The on-going clash of wills between the fiery artist Michelangelo and the equally stubborn warrior Pope Julius II provides the focus of Carol Reed’s The Agony and the Ecstasy adapted from the best selling book by Irving Stone. There isn’t a lot of plot for a movie than runs over two hours, and the constant angry byplay between the two strong-willed men grows tiresome after a time, but the film is sometimes glorious to look at, and if the dramatic impetus sometimes stalls, at least director Reed knows what to do with his camera.
Distributed By: N/A
Video Resolution and Encode: 1080P/AVC
Aspect Ratio: 2.20:1
Audio: English 5.1 DTS-HDMA, Spanish 1.0 DD (Mono), French 2.0 DD, Other
Subtitles: English SDH, Spanish, Other
Rating: Not Rated
Run Time: 2 Hr. 18 Min.
Package Includes: Blu-raykeep case
Disc Type: BD50 (dual layer)
Release Date: 03/04/2014
Busily working on the elaborate tomb and sculptures for Pope Julius II (Rex Harrison), Michelangelo (Charlton Heston) is taken off of that project and assigned to decorate the ceiling of the Pope’s favorite place of worship, the Sistine Chapel. At first commissioned to paint the twelve apostles and fill in empty spaces with anything which suits his fancy, the uncompromising artist quits the project and flees to the quarries after working a short time uninspired by the subject and basically disliking painting as opposed to sculpture. But the Pope is adamant that he complete his commission and when he begs his forgiveness after finally finding inspiration, he’s allowed to return and do what he wishes even though his estimate of six months to a year to complete the work is woefully shortsighted leading to more angry and bitter confrontations between the two as the pope, fighting holy wars to prevent Rome from being overrun, becomes convinced the work will never be finished.Adapted from the Irving Stone novel by Philip Dunne, the screenplay of this historical drama offers some surprises (especially for those who had no idea popes at one time were actual warrior soldiers who eagerly took up the fight for salvation – Rex Harrison’s colorful entrance is indeed an eye-opener) amid the noisy arguments and petty mind games the film’s two primary forces engage in. Director Carol Reed throws in a couple of battle scenes to spell all the arguing and stilted passages where we simply see Michelangelo on his back painting or his assistants mapping out his next piece of ceiling. The artist’s genius is certainly suggested as the script allows him to express in words and body language his frustrations, his inspirations, and his interpretations of what he is doing, but the man’s historically noted sexual orientation is slickly stepped around by inserting the presence of the Contessina de Medici (Diane Cilento) who makes romantic overtures to the artist and is continually turned down not by a lack of feeling but by his consuming passion for his work. All of their scenes together are obvious and often exasperating attempts to inject a female presence into a heavily male-dominated story (she even ludicrously serves as his nurse when months of close work and a lack of proper nutrition lead him to collapse) at the expense of allowing a fuller examination of all aspects of the man’s life (likely the Production Code in its gasping final years of control was partly to blame). But director Reed earns his supper when the camera inevitably tilts upward to show us the results of four long years of labor.Rex Harrison and Charlton Heston both do powerful jobs with the roles as written even if the continual running gag question and answer “When will it be finished?” “When it is finished!” wears out its welcome long before the film is completed. Diane Cilento rather circles around Michelangelo as a panther readying to pounce eyeing him hungrily in their every encounter, but Harry Andrews as the architect Bramante who’s busy with the basilica of St. Peter scores some impressive moments as does Tomas Milian as the young Raphael dangled in front of Michelangelo as his replacement if work on the frescoes isn’t completed in a more timely fashion.
The Production Rating: 3/5
The film’s Todd-AO theatrical aspect ratio of 2.20:1 is faithfully rendered in this colorful 1080p transfer using the AVC codec. Sharpness is simply superb throughout with the opening twelve and a half-minute Cinerama-like prologue showing examples of Michelangelo’s famous sculptures in dizzyingly detailed close-ups a wonder to behold with the various textures so realistic one could almost reach out and touch them. Color is richly presented (reds come through especially well) without ever threatening to go overboard, and flesh tones are natural throughout. Black levels are outstanding with excellent shadow detail. There is an occasional speck or two to be seen fleetingly and a curious bit of pulsating brightness in the scene where the artist is explaining his conception of Adam’s creation to the Pope. The film has been divided into 32 chapters.
Video Rating: 4.5/5 3D Rating: NA
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 sound mix gets an outstanding spread across the front channels with only some occasional spillage into the rear channels and that mostly through the music by Alex North (main feature) and Jerry Goldsmith (the prologue). There is some directionalized dialogue across the front soundstage though most of it has been placed in the center channel and has been well recorded (though ADR in dubbing some of the voices is pretty noticeable). There are a couple of instances of impressive use of bass in the LFE channel, too.
Audio Rating: 4/5
Teaser Trailer (1:15, SD)Theatrical Trailer (3:28, SD)
Special Features Rating: 1/5
Nominated for five Academy Awards for its lush cinematography, costumes, production design, music, and sound, The Agony and the Ecstasy is a mixed bag of historical drama. Though well acted, the pacing is uneven and the plot not sufficiently engaging for the length of its running time. Still, the Blu-ray can’t be much faulted for its presentation of this eye-filling spectacle.
Overall Rating: 3/5
Reviewed By: Matt Hough
Support HTF when you buy this title: