A decade after carrying home three Academy Awards for the silent classic Seventh Heaven at the first-ever Oscar ceremony, Fox decided to remake one of its greatest films with a new cast and with top-notch production values. The result, while not quite equaling the triumphant dramatic moments of the original movie, offers a fine film with some excellent performances and smooth direction by one of the studio’s stalwarts. Only one key piece of miscasting keeps the film from attaining its own status as a classic film.
Studio: Fox
Distributed By: N/A
Video Resolution and Encode: 480I/MPEG-2
Aspect Ratio: 1.37:1
Audio: English 2.0 DD
Subtitles: None
Rating: Not Rated
Run Time: 1 Hr. 42 Min.
Package Includes: DVD
Amaray caseDisc Type: DVD-R
Region: 1
Release Date: 01/14/2015
MSRP: $19.98
The Production Rating: 3.5/5
The 1922 play by Austin Strong became one of the greatest successes of the silent cinema when it starred Janet Gaynor and Charles Farrell in the 1927 silent version of the Broadway hit (winning Oscars for Gaynor’s performance, Frank Borzage’s direction, and the adaptation by Benjamin Glazer). Melville Baker’s screenplay can’t quite be forthcoming about Diane’s line of work, and the two lovers never get to share a bed together before Chico gets called to war, but all of the emotional high points of the original story are pretty much present and accounted for (Chico’s atheism slowly melting away, Diane’s growing sense of pride and confidence, the tragedy before the ultimate triumph) accompanied by the famous romantic theme song which plays almost continuously once the love story begins to develop. While cinema purists may protest the stagebound sets (Paris outside Chico’s seventh story window is clearly a painted backdrop) and studio backlot locations, but director Henry King makes great use of the studio’s resources. He very economically stages scenes from World War I without spending a king’s ransom, (some of the combat montages were obviously taken from other Fox war films) while the Paris sewers and streets are rather impressive.
The film fails to match the original due to a crucial piece of poor casting: Simone Simon as Diane. She simply hasn’t the requisite skill to dig deeply within herself to make Diane’s transformation from a simpleton gamin, weak and pitiable under the brutal hand of her sadistic sister into a strong, confident woman afraid of no one and convinced in the purity and sanctity of her love. There are feeble glimmers of character that can be spotted occasionally, but opposite James Stewart’s force of nature performance as Chico, she’s basically blown off the screen. Stewart even at this relatively early stage of his film career shows his combination of strength and softness, bold at times and shyly retiring at others, that made him a cinema favorite for almost half a century. Jean Hersholt offers a gentle, knowing performance as Father Chevillon while Gale Sondergaard fresh off her Oscar victory in Anthony Adverse plays the evil Nana with fangs flashing and eyes blazing. J. Edward Bromberg as the interfering astrologer Aristide has one of those roles that is underdeveloped and could just have easily been cut. John Qualen is quite amiable as the sewer rat who’s Chico’s best friend. Famous faces like Gregory Ratoff and Sig Rumann can be found under mounds of hair and make-up and add lots of color to the proceedings.
Video Rating: 2.5/5 3D Rating: NA
Audio Rating: 2.5/5
Special Features Rating: 0/5
Overall Rating: 3/5
Reviewed By: Matt Hough
Support HTF when you buy this title: