Jump to content

Sign up for a free account to remove the pop-up ads

Signing up for an account is fast and free. As a member you can join in the conversation, enter contests and remove the pop-up ads that guests get. Click here to create your free account.

DVD Reviews

HTF DVD REVIEW: L.A. Confidential: Two-Disc Special Edition

  • You cannot start a new topic
  • Please log in to reply
5 replies to this topic

#1 of 6 OFFLINE   Ken_McAlinden



  • 6,154 posts
  • Join Date: Feb 20 2001
  • Real Name:Kenneth McAlinden
  • LocationLivonia, MI USA

Posted September 22 2008 - 05:39 PM

L.A. Confidential: Two-Disc Special Edition

Directed By: Curtis Hanson

Starring: Kevin Spacey, Guy Pearce, Russell Crowe, Kim Basinger, Danny DeVito, James Cromwell, David Stathairn

Studio: Warner Bros.

Year: 1998

Rated: R

Film Length: 138 minutes

Aspect Ratio: 2.35:1

Subtitles: English, French

Release Date: September 23, 2008

The Film

L.A. Confidential follows the complex course of three police officers in 1950s Los Angeles. Bud White (Crowe) is a brutish officer with a particular hatred for wife beaters and a soft spot for women such as call-girl Lynn Bracken (Basinger). Jack Vincennes (Spacey) is a spotlight-embracing cop who invites tabloid editor Sid Hudgens (DeVito) to his pot-busts of Hollywood stars and relishes his ties to the Dragnet-like cop show for which he is a technical advisor. Ed Exley (Pearce) is a straight arrow, advancement minded son of a hero cop who considers himself above the ethical compromises made on a regular basis by his fellow officers. While they would seem to have little in common besides their employer, and in the case of White and Exley, there is even a deep seeded dislike between them, their divergent activities surrounding the investigation of a shooting at a local diner, an unusual prostitution ring headed by Pierce Patchett (Strathairn), and narcotics lead them to uneasy alliances and shocking discoveries.

Curtis Hanson' L.A. Confidential adapts James Ellroy's sprawling epic novel of the 1950s Los Angeles Police Department into a slightly less sprawling epic film. The screenplay, co-written by Hanson and Brian Helgeland, is a miracle of condensation in that it captures almost all of the mammoth novel's most memorable elements, including its balanced three-protagonist structure, despite casting its net much less widely and bringing the whole enterprise together in less than two hours and twenty minutes. This involves some invention on the part of the screenwriters, but with the exception of "Rollo Tomasi" (you'll know what I mean when you watch the film), these elements of invention feel like they are still in the spirit of Ellroy's original creation. They also cleverly took one of the subtexts of the novel, the conflict between appearances and truth, and brought it forward to be the overarching theme of the film.

Hanson's visual approach is perfectly suited to the material, with a stylized philosophy that consistently informs everything from the costumes, sets, location selections, and cinematography. It is recognizably a period film, but it also avoids screaming "period" by steering clear of most clichés. While set near the time that many postwar film noirs were produced, and certainly containing signature noir elements to its story, it does not go for the high-contrast photographic style associated with the genre. Instead, Storaro's lighting set-ups emphasize a naturalistic look with lighting appearing to come from real sources even when it is not. The stylization extends to the soundtrack, which combines several pieces of pre-rock popular music of the early 50s with Jerry Goldsmith's spare but just about perfect score with its liberal use of alternating aggressive percussion and solo trumpet.

In addition to its technical merits, the film features a particularly fine ensemble cast. Kim Basinger received a supporting actress Oscar for her performance as the "Veronica Lake" in a ring of celebrity lookalike call girls, and while she does indeed deliver a fine performance, it is only one of several, and not necessarily even the strongest in the film. Of the three male leads, Kevin Spacey was the best known at the time thanks to his supporting actor Oscar for The Usual Suspects and strong turns in Seven and A Time to Kill, but even he was making a new step into cinematic leading roles. Producers must have been dumbfounded when Hanson told them that his other two leads would be filled by relatively unknown Australian actors, but Russell Crowe and Guy Pearce both deliver convincing breakout performances as opposite number detectives. If Danny DeVito's slimy tabloid reporter constitutes typecasting, the casting of James Cromwell, at the time best known as the kindly farmer from Babe, as hard-nosed Police Captain Dudley Smith was a stroke of genius casting against type.

