Does anyone else remember the Pushing Daisies
episode that was a tribute to this film?
Originally Posted by classicmovieguy
I picked up the Blu-ray yesterday and watched the entire thing last night - the sound to me was very flat and muddy, and I do prefer the old 'High Flying' DVD edition's soundtrack. Also, am I alone in seeing a bit of green tinge to most of the darker, nighttime scenes?
I finally watched it a couple days ago, and I agree with you about the sound, although the high ends have always been kind of lacking. The songs sound a lot better on the soundtrack album. How does it compare to the French track?
On the other hand, the picture is (mostly) stellar, good enough to reveal the generation loss from the process shots. There are some mistakes with the sodium vapor shots that Disney could theoretically go back and redo (especially in the scene with Paul in his boat), but chose not to. Some of the coloring did seem a little odd to my eyes, and the first scene, which I have always assumed was supposed to take place in the early evening, was just way too bright compared to any video version I've seen. But the sharpness blows all past versions out of the water, and you can actually read the writing on the Gogans' bill of sale.
Originally Posted by Dick
"I always thought Elliot bore a remarkable resemblance to Dame Margaret Rutherford..."
Good one, Mark, and I agree! Nice catch.
There are things about this film I like well enough to have purchased the Blu, and the image looks fine. "Candle On the Water" is the best sequence in the film for me, and some of the choreography is good. But the characters are either way-y over the top, like the villains, or rather bland, like the kid and the heroes. And the titular dragon.
The worst element of the film in my opinion is Elliot. First, the particular shade of green he was painted in has always bugged me... a sort of dull olive that I find irritating. Second, he was designed to look and behave like a doofus. Yes, I realize the film had to be family-friendly and the dragon could not be frightening the way that Vermithrax Pejorative was in the Disney co-production of DRAGONSLAYER (which, by the way, Paramount, is where...?), but couldn't he have appeared at least a bit more, well...imposing? It was hard to take Dame Margaret Rutherford seriously (and we weren't meant to), and it's hard to take Ellot seriously. Since I couldn't, I found it hard to believe the characters got all in a tizzy about him.
As a side note, I am getting an error message of late when I try to quote a prior post. "There was a problem submitting this to the server. Please try again." Is anyone else experience this?
The one major reservation I have about the film is the editing: some of the cuts were made very haphazardly (the cut after Lampie says "good boy, good lad" is especially sloppy), and some of the shots seem to go on about a second too long. I felt this way when I was a child, too. Watch the "Brazzle Dazzle Effects" supplement and listen to its soundtrack. It uses the film's underscore extensively (an expanded soundtrack would be nice; perhaps Intrada will get around to it someday), and it has several bars of the dance sequence from "There's Room For Everyone" that are nowhere to be heard in the film. Things like that (not to mention the fact that this happened to at least two of the studio's prior musicals) what lends credence to the as-yet-unconfirmed idea that the studio cut the film (that and the soundtrack album's extra lyrics to "I Saw a Dragon" and "Passamashloddy").
As for Elliott not being frightening, I always thought that was the point. The whole film's plot depends on him not being frightening and the people of Passamaquoddy being irrational enough to be frightened by him. Even at the end of the film, they continue to believe that causation equals correlation regarding the temporary fish shortage ("he filled the ocean full of fish, he packed it to the brim"), and they fall for Doctor Terminus' patent medicines twice. If Elliott, who also seems to be somewhat deficient in basic social skills, posed a threat to anyone not deliberately harming a child, the people of Passamaquoddy (which, when you think about it, is a pretty sordid town underneath the surface of those fine John Mansbridge/Jack Martin Smith sets) would be justified in being afraid of him.
All in all, I'm glad it came out, but the disc feels like a compromise considering how many extras were left off past versions. And between this, Pocahontas
and, most likely, Muppet Christmas Carol
, we're gonna need to hold onto our old Disney DVDs and laserdiscs if we want all the extras.
Here's a little article about the film's production with some interesting tidbits:
Don Bluth The Disney Years: Pete's Dragon