Is 2009 the best year ever for movies? (1 Viewer)

cineMANIAC · Aug 21, 2009

It all began with May's Star Trek reboot and will end grandly with Avatar. 2009 may be the best year ever for big-scale film (and some very good small ones):

Terminator Salvation. I wasn't disappointed with it, to say the least
Moon. A great little sci-fi drama that nobody saw
District 9. Finally, an original storyline and highly entertaining
and coming up:

Possibly the best WWII movie ever made: Inglorious Bastards
You want a slasher movie? Check. Halloween II
Looking for a Disaster flick to end all disaster flicks? 2012. Amazing trailer
Post-Apocalyptic angst? The Road
Need some mystery thrills? Check. Shutter Island
Sci-fi Action? Take your pick: Whiteout, Pandorum
Sc-fi thrillers your game? Go see The Surrogates
Then there's the remake of one of the best episodes of the 80's version of The Twilight Zone: The Box.

I don't remember anything pre-summer but, man, what a lineup!

Chuck Mayer · Aug 21, 2009

In recent years, 2003 had two Matrix films, Return of the King, Pirates 1, Master and Commander, and Nemo. 2009 doesn't come close.

And the word angst and the Road really don't go together. And I'd argue that Inglorious Basterds won't unseat Patton or several other movies anytime soon. It might be the best WWII fantasy film ever.

Pre-summer did have Watchmen.

Andrew Pierce · Aug 21, 2009

IMO, 2009 can't touch 1999, which was for my money the greatest year of movies thus far. Check out the embarasment of riches -- Bear in mind all of the the first three were, at the time, untainted by disappointing followups:

The Matrix
The Mummy
The Sixth Sense
Fight Club
American Beauty
Office Space
The Iron Giant
Toy Story 2
Three Kings
Sunshine
Being John Malkovich
Galaxy Quest
Election
Payback
EdTV
Idle Hands
Stuart Little
Go
Girl, Interrupted
Man on the Moon
The Boondock Saints
The Limey
The Talented Mr Ripley
South Park: B,L,U
The Insider
Eyes Wide Shut

Charles Knox · Aug 21, 2009

Originally Posted by Luisito34

It all began with May's Star Trek reboot and will end grandly with Avatar. 2009 may be the best year ever for big-scale film (and some very good small ones):

Terminator Salvation. I wasn't disappointed with it, to say the least
Moon. A great little sci-fi drama that nobody saw
District 9. Finally, an original storyline and highly entertaining
and coming up:

Possibly the best WWII movie ever made: Inglorious Bastards
You want a slasher movie? Check. Halloween II
Looking for a Disaster flick to end all disaster flicks? 2012. Amazing trailer
Post-Apocalyptic angst? The Road
Need some mystery thrills? Check. Shutter Island
Sci-fi Action? Take your pick: Whiteout, Pandorum
Sc-fi thrillers your game? Go see The Surrogates
Then there's the remake of one of the best episodes of the 80's version of The Twilight Zone: The Box.

I don't remember anything pre-summer but, man, what a lineup!

2008's offerings have eclipsed this year's by a mile. Outside of UP, I was really let down this year movie wise. To answer your question, the best movie year ever has to be 1939. No other year will ever compare to that year.

Zack Gibbs · Aug 21, 2009

I'd say it's been one of the weakest years in a long long time, and I know I'm not alone.

Adam Lenhardt · Aug 21, 2009

Originally Posted by Zack Gibbs

I'd say it's been one of the weakest years in a long long time, and I know I'm not alone.

I was thinking the same thing. This year has definitely had its share of gems -- the quite possibly the best Harry Potter of them all, The Hangover, Watchmen, Knowing, Star Trek, and some great smaller films, -- and with Avatar looks set to finish with a bang. But this year has high an unusually high dud to success ratio.

mattCR · Aug 21, 2009

This has been a good year. But in my mind, nothing can replace 1994:

Hoop Dreams
Forest Gump
Nell
Ed Wood
Shawshank Redemption
Pulp Fiction
Bullets over Broadway
Four Weddings and a Funeral
Heavenly Creatures
Lion King
Hudsucker Proxy
Quiz Show

1994 to me stands out because it has so many films that to this day I don't view as just "good" but "incredible" film efforts.
But 2009 has been good so far

I was VERY dissappointed by the trailer for "The Road" which appears as though someone has NO real understanding of the book.. and when was it decided that this would be declared as an

environmental disaster, as it is proclaimed in the trailer, they'd ad gun battles with road gangs.. I don't remember ANY of that form the book, at all.

Ray H · Aug 21, 2009

Originally Posted by mattCR

I was VERY dissappointed by the trailer for "The Road" which appears as though someone has NO real understanding of the book.. and when was it decided that this would be declared as an

environmental disaster, as it is proclaimed in the trailer, they'd ad gun battles with road gangs.. I don't remember ANY of that form the book, at all.

I wouldn't be too worried. The Weinstein Company doesn't know how to sell the movie, so they're pulling a bait and switch ad compaign, which will probably piss off people who go to see the movie expecting one thing and getting something else entirely.

Aug 22, 2009

The best years for movies IMO were: 1939 (Gone With the Wind, The Wizard of Oz, Mr. Smith Goes to Washington, Stagecoach, The Women, and MANY more) , 1951, 1967, 1977, 1980, 1994, and 2001.

