- Joined
- Jul 3, 1997
- Messages
- 66,786
- Real Name
- Ronald Epstein
Originally Posted by cafink
When Watchmen was initially released on Blu-ray, I had planned to purchase both the U.S. and U.K. releases in order to get both cuts of the film, but decided to hold off, knowing that an extended version was coming and figuring that it'd probably be part of a comprehensive release.
I'm disappointed to see that this release does not appear to be that comprehensive release, as the above ad mentions neither the theatrical version (except as a "digital copy," about which I am completely apathetic) nor the director's cut.
I think a better question is why bother posting in this thread at all if you didn't like the movie?Originally Posted by Ben Cheshire
I wonder if the ultimate cut will add even more unnecessary footage, turning an already bloated and indulgent director's cut into a movie that can actually make time stand still. Or perhaps it can add in more scenes of giant blu penises, or make the disappointingly puncy bad guy even less intimidating.
Why bother with this dross when The Incredibles said everything it said, but funnier and much more efficiently.
I never said that this release is not what it claims to be, or that its advertisement was misleading. I'm just disappointed that it's not what I'd hoped to get from the next Watchmen release.Originally Posted by TonyD
this release doesn't claim to be comprehensive.
It claims to be the ultimate cut.
this release is exactly as advertised.
Originally Posted by Ben Cheshire
I guess I also posted here because I kind of feel bad that so many other people like the movie and I just didn't. At all.
Some speculation: At that price point, I think this is mostly for hard core fans. That number sounds like it will meet demand, and making it limited creates a sense of urgency that will push people who might otherwise have waited for a lower price.Originally Posted by Sam Favate
One report says this edition is limited to 70,000. Why? If people want to buy it, make more!