Jump to content



Sign up for a free account to remove the pop-up ads

Signing up for an account is fast and free. As a member you can join in the conversation, enter contests and remove the pop-up ads that guests get. Click here to create your free account.

Photo
Blu-ray Reviews

Bruce Lee: The Legacy Collection Blu-ray Review

Blu-ray Shout Factory

  • You cannot start a new topic
  • Please log in to reply
1 reply to this topic

#1 of 2 OFFLINE   Cameron Yee

Cameron Yee

    Executive Producer



  • 10,752 posts
  • Join Date: May 09 2002
  • Real Name:Cameron Yee
  • LocationSince 2006

Posted November 02 2013 - 12:51 PM

Bruce Lee: The Legacy Collection Blu-ray Review

After a major production delay, Shout! Factory’s Blu-ray collection of Bruce Lee’s Hong Kong films finally arrives on North American store shelves, but was it worth the wait, or has Shout! delivered a swift kick to the aspirations of martial arts fans everywhere?

Posted Image


Studio: Shout! Factory

Distributed By: N/A

Video Resolution and Encode: 1080P/AVC

Aspect Ratio: 2.40:1

Audio: English 5.1 DTS-HDMA, Mandarin 5.1 DTS-HDMA, Other

Subtitles: English

Rating: R

Run Time: 1 Hr. 40 Min. / 1 Hr. 46 Min. / 1 Hr. 39 Min. / 1 Hr. 40 Min.

Package Includes: Blu-ray, DVD

Disc Type: BD50 (dual layer), DVD-9 (dual layer)

Region: A

Release Date: 10/22/2013

MSRP: $119.99




The Production Rating: 4/5

Looking to go beyond his supporting role as The Green Hornet’s Kato, Bruce Lee returned to his childhood home of Hong Kong to finally be cast as a leading man. The runaway success of his first film, The Big Boss, made him a box office sensation in much of Asia, and Fist of Fury and Way of the Dragon quickly followed to try to meet audience demand for more.That unbridled enthusiasm eventually found its way to the United States, where Warner Brothers’ Studio greenlit Enter the Dragon, what would be Lee’s first, legitimate Hollywood feature. Lee’s untimely death just six days before the premiere cut short a career that was only beginning to find its footing with Western audiences, though of course the tragedy propelled Lee’s persona to legendary status, which in turn has kept his films in demand.Assembled in Shout! Factory’s Bruce Lee: The Legacy Collection are the four films originally distributed by Hong Kong movie studio Golden Harvest. The Big Boss and Fist of Fury don’t deviate much from the melodramatic quest for justice / lust for vengeance plots that continue to be martial arts movie tropes. Their cookie cutter stories and leaden pacing are only redeemed by Lee’s high energy fight scenes, which continue to thrill and entertain despite some dated choreography and filming techniques.By comparison, The Way of the Dragon, Lee’s directorial debut, is a breath of fresh air with doses of humor sprinkled among some decidedly superior fight choreography and cinematography. The now epic brawl with Chuck Norris in the Colosseum also doesn’t hurt its cause, becoming a sort of proof-of-concept for Lee’s mythic follow-up, Game of Death. Unfortunately, Lee passed away before completing his archetypal tale of a lone warrior battling his way through seven stages of martial arts hellions, the most famous being basketball star Kareem Abdul-Jabbar. The film that was posthumously completed and released by Golden Harvest in 1978 may bear the same title, but deviates far afield from Lee’s original concept, using but 11 minutes of his original footage and filling in the rest with a hackneyed conspiracy story, obvious body doubles, recycled footage, and, in one instance, a ridiculous cardboard cutout of Lee’s face. Fortunately, a more accurate reflection of his vision is available as a special feature.Still, because Lee’s Golden Harvest films have existed in less than satisfactory forms for almost four decades, it’s a treat to finally have the original versions of the films in high definition (notwithstanding a series of strange production delays). Though the films have far from perfect image quality, at times going from surprisingly good to plain awful, I have no reason to doubt it’s the best technicians had to work with given the age and condition of the movies, which weren’t likely treated with kid gloves in the first place. And in one respect, watching a Bruce Lee film wouldn’t be the same without some kind of grindhouse style artifact.Bruce Lee: The Legacy Collection includes four Blu-rays and seven DVDs with the following contents:
    [*]Disc 1: The Big Boss (DVD)[*]Disc 2: The Big Boss (Blu-ray)[*]Disc 3: Fist of Fury (DVD)[*]Disc 4: Fist of Fury (Blu-ray)[*]Disc 5: The Way of the Dragon (DVD)[*]Disc 6: The Way of the Dragon (Blu-ray)[*]Disc 7: Game of Death (DVD)[*]Disc 8: Game of Death (Blu-ray)[*]Disc 9: Bruce Lee: The Man, the Legend / Bruce Lee: The Legend (DVD)[*]Disc 10: I Am Bruce Lee (DVD)[*]Disc 11: Bonus Features (DVD)[/list]


