Bob McElfresh
Senior HTF Member
- Joined
- May 22, 1999
- Messages
- 5,182
I'm seeing lots of people consider a new receiver because suddenly they have 3 or more component video sources. And these sources are now progressive or HD quality so they need the higher 24-30 Mhz bandwidth. This means considering a flagship receiver.
But many people already have a good receiver, but without enough/any component inputs.
So I have been trying to find a HD capable video switcher that does not run $500 like the professional gear.
I finally found the Audio Authority 1154 video switcher for about $195.
This thing handles 4 HD Video sources and both Optical and coaxial digital audio as inputs. It has one HD video output and BOTH optical and coaxial outputs. (Yes, it converts). This means you can have a mix of coaxial and optical audio sources (DVD, XBox, HDTV decoder), but they all get converted to optical or coaxial.
They also have versions for Composite and SVideo switchers.
If anyone has other solutions, please post them here.
1/24/2003 - Update
Several people on a budget have bought some Radio Shack switchers for $40-$60 and say it works fine to feed XBox, PS-DVD players into HDTV's. While I STRONGLY suggest buying a true HD switcher rather than a whole new receiver, these box's are an option:
15-1976 - 4 input, 1 output manual switcher: $40
15-1977 - 4 input, 1 output remote switcher: $60
15-1987 - 6 input, 2 output w/optical remote: $150
(Note: if you are in this price range, you should be looking at the Audio Authority, Inday, Zektor units)
The Keohi Video Switch Comparison
Inday Switcher
Zektor Switcher
The CopperBox Retail Site
The IScan Pro page. This cool device takes Composite or SVideo or Component and up-converts all 3 to 480 progressive. This was THE unit to have before the built-in line doublers on HDTV's became as good as they are today.
The JVC JX-S111 Switcher
2/3/2003 update Here is a link to someone who got the Zektor Switcher. I thought I should include a link.
2/6/2003 Someone else posted a quote from the "Secrets of Home Theater" site about video switching that I thought was on-topic for this thread:
But many people already have a good receiver, but without enough/any component inputs.
So I have been trying to find a HD capable video switcher that does not run $500 like the professional gear.
I finally found the Audio Authority 1154 video switcher for about $195.
This thing handles 4 HD Video sources and both Optical and coaxial digital audio as inputs. It has one HD video output and BOTH optical and coaxial outputs. (Yes, it converts). This means you can have a mix of coaxial and optical audio sources (DVD, XBox, HDTV decoder), but they all get converted to optical or coaxial.
They also have versions for Composite and SVideo switchers.
If anyone has other solutions, please post them here.
1/24/2003 - Update
Several people on a budget have bought some Radio Shack switchers for $40-$60 and say it works fine to feed XBox, PS-DVD players into HDTV's. While I STRONGLY suggest buying a true HD switcher rather than a whole new receiver, these box's are an option:
15-1976 - 4 input, 1 output manual switcher: $40
15-1977 - 4 input, 1 output remote switcher: $60
15-1987 - 6 input, 2 output w/optical remote: $150
(Note: if you are in this price range, you should be looking at the Audio Authority, Inday, Zektor units)
The Keohi Video Switch Comparison
Inday Switcher
Zektor Switcher
The CopperBox Retail Site
The IScan Pro page. This cool device takes Composite or SVideo or Component and up-converts all 3 to 480 progressive. This was THE unit to have before the built-in line doublers on HDTV's became as good as they are today.
The JVC JX-S111 Switcher
2/3/2003 update Here is a link to someone who got the Zektor Switcher. I thought I should include a link.
2/6/2003 Someone else posted a quote from the "Secrets of Home Theater" site about video switching that I thought was on-topic for this thread:
excerpted from the 'Secrets' review of the Anthem AVM-20:
"I, like most of my colleages at Secrets, am not fond of video switchers. Given the option, I will always run video directly from source to display. But with a multi-zone controller as powerful as the AVM-20, it only makes sense to have it. The video switch boasts a published bandwidth of 100Mhz (-3dB) which should be sweet for DVD's 480p. In pro-video circles, 3 to 5 times the bandwidth is regarded as being required for "safe passage", questioning the AVM-20's ability for 1080p material. However, to put it in perspective, not only was I unable to get good enough test equipment to check it but had I, I would have had no 1080p source to test it with! Given that HDTV set top boxes roll off their output anyway, I'm not going to lose sleep over such technicalities."
2/18/03
Someone was kind enough to post a link to a Component Video Distribution Amp : CE Labs AV400C but while it appears to work for Progressive/HD video, it does not appear to specify that it's HD rated.
6/14/03
Here is a link to AV Toolbox AVT-5842 which is a bright green 4-input, 2-output HD switcher. It does not appear to do digital-audio, but does switch L/R audio. Not bad for ~$90.
Someone posted about the Sima Video Converter that not only switches component video, but up-converts composite & SVideo to component. Nice, but in the $800 range.