Jump to content

Sign up for a free account to remove the pop-up ads

Signing up for an account is fast and free. As a member you can join in the conversation, enter contests and remove the pop-up ads that guests get. Click here to create your free account.

DVD Reviews


  • You cannot start a new topic
  • Please log in to reply
7 replies to this topic

#1 of 8 OFFLINE   Ken_McAlinden



  • 6,154 posts
  • Join Date: Feb 20 2001
  • Real Name:Kenneth McAlinden
  • LocationLivonia, MI USA

Posted January 11 2009 - 10:39 PM


Directed By: Ed Harris

Starring: Viggo Mortensen, Ed Harris, Renée Zellweger, Jeremy Irons, Timothy Spall, Lance Henriksen

Studio: Warner Brothers

Year: 2008

Rated: R

Film Length: 115 minutes

Aspect Ratio: 2.35:1 and 4:3 reformatted

Subtitles: English SDH, Spanish

Release Date: January 13, 2008

The Film

Director/star/co-writer/producer Ed Harris' Appaloosa concerns 1880s lawmen for hire Virgil Cole (Harris) and Everett Hitch (Mortensen). When the Sheriff of the small southwestern town of Appaloosa is shot while trying to arrest two employees of wealthy, politically connected citizen Randall Bragg (Irons), the town Aldermen desperately turn to Hitch and Cole, giving them carte blanche as the new town Marshals. Cole and Hitch prove to be a brutally efficient team when it comes to imposing law and order, not hesitating to butt heads with Bragg and his men. Their near wordless chemistry, born from years of working together, is tested when widow Allison "Ally" French (Zellweger) arrives in town and takes up with Virgil.

For his second film as a director, Ed Harris goes off in quite a different direction from Pollack, adapting Robert B. Parker's novel into a relatively straightforward western. The film is not afraid to touch on a lot of familiar western elements (sinister wealthy landowner, desperate town hiring sheriff for his violence skills, locomotive ambush, Indian siege of isolated group on frontier, "High Noon"/"OK Corral" style showdown, Lonesome Dove-style "bromantic" relationship between its protagonists,mano-a-mano pistol duel outside a saloon, unfathomable woman, etc.), and that is not necessarily a bad thing. Four decades or so along since The Wild Bunch and McCabe and Mrs. Miller and over 15 years since Unforgiven, a non-elegiac western with minimal to no post-modernism seems almost like a bold new direction.

Despite so many familiar genre elements, Appaloosa distinguishes itself by its attention to details of both period and character. The production design and costuming feels authentic. Viggo Mortensen's facial hair is so ridiculous that one assumes it had to be based in reality (The "Gettysburg" effect!). Other than some questionable variations in the accents and dialects of some of the actors through the course of the film, one feels properly immersed in the illusion of the films late 19th century reality.

The various armed confrontations are also staged in a way that feels authentic. By way of illustration, a lot of the scenes revolve around the suspense inherent to the potential of violence rather than having characters drawing their guns at every opportunity. On top of that, when a gun battle does occur, it commences suddenly and is over quickly, with no one who is established as a skilled gunfighter all of a sudden becomes a lousy shot just because they are a bad guy.

The film falls short of being a complete success from what I surmise is a weakness in its adaptation. The original novel was a first person narrative written from the perspective of the Hitch character. Empathizing with Hitch and understanding his perspective is critical for the film's conclusion to play out properly. While the screenplay was constructed so that almost no scenes aside from the prologue play out from a perspective that Hitch could not observe personally, the relative reticence of Hitch and Cole and Hitch's deference to Cole in most situations leads to a more balanced perspective than the novel. As such, the viewer experiences things from what feels like both of their points of view. This probably could have been addressed with a few more scenes between Hitch and his female companion, which are the only relatively unguarded moments where he gets to talk about his relationship with Cole when he is not in the scene. In any case, this lack of identification with Hitch in the first two acts of the film robs the final act of some of its impact. In many ways, the third act, which is told more specifically from Hitch's point of view and telescopes the passage of time, feels like it comes from a different movie than what has gone before.

The Video

The 16:9 enhanced 2.35:1 transfer and encoding shares a single side of a dual-layered disc with a reformatted 4:3 presentation (unreviewed by me) and all of the disc's extras. Given that limitation, I was surprised by how good the widescreen presentation looked. It appears that the film was very carefully compressed with some judicious filtering here and there resulting in a virtually artifact free image. Detail suffers a bit on larger displays due to the filtering, and there are occasional instances of ringing along high contrast edges, but it is otherwise an excellent rendering of Harris and cinematographer Dean Semler's carefully composed images.