Released in the early fall of 1997 to generally positive reviews, the film was initially a disappointment at the box office, possibly due to a weak marketing campaign. Warner's marketing department was having trouble at the time figuring out what to do when they had something unique or special to sell (Exhibit B: The Iron Giant). The studio extended its run by several months to last through Oscar season and it slowly but steadily found a respectably sized audience. It was also doomed to be underserved during awards season due to the juggernaut that was Titanic but still managed to benefit from the awards consideration it did receive

The Video

While the 16:9 enhanced 2.35:1 video transfer is not a large departure from that of the previous release, viewing it on a very large screen reveals better overall compression resulting in a more stable image. Viewers watching on more modest sized displays may be more hard pressed to detect an improvement, but it is there. The film carries healthy amounts of natural film grain which occasionally gives the compression algorithm fits, and the use of long lenses often insures that background items are out of focus, making the image quality difficult to judge. That being said, it struck me as an above average DVD rendering of the film as I remember it from theaters.

The Audio

Audio comes courtesy of a Dolby Digital 5.1 track that gets a bump up to 448 kbps bitrate from the previous release's 384 kbps track, but otherwise sounds much the same, which is generally a good thing. Fidelity is strong with wide dynamic range occasionally given a boost from the LFE channel. As expected, the climactic gunfight offers the best opportunitiy for multi-channel surround fun. There are no other alternate language dubs so the French 5.1 track from the previous release has been dropped.

The Extras

A full complement of extras sets this release apart from the previous single disc special edition from 1998. In addition to the newlyy produced material, all of the features from the previous release have been carried over except for a series of text-based features on the cast crew, production, and history of L.A..

Disc one includes an "oral history" large group audio commentary cobbled together from several interviews with most of the film's key creative participants and one critic/scholar. Commentators include critic/historian Andrew Sarris, novelist James Ellroy, Russell Crowe, Kevin Spacey, Guy Pearce, James Cromwell, costume designer Ruth Myers, David Strathairn, Kim Basinger, screenwriter Brian Helgeland, production designer Jeannine Oppewall, cinematographer Dante Spinotti, and Danny DeVito. Commentators are identified by on-screen player-generated subtitles. The comedic highlight of the commentary comes early just before the four minute mark when Russell Crowe relays a typical answering machine message he would get from James Ellroy when he was preparing for the role of Bud White. Hanson does not participate in the commentary, but he is so well represented across the documentary featurettes that his absence is tolerable.

Carried over from the first release of the film is a Music-Only Audio Track that occupies a separate Dolby Digital 5.1 track. It Highlights the large number of pre-rock pop and jazz songs in the film as well as Jerry Goldsmith's sparse but effective score. It is not selectable on the fly while watching the film, and must be played by going through the disc's Special Features menu. I was hoping this would mean that chapter stops would be re-arranged to coincide with music cues, but ... no such luck. They did bump the bitrate for this feature to 448 Kbps from the previous disc's 384kbps.

Also on the first disc is a collection of trailers, promos, and TV spots carried over from the previous DVD release. All are presented with Dolby Digital 2.0 audio with aspect ratios and running times as indicated below:
  • Showest Trailer (4:3 - :37)
  • "Nite Owl Action" TV Spot (4:3 - 1:07)
  • "Hollywood" TV Spot (4:3 - :37)
  • Theatrical Trailer (16:9 - 2:21)
  • Soundtrack Promo (including interview segments with Hanson) (4:3 -1:01)
The second disc is jam-packed with video-based extras, all of which are presented in 16:9 enhanced video with Dolby Digital 2.0 stereo sound unless indicated otherwise below.

