get 1 Free" sale.

Click to expand...

I never saw the film until a month ago when I checked out the old Criterion release from the library. One of the nice extras on the disc is a 15 minute interview with Alec Guinness.

As an aside, aeons ago, I received a call from Mr. Neame, as I my company had rights and printing elements to a film entitled The Charm of Dynamite.

He was requesting a print, which I gifted him. His mother was Ivy Close, who was in a little silent film, La Roue.

Wonderful discussion, with a brilliant filmmaker.

The Horse's Mouth is another great film by the director and I hope a Blu-ray upgrade soon.

atcolomb said:

The Horse's Mouth is another great film by the director and I hope a Blu-ray upgrade soon.

Click to expand...

I'm sorry, Mr. Neame will always be the director of "The Poseidon Adventure" to me !

Robert Harris said:

As an aside, aeons ago, I received a call from Mr. Neame, as I my company had rights and printing elements to a film entitled The Charm of Dynamite.

Click to expand...

Is that the film made my Kevin Brownlow about the director Abel Gance? I can still remember seeing it on TV way back in the sixties (I think). It's funny the little bits of the past that you remember.

Billy Batson said:

Is that the film made my Kevin Brownlow about the director Abel Gance? I can still remember seeing it on TV way back in the sixties (I think). It's funny the little bits of the past that you remember.

Click to expand...

Precisely

Robert, you've got a typo in your original post. You spelled Alec as Alex.

Mark

Mark Booth said:

Robert, you've got a typo in your original post. You spelled Alec as Alex.

Mark

Click to expand...

Audio correkt

Billy Batson said:

Ages ago, I'm sure I read that Alec Guinness & John Mills flipped a coin as to which part to play. I don't know how true that is, but it would have been just as effective if they'd swapped, I can really see John Milles giving it large as the Major & Alec Guinness as the uptight Lt Col. Two great film actors.

Click to expand...

I rather doubt that story. According to IMDb Alec Guinness was first offered the part of Lt Col Barrow but asked to play Major Sinclair instead. Guinness then suggested John Mills for the part of Barrow.

I'm sure that Guinness could have played either role but I don't think John Mills would have been as effective as Jock Sinclair. Of course, playing an officer must have been second nature to Mills who appeared in so many military films. He plays Barrow very much as he played the stern, uptight ex-officer in the little known but favorite film of mine, "Tiara Tahiti" as antagonist against laid-back, ignore the rules, James Mason.

I'm never sure which character one is meant to empathise with in "Tunes of Glory" but my sympathies always go to John Mills' character.

I'm sure you're correct, I did read that about the leads of some film or other & thought it was this one, I wonder which film it was. It's been ages since I've seen the film, but I remember that Denis Price had a good little roll in it as someone who could see just what was going on. I don't think I empathised with any of the two lead characters, I wouldn't like either of them if I met them in real life.

The old Criterion DVD has a black line running through the right side of the image starting around the suicide and disappears around the funeral planning scene. Does the blu ray have it, too?