The Audio

The Dolby Digital 5.1 audio track presents the theatrical mix with excellent fidelity. The film has a very subtle and dynamic mix which is repurposed nicely for the home environment. As previously mentioned, the action and suspense sequences in the film are as much about the potential for violence as actual gunplay, and the mix leaves plenty of dynamic headroom so that the handful of moments where gunfire actually erupts are extremely impactful. The mix does not use the surround channels for much more than light ambient support for music and effects.

The Extras

When disc one is first spun up, the viewer is greeted with the following series of skippable promos. All are presented in 4:3 video, letterboxed when appropriate, with Dolby Digital 2.0 stereo sound unless indicated otherwise:
  • Anti-Piracy PSA with clips from Casablanca (1:00)
  • DVDTrailer for Snow Angels (2:09)
  • Video Game Promo for Tomb Raider: Underworld (2:08)
  • DVD/BD Trailer for Bam Margera Presents: Where the #$&% is Santa (1:38)
  • Warner Blu-Ray Promo (Dolby Digital 5.1 Sound - 1:09)
  • Anti-Smoking PSA telling you that smoking is not as cool as tobacco companies tell you (:34)
The first proper listed extra is a Commentary by Ed Harris and Screenwriter/Producer Robert Knott. Harris goes solo for the first 53 minutes or so after which he is joined by Knott. Harris is soft spoken, almost to the point that I had to strain to hear him over the low level film soundtrack a few times, but he is a font of information about the film's production whether it be screenplay development, casting stories, location specifics, or just about any other behind the scenes topic one could imagine. He is complimentary to his collaborators without coming across as fawning. Knott is even softer spoken and contributes comments sporadically through the film's second half, a few of which echo things Harris said before he joined the track. A lot of Knott's comments amount to little more than praise for the cast and crew, but Harris continues to offer up interesting facts and anecdotes throughout.

Next up is a series of featurettes consisting of on-set interviews interspersed with film clips and a bit of behind the scenes footage. All are presented in 4:3 letterboxed video with Dolby Digital 2.0 stereo sound unless otherwise indicated below:

Bringing the Characters of "Appaloosa" to Life (7:33) covers Harris' initial attraction to the book, actors' thoughts on their characters and fellow cast members, how the actors came to the project, the modest budget of the film, and Harris' working methods as actor and director. On-camera interview participants include Harris, Knott, Viggo Mortensen, Renee Zellweger, Jeremy Irons, Director of Photography Dean Semler, and Lance Henriksen.

Historic Accuracy of "Appaloosa" (10:21) looks at the attention to detail involved with the costumes, the props (especially guns), the stunts, and the 100 year old train. On camera commentators include Mortensen, Harris, Irons, Costume Designer David Robinson, Property Master Keith Walters, Horse Wrangler Rex Peterson, Stunt Coordinator Mike Watson, Locomotive Engineer Charlie Greathouse, and Zellweger.

The Town of "Appaloosa" (5:08) looks at the design of the fictional late 19th century southwestern town created for the film and the philosophy behind it. Commentators include Harris, Production Designer Waldemar Kalinowski, and Semler.

Dean Semler's Return to the West (5:17) focuses on the film's cinematographer. Topics include how Harris convinced Semler to take the job for less than his usual fee, Semler's attraction to the project, his working methods with Harris, the cinematographic style of the film, and Semler's return to film after several previous movies shot digitally. After a brief introduction from Harris, the lion's share of this featurette consists of comments from Semler himself.

Deleted Scenes (12:03 w/Play All) are available with and without commentary from Ed Harris and Robert Knott. They are also viewable individually or via a "Play All" selection. The scenes are as follows:
  • Original Prologue (4:20) shows the original opening illustrating the crime committed by Bragg's men against a prominent citizen that leads to the confrontation that opens the final cut of the film.
  • Walk up the Stairs (1:05) is an additional conversation between Hitch and Katie which fleshes out their relationship a bit but is not essential
  • Buggy Ride (1:31) has Cole and Allie returning from their Buggy ride, picking up Hitch, and discussing the gunmen who recently arrived in town
  • Praying Mantis (1:18) features a discussion between Cole and Hitch prior to Bragg's trial where Cole asks Hitch to watch out for Allie if anything happens to him
  • The Blue Room(:54) extends the conversation from the film between Cole and Hitch where Hitch explains what happened when Allie kissed him
  • Town Hall Meeting (2:54) features Bragg publicly re-introducing himself to the Appaloosa community, apologizing for his past transgressions, and announcing his intentions to open a hotel and saloon in town and form a copper company.