Whatever You Desire: Making L.A. Confidential (29:28) kicks off a series of newly produced documentary featurettes from Gary Leva. As with his work on the recent 2-Disc Special Editions of Stanley Kubrick films, Leva does a nice job of creating featurettes that stand well on their own and also compliment the other features on the disc with only a reasonable amount of overlap. Topics covered in this overview retrospective featurette include how Hanson was drawn to the material, difficulties selling the film to Warner Bros., characters and casting, creating the look of the period, finding locations, cinematography, costumes, and the reception of the film. On camera interview participants include Curtis Hanson, James Ellroy, Russell Crowe, Producer Arnon Milchan, Producer Michael Nathanson, Guy Pearce, Kevin Spacey, Kim Basinger, Danny DeVito, James Cromwell, David Strathairn, Production Designer Jeannine Oppewall, Cinematographer Dante Spinotti, and Costume Designer Ruth Myers.

Sunlight and Shadow: The Visual Style of L.A. Confidential (21:02) Covers both technical and thematic decisions that informed Dante Spinotti’s cinematography and how it integrates with aspects of the production design including costumes, sets and locations. On camera interview participants include Hanson, Spinotti, Ellroy, Myers, Basinger, Oppewall, Crowe, Pearce, Strathairn, and Spacey.

A True Ensemble: The Cast of LA Confidential (24:33) is a look at the characters and actors playing them. This topic was covered extensively in the Whatever You Desire: Making L.A. Confidential piece, but this featurette has much more in depth comments from the actors themselves. On-camera interview participants include Hanson, Crowe, Pearce, Spacey, Basinger, Strathairn, DeVito, Cromwell, Ellroy, Editor Peter Honess, Helgeland, Milchan, and Nathanson

L.A. Confidential: From Book to Screen (21:06) is the last of the newly produced featurettes. It looks specifically at how the novel was translated to film including screenplay adaptation difficulties, how Helgeland and Hanson came together after approaching the project independently, Helgeland as a fan of Ellroy, how they worked together, structural considerations, jettisoned subplots and backstories, the invention of Rollo Tomasi, and the re-invention of the shootout at the Victory Motel. The heart of it is an interview with Hanson and Helgeland sitting together, but other on camera interview participants include Ellroy, Nathanson, Pierce, Crowe, Milchan, and Spacey.

Off the Record (18:48) was created for the previous DVD release, and offers a surprisingly efficient overview of the production over its nineteen minutes. It is presented in 4:3 full frame video. Topics discussed include the tradition of Warner Bros. crime films, the appeal of Ellroy's book to Hanson, David Wolper's attempts to adapt it as a miniseries, the deal to make the movie, teaming with Helgeland, the adaptation process, Hanson's slideshow pitch to Milchan, casting of relative unknowns including clips from readings/screen tests, Spinotti's lighting style, Oppewall's designs and location choices, Ruth Myers' costumes, the use of period music, Goldsmith's score, reactions to screenings, and the movie's themes. On camera interview participants include Hanson, Ellroy, David L. Wolper, Helgeland (sitting with Hanson), Basinger, Milchan, Pearce (on-set), Crowe (on-set), Spacey, and DeVito

Photo Pitch (8:25) is another carry over from the previous DVD, this featurette is presented in 4:3 video. After a brief introduction, Hanson takes viewers through the photo pitch he assembled to demonstrate the look and feel of the movie to producers and collaborators.

The L.A. of L.A. Confidential presents an interactive map of the locations used in the film. Selecting any one of them pulls up a short clip from the film highlighting the location with narration from Curtis Hanson offering information about the location in both the film and the real Los Angeles. While largely a carry over feature from the previous release, it has been enhanced with spiffy new graphics.

The L.A. Confidential TV Series Pilot (46:27) is one of the more intriguing extras in this collection. It is presented in 4:3 full-frame video. The pilot, which was filmed in 1999 but never picked up by a network, features Kiefer Sutherland as Jack Vincennes, Josh Hopkins as Bud White, David Conrad as Ed Exley, Pruitt Taylor Vince as Sid Hudgens, Melissa George as Lynn Bracken, Tom Nowicki as Dudley Smith, and Eric Roberts as Pierce Patchett. While an intriguing idea for a series, the pieces are not quite in place with this pilot episode. In particular, the Sid Hudgens character is over-used as an omniscient narrator. The writing is not nearly up to the level of the feature film that preceded it, let alone Ellroy's source novel. Period shows are expensive, so it is understandable why it did not get picked up by a network. If anything, Sutherland's subsequent TV success as Jack Bauer on 24 demonstrates that he might have been better cast in the Bud White role despite being a bit small for the part.