    Video Rating: 3/5 3D Rating: NA

    Originally slated for release on August 6, 2013, a “production delay” moved the collection’s release date back a month to September 17th, and then again to October 22nd. The setback stemmed from Shout! Factory apparently receiving the wrong (i.e. old) masters from license holder Fortune Star Entertainment, resulting in the films having a noticeably up-converted quality. That people in the production chain didn’t notice the issue early on is befuddling, but whatever the reason, the problem has been addressed, though, as noted earlier, this doesn’t equate to consistently sparkling images.Each of the films has moments when everything comes together nicely, with inky black levels, richly saturated color, spot-on contrast, and fine detail. But just as quickly, all of that can go out the window, whether from inherent flaws in the camera optics, dodgy production techniques, or poorly maintained source elements. Viewers will notice technical problems ranging from fogging (The Big Boss), problematic color and contrast (Fist of Fury and Game of Death), and excessively low resolution (the first 10 minutes of The Way of The Dragon). Of the four films, I’d say The Big Boss and Game of Death look the best. Fist of Fury is a bit of a disappointment because of its consistently flat looking picture and cyan color cast, while Way of the Dragon’s problems are largely isolated to the opening airport scenes, which get so splotchy and low-res they look like an Impressionist painting (fortunately, the rest of the film never gets that bad). Overall, the good tends to outweigh the bad in all the movies, though viewers should be prepared for some, at times dramatic, inconsistencies.
      [*]The Big Boss: 3.5/5[*]Fist of Fury: 2.5/5[*]The Way of the Dragon: 3/5[*]Game of Death: 3.5/5[/list]



      Audio Rating: 3/5

      A variety of audio options are included for each film, but most will prefer the 1.0 Dolby Digital or 2.0 DTS-HD Master Audio tracks. The films’ 5.1 DTS-HD Master Audio options offer seemingly increased clarity and dynamic range, but the surround mixes are ultimately gimmicky and distracting. The English dub tracks on The Big Boss, Fist of Fury, and The Way of the Dragon are entertaining in their way, but ultimately hard to bear over the films’ entirety.With the exception of the last film, the following evaluations are based on the Cantonese mono tracks, based on that dialect being the dominant one spoken in Hong Kong and thus by the majority of the cast (even though all dialogue was looped in post, per production practices at the time). For Game of Death, I opted for the English mono track.Generally speaking, each of the tracks gets the job done with the occasional moment of distortion, strain and/or hiss. LFE is absent, but bass extension and dynamic range are decent given the audio productions’ vintage and budget.The Big Boss: 2.5/5
        [*]Original Mandarin Mono[*]Mandarin DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1[*]English DTS Mono (U.S. Dub)[*]Cantonese Mono[*]Rare English Dub Never Heard Before[/list]Fist of Fury: 2.5/5Note: Shout! Factory recently announced a trade-in program for theFist of Fury Blu-ray because the Mandarin mono track can’t be selected. Email info@shoutfactory.com to get a replacement, if desired.
          [*]Original Mandarin Mono[*]Mandarin DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1[*]Cantonese Mono[*]Cantonese DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1[*]English Mono[*]English DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1[/list]The Way of the Dragon: 2.5/5
            [*]Mandarin Mono[*]Mandarin DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1[*]Cantonese Mono[*]Cantonese Dolby Digital 5.1[*]English Mono (U.S. Dub)[*]English Mono (Japanese Theatrical)[*]English DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1[/list]Game of Death: 3/5
              [*]English DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1[*]English DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0[*]English Mono[*]English Mono (Japanese Theatrical)[/list]