Kevin Lamb · Aug 23, 2009

1982 had one heck of a lineup:

E.T. The Extra-Terrestrial
Blade Runner
Tootsie

Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan

Poltergeist

Ghandi

First Blood

The Dark Crystal

Tron
Rocky III
Conan the Barbarian

The Secret of Nimh

Sam Favate · Aug 24, 2009

Originally Posted by Luisito34
Need some mystery thrills? Check. Shutter Island

Shutter Island has been delayed until February 2010.

This year has had some good movies, but overall, I'd say it's pretty weak in comparison to other years. Everyone will have their favorite year, depending on the kinds of films you like and what the marketplace meant for those kinds of films at a given time.

I found this year to be pretty weak, especially this summer. With the exception of Star Trek and Up, I haven't seen any films I'd consider great. Public Enemies was good, but not great. Many films were just too disappointing. The writers strike created this situation - studios have delayed some of their good films to have something to compete with this summer (Star Trek is a prime example) but film slates are pretty slim because the strike left fewer films in development. Add to that the economic downturn and you have a weak crop.

Chad R · Aug 24, 2009

Originally Posted by Luisito34

It all began with May's Star Trek reboot and will end grandly with Avatar. 2009 may be the best year ever for big-scale film (and some very good small ones):

Terminator Salvation. I wasn't disappointed with it, to say the least
Moon. A great little sci-fi drama that nobody saw
District 9. Finally, an original storyline and highly entertaining
and coming up:

Possibly the best WWII movie ever made: Inglorious Bastards
You want a slasher movie? Check. Halloween II
Looking for a Disaster flick to end all disaster flicks? 2012. Amazing trailer
Post-Apocalyptic angst? The Road
Need some mystery thrills? Check. Shutter Island
Sci-fi Action? Take your pick: Whiteout, Pandorum
Sc-fi thrillers your game? Go see The Surrogates
Then there's the remake of one of the best episodes of the 80's version of The Twilight Zone: The Box.

I don't remember anything pre-summer but, man, what a lineup!

Curious that most of the movies on your list have yet to come out and consequently not been seen. Therefore it's hard to declare this year "the best" based on trailers and pre-release hype.

Steve_Tk · Aug 24, 2009

I'd say this year has been bordline between terrible and very terrible. I enjoyed Star Trek though.

Todd H · Aug 24, 2009

Gotta agree with Steve. It's been a terrible year so far. The only two movies I've really enjoyed are Star Trek and Inglourious Basterds. I hope the end of the year is better than the summer has been.

Walter Kittel · Aug 24, 2009

I'll wait until the end of the year to evaluate 2009, which has been hit and miss for me personally.

In terms of best years for cinema, I agree with the previous selections of 1939 and 1982 (two of my favorite years) and would add 1996 to the mix with:

Angels and Insects
Breaking the Waves
Bound
The English Patient
Fargo
Fly Away Home
Hamlet
Lone Star
Microcosmos
Secrets and Lies
Shine
Sling Blade
Sydney (Hard Eight)
Trainspotting
- Walter

cineMANIAC · Aug 24, 2009

I kind of jumped the gun by declaring 2009 the best year ever. I guess I got carried away by trailers for upcoming films (Avatar, The Road) plus there are several films I've seen this year that I consider to be very good, more than in recent times. My main criteria for judging films is that they have to be infinitely watchable, in other words, they need to have a very high re-watch value. This is why I'm changing my best year ever award to 1982. Thanks Kevin for reminding me.

zackscott5 · Aug 25, 2009

I would definately declare 2009 a good year for smaller films but as a whole in general, 2009 pales in comparison with 1939, 1982, 1999, and 2001.

TheBat · Aug 25, 2009

I have to say that 1989 is my favorite year for movies.

batman 89
indy 3
lethal weapon 2
when harry met sally
parenthood
the abyss

and many more.

Jacob

Brett_M · Aug 25, 2009

Originally Posted by Kevin Lamb

1982 had one heck of a lineup:

E.T. The Extra-Terrestrial
Blade Runner
Tootsie

Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan

Poltergeist

Ghandi

First Blood

The Dark Crystal

Tron
Rocky III
Conan the Barbarian

The Secret of Nimh

Agreed.

Doug Ennis · Aug 25, 2009

Of recent years (this decade), I think that 2004 is the best:

Personal all-time favorites:
Garden State
Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind
Life Aquatic with Steve Zissou
Before Sunset

Other good or great movies:
Aviator
Bourne Supremacy
Closer
Collateral
Dawn of the Dead
Dreamers
Finding Neverland
Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban
Hellboy
Hotel Rwanda
I Heart Huckabees
Incredibles
Kill Bill V2
Million Dollar Baby (not a big fan personally, but critically acclaimed)
Miracle
Ray (not a fan personally, but critically acclaimed)
Shaun of the Dead
Sideways
Spider-man 2

Home Theater

Entertainment & Streaming Content

Physical Media

Home Theater Equipment and Hardware

Other Diversions

Bargains and Classifieds

Home Theater Forum

Archives

Is 2009 the best year ever for movies? (1 Viewer)

Stunt Coordinator

Agent

Screenwriter

Second Unit

Go Dawgs!

Stunt Coordinator

Screenwriter

Stunt Coordinator

Similar threads

Users who are viewing this thread

Sign up for our newsletter

and receive essential news, curated deals, and much more

Similar Threads

Forum statistics