Finally, the exhaustive extras are topped off by a surprise third disc in this Two-Disc Special Edition: a bonus CD with six vintage tracks used on the film's soundtrack. They are
  1. Ac-Cent-Tchu-Ate the Positive - Johnny Mercer and the Pied Pipers
  2. Look for the Silver Lining - Chet Baker
  3. Hit the Road to Dreamland - Betty Hutton
  4. Wheel of Fortune - Kay Starr
  5. But Not for Me - Jackie Gleason
  6. Powder Your Face with Sunshine (Smile Smile Smile) - Dean Martin

The DVDs and CD are packaged in a standard Amaray-sized case with a double-sided hinged tray with no insert that allows it to accommodate two DVDs and the bonus CD. The hard case is in turn inserted into a cardboard slipcover that reproduces the artwork from the hard case with shiny foil-like enhancements. Menus are sensibly laid out which is a huge improvement over the cutesy but unwieldy tabloid-themed menus of the original single disc special edition DVD release.


the L.A. Confidential: Two-Disc Special Edition is a no-brainer purchase recommendation for those who do not already own the earlier DVD of the film. It offers a modest improvement in image and audio quality compared to its predecessor and a quantum increase in the number and depth of special features. Heck, there's even a third disc which you rarely see in Two-Disc SEs. Those who own the earlier edition may want to stand pat unless they are interested in the extras or they watch the film on very large displays. In the latter case, they may want to consider the Blu-ray version of the film released concurrently with this SE.


Ken McAlinden
Livonia, MI USA

#2 of 6 OFFLINE   Aragorn the Elfstone

Aragorn the Elfstone

    Stunt Coordinator

  • 57 posts
  • Join Date: Mar 09 2008

Posted September 23 2008 - 12:08 AM

I think I'm gonna go ahead and pick this up today. Video sounds good, and the extras intrigue me. Posted Image

Blu-ray isn't going to be a reality for me for the forseeable future, so this is release is a no-brainer for me.

#3 of 6 OFFLINE   Micah Cohen

Micah Cohen


  • 1,156 posts
  • Join Date: Jun 08 2000

Posted September 23 2008 - 12:42 AM

[head down on keyboard in frustration and anxiety over the slew of rebuying that might have to go on in the near future... THE GODFATHER now, again?] ... I guess I'll have to pick it up, too. If only for that stellar box art, and to judge for myself how it might look on my (upgraded) TV... (Thanks for the review!) MC

"There's nothing funny about a clown in the moonlight." - Lon Chaney

#4 of 6 OFFLINE   Ken_McAlinden



  • 6,154 posts
  • Join Date: Feb 20 2001
  • Real Name:Kenneth McAlinden
  • LocationLivonia, MI USA

Posted September 23 2008 - 01:02 AM

The box art is okay and a big improvement over the previous release. Going along with my marketing beef from the review, this film had some pretty boring posters and print ads. The two coolest images ever used to represent the film commercially were used for the covers of the Original Soundtrack CD and the Original Score CD.
Posted ImagePosted Image

Ken McAlinden
Livonia, MI USA

#5 of 6 OFFLINE   Lord Dalek

Lord Dalek


  • 2,426 posts
  • Join Date: Apr 04 2005

Posted September 23 2008 - 01:55 AM

That actually was used on a poster.

#6 of 6 OFFLINE   Ken_McAlinden



  • 6,154 posts
  • Join Date: Feb 20 2001
  • Real Name:Kenneth McAlinden
  • LocationLivonia, MI USA

Posted September 23 2008 - 02:31 AM

Yes, I know. I did not say all of the posters and ads stunk. Just some of them (actually, all of them except the ones for which I provided examples). I believe it was used for the tie-in reprint of the novel as well. I believe the Kim Basinger/Veronica Lake image from the Goldsmith Score CD was used elsewhere as well, but memory fails at the moment. Regards
Ken McAlinden
Livonia, MI USA

0 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users