              Special Features Rating: 5/5

              Earning high marks for sheer quantity, if not quality, the bonus material includes almost every conceivable kind of extra, short of a set of nunchucks and a yellow track suit.Viewers will ultimately get the most out of the numerous interviews with those who knew Lee himself, like Bob Wall, Gene Lebell, Dan Inosanto, and Lee's childhood friend William Cheung.The number of biographical documentaries included may be a little overwhelming at first, but start with the newest - I Am Bruce Lee, located on Disc 10 - which includes even more from the legend's colleagues and surviving family members.Finally, be sure to check out Game of Death Revisited, a recut of original footage that more closely follows Lee's original vision for the film.Collectible Book and Packaging: Measuring 11.5” x 8” x 1”, the packaging holds all 11 optical discs in top-loading, die-cut cardboard sleeves. A 64-page pictorial section includes a biography, production stills, profiles on each film in the collection, and various bits of trivia. Though the set is handsomely printed and sturdy, the discs are often difficult to remove from their sleeves, requiring a bit of muscle to extract them. However, given the cardboard construction, I imagine things will loosen up over time.Disc 1: The Big Boss (DVD)
                [*]Mirrors the bonus features on Disc 2[/list]Disc 2: The Big Boss (Blu-ray)
                  [*]Audio Commentary with Hong Kong Film Expert Mike Leeder[*]Trailers (17:27, HD)[*]U.S. TV Spots (1:15, HD)[*]Alternate Title Sequence (4:45, HD)[*]Alternate Finale (:43, HD): The censored version showing less blood and violence.[*]Return to Pak Chong: The Big Boss Revisited (9:26, HD): Martial Artist Daniel Whyte talks about his pilgrimage to Pak Chong, Thailand, the town where The Big Boss was filmed, and how he was inspired by Lee.[*]Bruce Lee: The Early Years (13:51, HD): Legendary stuntman and martial artist Gene Lebell talks about how he first met Lee and their subsequent friendship and professional collaboration.[*]Interview with Tung Wai (2:37, SD): The Hong Kong director reflects on his first impressions of Lee and the significance of the late martial artist’s physical abilities.[*]Rare Scene Extensions (2:22, HD)[*]Bruce Lee vs. Peter Thomas (2:27, HD): An explanation of the film soundtrack adapted for Western markets.[*]Still Gallery (4:30, HD): Production and promotional photographs and a variety of posters.[/list]Disc 3: Fist of Fury (DVD)
                    [*]Mirrors the bonus features on Disc 4[/list]Disc 4: Fist of Fury (Blu-ray)
                      [*]Audio Commentary with Hong Kong Film Expert Mike Leeder[*]Trailers (4:10, HD)[*]U.S. TV Spot (1:05, HD)[*]Alternate Title Sequence (7:31, HD)[*]Alternate Ending (1:23, HD)[*]Remembering Fist of Fury (30:45, HD): Actor Jason Tobin and Director Isaac Florentine reflect on how they were inspired by Lee.[*]Interview with Yuen Wah (9:40, HD): The Hong Kong actor talks about how he started learning martial arts and his work with Lee.[*]Still Gallery (3:41, HD): Production and promotional photographs and a variety of posters.[/list]Disc 5: The Way of the Dragon (DVD)
                        [*]Mirrors the bonus features on Disc 6[/list]Disc 6: The Way of the Dragon (Blu-ray)
                          [*]Audio Commentary with Hong Kong Film Expert Mike Leeder[*]Trailers (2:09, HD)[*]U.S. TV Spot (:25, HD)[*]Alternate Title Sequences (4:51, HD)[*]Celebrity Interviews including Sammo Hung, Simon Yam, and Wong Jing (4:33, HD)[*]Kung Fu? Jon Benn Remembers the Shooting of the Film (21:40, HD): The actor who played the Boss reflects on meeting and working with Lee.[*]Still Gallery (2:16, HD): Production and promotional photographs and a variety of posters.[/list]Disc 7: Game of Death (DVD)
                            [*]Mirrors the bonus features on Disc 8, with the exception of the Japanese Print in HD[/list]Disc 8: Game of Death (Blu-ray)
                              [*]Audio Commentary with Hong Kong Film Expert Mike Leeder[*]Trailers (5:21, HD)[*]Still Gallery (2:58, HD): Production and promotional photographs and a variety of posters.[*]Game of Death Outtake Montage (3:38, HD)[*]Game of Death Bloopers (2:59, HD)[*]Game of Death Revisited (38:58, HD): All the original footage re-cut to fit Lee’s vision for the story.[*]Alternate Opening (1:55, HD)[*]Alternate Endings (5:13, HD)[*]Deleted Scenes (5:39, HD)[*]Game of Death Locations (7:26, HD): Comparisons of film locations, then and now.[*]Japanese Print in HD (1:39:51, HD): The Japanese cut of the film, in its entirety.[/list]Disc 9: Documentaries (DVD)1970s-era documentaries produced by Hong Kong studios following Lee's untimely death are interesting as time capsules, but aren't particularly definitive in their scope.
                                [*]Bruce Lee: The Man, the Legend (1:25:59)[*]Bruce Lee: The Legend (1:22:40)[/list]Disc 10: I Am Bruce Lee (1:34:00) (DVD)Considering the documentary was released on Blu-ray, it would have been nice if Shout! Factory had included it instead of the DVD version. Nevertheless, the film is worthwhile viewing. See my review of the Blu-ray edition.Disc 11: Bonus Features (DVD)
                                  [*]Game of Death Revised (28:46): Bob Wall talks about his time shooting Game of Death.[*]Way of the Dragon (13:38): Bob Wall talks about his time shooting Way of the Dragon.[*]Master of the Game (25:12): Dan Inosanto talks about his martial arts and friendship with Lee.[*]Legacy of the Dragon (46:48): 2001 documentary made for British television.[*]The Grandmaster and the Dragon (54:36): 2009 Australian documentary interviews Grandmaster William Cheung, Lee’s childhood friend and martial arts training partner, hoping to shed some light on Lee’s early life and his kung fu philosophy.[*]Return of the Dragon in 60 Seconds (1:00): Fake film trailer imagines a Bruce Lee in the modern era. Find out more at Vimeo.[*]Bruce Lee Remembered (50:55): Interviews with actors Anthony DeLongis, Byron Mann, Dustin Nguyen; writer/director Gareth Evans; and Inside Kung Fu writer Jason McNeil.[*]Fist of Fury Interviews (43:21): Interviews with Nora Miao, Riki Hashimoto, and Jun Katsumura, supporting players from Fist of Fury.[*]Still Galleries: Eleven separate galleries titled Bruce Lee Gallery (4:48), Bruce Lee the Legend (:43), Enter the Dragon (4:36), EP Covers (4:31), Fist of Fury (4:34), Game of Death (4:00), The Green Hornet (4:00), Marlowe (3:19), The Big Boss (4:13), Way of the Dragon (4:31), and Various Stills (3:58).[/list]


