- Joined
- Feb 8, 1999
- Messages
- 18,409
- Real Name
- Robert Harris
In typical Warner Bros. fashion, their home video alchemists seem to have taken a piece of what is now a creaky old Blu-ray edition, The Stanley Kubrick Limited Edition Collection, released back in May of 2011, fashioned it with eye of newt, finger of mummy and ear of flea, and created a totally new release, forever to be known as the Full Metal Jacket 25th Anniversary Book.
I like the name. The words flow rather nicely. The new book is cute, 44 whole pages of terrific stuff. And then there's the super-special extra disc -- DVD by the way, and not Blu-ray, of the 2008 48 minute documentary, using lots hof footage we've seen elsewhere -- or have I seen this before? -- and that's it.
Here's the rub.
You can buy, and I'm using Amazon prices, The SK Collection - virtually every film made by SK - 9 in all, and all quality Blu-ray discs, with the exception of Spartacus, which is garbage, for $100. That's about $11 a disc. And not a bad deal.
Of course, if one is a true collector and collector of all things Kubrick, there the HD-DVD from 2006, the original Blu-ray, also 2006, the Full Metal Jacket Limited Edition Collector's Set (2001), the Full Metal Jacket Deluxe Edition HD-DVD (2007), various and sundry other DVDs and boxed sets, and now the super-special 25th Anniversary Book Edition.
Funny thing is, Warner Bros. has myriads of other films that should be out on Blu-ray, which aren't showing up.
It has a really pretty cover, same as the 2007 Blu-ray, but I'm just not seeing what he's seeing. There's new artwork on the disc, which makes no difference to me one way or the other.
But here's what my eyes are telling me about this splashy new edition, labeled by the way as "All-New Remastered Feature on Blu-ray for the First Time!"
I'm going to use a highly technical archival term, and I don't want anyone to get lost.
Bul**hit!
To these eyes, the transfer looks precisely like the previous Blu-ray. I tried to look for a single frame bit of damage in the "I love you sooo long" scene, but didn't want to waste the time. Bottom line is that if you already own any of the previous high definition releases, you don't need this one. If you've not purchased the Kubrick boxed set (please don't admit it publicly, if you've not) and you still have a desire to own FMJ, buy the 2007 edition for $15.
Did I mention that the feature disc has different artwork than that of the boxed set?
Here's a trick. Please don't try it at home, without professionals standing by. The ownership of HTF denies all potential liability.
Take the old disc, place it carefully in your Blu-ray player. Don't scratch it, and please make certain that you're using a new thorn.
Play it for a bit. Move forward a few chapters. Just let it play.
And then pop it out of your player. Set that disc aside, take the brand new disc, and place that in the same player. Don't go to a different player. It must be the same one.
Allow it to spin up.
Funny thing about the newly re-mastered Full Metal Jacket. It goes to precisely the same spot at which the older disc was removed, as if the very same disc had been removed and then replaced. See where this is going?
Same menus, same content, same transfer, same master.
Now here's the kicker, and my final thoughts and recommendation.
Great film. Nice transfer.
I can think of no reason why Warner would waste their time on a release like this one.
RAH
I like the name. The words flow rather nicely. The new book is cute, 44 whole pages of terrific stuff. And then there's the super-special extra disc -- DVD by the way, and not Blu-ray, of the 2008 48 minute documentary, using lots hof footage we've seen elsewhere -- or have I seen this before? -- and that's it.
Here's the rub.
You can buy, and I'm using Amazon prices, The SK Collection - virtually every film made by SK - 9 in all, and all quality Blu-ray discs, with the exception of Spartacus, which is garbage, for $100. That's about $11 a disc. And not a bad deal.
Of course, if one is a true collector and collector of all things Kubrick, there the HD-DVD from 2006, the original Blu-ray, also 2006, the Full Metal Jacket Limited Edition Collector's Set (2001), the Full Metal Jacket Deluxe Edition HD-DVD (2007), various and sundry other DVDs and boxed sets, and now the super-special 25th Anniversary Book Edition.
Funny thing is, Warner Bros. has myriads of other films that should be out on Blu-ray, which aren't showing up.
It has a really pretty cover, same as the 2007 Blu-ray, but I'm just not seeing what he's seeing. There's new artwork on the disc, which makes no difference to me one way or the other.
But here's what my eyes are telling me about this splashy new edition, labeled by the way as "All-New Remastered Feature on Blu-ray for the First Time!"
I'm going to use a highly technical archival term, and I don't want anyone to get lost.
Bul**hit!
To these eyes, the transfer looks precisely like the previous Blu-ray. I tried to look for a single frame bit of damage in the "I love you sooo long" scene, but didn't want to waste the time. Bottom line is that if you already own any of the previous high definition releases, you don't need this one. If you've not purchased the Kubrick boxed set (please don't admit it publicly, if you've not) and you still have a desire to own FMJ, buy the 2007 edition for $15.
Did I mention that the feature disc has different artwork than that of the boxed set?
Here's a trick. Please don't try it at home, without professionals standing by. The ownership of HTF denies all potential liability.
Take the old disc, place it carefully in your Blu-ray player. Don't scratch it, and please make certain that you're using a new thorn.
Play it for a bit. Move forward a few chapters. Just let it play.
And then pop it out of your player. Set that disc aside, take the brand new disc, and place that in the same player. Don't go to a different player. It must be the same one.
Allow it to spin up.
Funny thing about the newly re-mastered Full Metal Jacket. It goes to precisely the same spot at which the older disc was removed, as if the very same disc had been removed and then replaced. See where this is going?
Same menus, same content, same transfer, same master.
Now here's the kicker, and my final thoughts and recommendation.
Great film. Nice transfer.
I can think of no reason why Warner would waste their time on a release like this one.
RAH