The film is presented on a single sided double layered DVD-9 and packaged in a standard Amaray case with a single insert explaining how the disc purchaser can obtain a reduced price Windows Media digital copy from CinemaNow.


Apaloosa is a mostly successful western focusing on the tight-knit relationship between a pair of late nineteenth century lawmen for hire that is refreshingly traditional in its approach to the genre. It is provided on disc with a better than expected widescreen video presentation carefully rendered at a modest bitrate, a completely unreviewed by me 4:3 reformatted presentation, an effective Dolby Digital 5.1 audio presentation, an informative commentary from Ed Harris and co-writer/producer Robert Knott, and some brief but interesting featurettes and deleted scenes.


Ken McAlinden
Livonia, MI USA

#2 of 8 OFFLINE   Brett_M



  • 1,396 posts
  • Join Date: Nov 18 2004
  • Real Name:Brett Meyer
  • LocationMos Eisley Spaceport

Posted January 12 2009 - 04:47 AM

Nice review, Ken. I particularly liked your info about the differences between the book and film. I did not read the book but I noticed the disconnect. It never really gelled for me as a film. I liked parts of it but I was underwhelmed. Fans of the actors should check it out, though. It's a good rental.
Many Shubs and Zuuls knew what it meant to roast in the depths of the Sloar that day I can tell you.

#3 of 8 OFFLINE   Colin Jacobson

Colin Jacobson


  • 5,590 posts
  • Join Date: Apr 19 2000

Posted January 12 2009 - 08:50 AM

Listening to the commentary - especially the deleted scenes commentary - it becomes clear that the movie wasn't what Harris wanted. He indicates a definite interest in a director's cut, and I think that'd be a good idea. I thought the movie was a bit of a mess, and a longer cut might make it more coherent. I agree that Knott's "contributions" the commentary are a waste of time...
Colin Jacobson

#4 of 8 OFFLINE   Ken_McAlinden



  • 6,154 posts
  • Join Date: Feb 20 2001
  • Real Name:Kenneth McAlinden
  • LocationLivonia, MI USA

Posted January 12 2009 - 09:03 AM

...except that some of the stuff that Harris suggests he would put back into the movie is stuff that I am convinced would not make it any better. For instance, I am glad to have the extended prologue as an extra, but it does not add anything to the film or fix anything that is wrong with it. The only deleted scene that I think might have helped is the "Town Hall Meeting" one which would help with the seeming abruptness of Bragg's acceptance into the community. Unless Harris has some significant other stuff in his back pocket, I am not sure a longer cut would help all that much. Regards,
Ken McAlinden
Livonia, MI USA

#5 of 8 OFFLINE   Frank@N



  • 1,718 posts
  • Join Date: Sep 12 2002

Posted January 13 2009 - 07:11 AM

I can't believe that studios are still wasting a precious DVD layer on additional FS transfers. It's 2009, you can't even buy a 4:3 TV anymore!

#6 of 8 OFFLINE   Ken_McAlinden



  • 6,154 posts
  • Join Date: Feb 20 2001
  • Real Name:Kenneth McAlinden
  • LocationLivonia, MI USA

Posted January 13 2009 - 08:06 AM

It is a small consolation, but at least this time they rendered the lower bitrate transfer carefully. It is not a complete disaster like "Run, Fatboy, Run", the last New Line title to waste disc space on a 4:3 reformatted version. Regards,
Ken McAlinden
Livonia, MI USA

#7 of 8 OFFLINE   Colin Jacobson

Colin Jacobson


  • 5,590 posts
  • Join Date: Apr 19 2000

Posted January 13 2009 - 08:15 AM

You might be right - I just felt the film seemed vaguely incomplete and thought a longer cut might make it better. I do assume Harris has a lot of additional cut footage, though; IIRC, he alluded to a preferred cut that ran close to three hours, but the theatrical cut plus the DVD's deleted scenes would only run about 127 minutes. I'd guess there's another 30-40 minutes of footage NOT found on the DVD. I kinda doubt this flick will sell enough to warrant a director's cut, though...
Colin Jacobson

#8 of 8 OFFLINE   Dave Scarpa

Dave Scarpa


  • 5,325 posts
  • Join Date: Apr 08 1999

Posted January 14 2009 - 04:56 AM

It worked for me, but I know what you mean about the disconnect, it starts and ends like it wants to be told from Hitch's, but mostly it's from cole's. Still Good westerns are rare today so Thumbs up from me, I watched this as an HDX Download from Vudu and it looked spectacular
My DVD Collection

The Megaplex

0 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users