                                  Overall Rating: 4/5

                                  Shout! Factory’s Bruce Lee: The Legacy Collection has been a long time coming, not just in terms of the title finally making it to North American store shelves after a major production delay, but in gathering together Lee’s Golden Harvest films in one definitive, high definition package. For the most part the release fulfills its promise; though it may not have the most consistent image or sound quality, the inconsistency also shouldn’t come as a surprise for anyone who’s familiar with ‘70s-era Hong Kong cinema (and most should be surprised the films look as good as they do). More critically is that the films are presented in their original, unedited forms and with original language options intact. That the set includes a plethora of archival supplements is another boon to the title, though it may ultimately hold less appeal for Lee’s more casual fans.


                                  Reviewed By: Cameron Yee


                                  Support HTF when you buy this title:



#2 of 2 OFFLINE   Russell G

Russell G

    Fake Shemp



  • 10,226 posts
  • Join Date: Sep 20 2002
  • Real Name:Russell
  • LocationDeadmonton

Posted November 02 2013 - 09:28 PM

Thanks for the review. Hard to believe that with all the delays, there's still a disc exchange happening.

 

I'm not in a rush on this one, but if it hits a good sale I'll grab it to replace my old DVD set.







Also tagged with one or more of these keywords: Blu-ray Reviews, Blu-ray, Shout Factory

0 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users