- View New Content
- Blu-ray, DVD, Streaming Video and Digital Downloads
- Home Theater Hardware
- Theaters, Remotes and Accessories
- Equipment Reviews
- DVD & Blu-ray Reviews
- Other Diversions
- Bargains and Deals
- Feedback and Testing
- Latest Blu-ray Deals
- Shop Amazon & Support HTF
- Theater Photos
DVD & Blu-ray Reviews
- Equipment Reviews
Blu-ray Release Listings
- Shop Amazon
- Support HTF
HTF Review: Underdog
1 reply to this topic
Posted February 01 2008 - 02:22 PM
Studio: Walt Disney Video
Aspect Ratio: 1.85:1
Audio: English (Dolby Digital 5.1)
Subtitles: English, French, Spanish
Street Date: 18 December 2007
It would be easy to rag on the live-action cinematic adventures of “Underdog.” Starring Jason Lee as the voice of the titular protagonist and featuring a nigh incomprehensible story, dull protagonist, and a budget of wiz-bang special effects that in one shot eclipsed the entire budget of the original show, picking on “Underdog” is simple. So I’m going to take the high road and try to be positive about this mess.
The first positive I can say about “Underdog” is that it wasn’t nearly as bad as I expected. Sure Jason Lee’s dialogue recitation was largely uninspired, save a few bits about dogs licking their butts. I lay the blame for this not entirely at Lee’s feet, instead holding culpable the writers who didn’t seem to understand what they wanted to do with “Underdog” and the director, who took a script that substituted a plot for a string of one-off jokes and subtle nods to longtime fans. The rhyming was quaint in the cartoon; it’s obnoxious and illogical in the film, seemingly forced in by the filmmakers to say, “See, we’re familiar with the source.” Then ignoring every bit of what made the original great. And I’m not even an Underdog fan.
The story of the cinematic underdog follows the exploits of an underwhelming police dog, an unnamed beagle who has a malfunctioning sniffer and no police instincts. After a particularly embarrassing encounter with the Mayor, the dog who would become a hero is kidnapped by henchman extraordinaire Cad (Patrick Warburton playing a 21st Century version of his Kronk from “The Emperor’s New Groove”). Cad secrets the pooch to a secret laboratory to satisfy the malevolent machinations of mad scientist Dr. Barsinister (Peter Dinklage), who is bent on creating the ultimate canine crimefighter. An accident results in Shoeshine being bathed in a host of chemicals which give him super strength, speed, the ability to communicate, and a host of other super powers.
In the realm of science fiction, I can accept odd animal testing. But the screenwriters have obviously no idea what DNA is or its scientific implications. There was a reason we never got Underdog’s origins in the cartoon; because it didn’t matter. Speaking metaphorically, this story is like using a cookie-cutter on pudding; the results are somewhat familiar, but so messy that you just don’t care.
But I’m trying to stay positive. On that note, I mention the supporting cast for the titular cape-laden protagonist. Lead by the young Alex Neuberger as Jack, the boy who adopts Shoeshine (one of many not-so-subtle and painfully-obviously, but largely useless references to the original cartoon). It’s rare that I get to say that Jim Belushi isn’t the worst part of something, however Neuberger’s inexperience and lack of direction result in uninspired line deliveries that inspire no passion, don’t speak to the character, and left me feeling cold.
Positive, Justin. Positive. Okay… Jason Lee. I love the actor in “My Name is Earl.” His narration there is packed with discernable character. Underdog sounds… well… like he was handed the script in a recording studio and asked to pound out the dialogue in one sitting. There isn’t a hint of energy, understanding of his surroundings, or interaction with his fellow actors.
Okay, I give up. There is very little good about Underdog. The effects are pretty, some of the jokes are funny, but it’s a boring movie, uninspired movie that limps forward through its thankfully short running time. The film is good for a rainy day when nothing else is on television, but is a painfully bad movie. Just skip it.
Okay, here the big guns come out. This is one of the worst modern transfers I have seen in years. Mosquito noise litters the transfer, the colors are pallid, and there is a lot of edge enhancement. The reason, I believe, it looks so troubled is the amount of information packed onto this disc: Three full-screen and two wide-screen presentations with 5.1 tracks in English, French, and Spanish.
The disc defaults to fullscreen, and accessing the 2.35:1 widescreen version is no simple task because it is improperly labeled. To achieve the original theatrical aspect ratio, you have to go into the set-up, then audio options where you will find the different video flavors.
The audio options are a lot more palpable than their video brothers, though nothing spectacular. The 5.1 Dolby Digital track has good separation between channels, with an excellent LFE push.
The single-disc set of Underdog has a surprising amount of extra features. There are three deleted scenes with optional commentary from the film’s director. The scenes are presented in Anamorphic widescreen, which is a welcome surprise. Especially since the film itself defaults to a matted 4:3 ratio.
A host of bloopers populate the set, too, which include fumbled lines and animals acting like animals.
“Sit, Stay, Act” is a in-character, behind-the-scenes look at the film from the perspective of the dog Shoeshine, as narrated by actor Jason Lee. There are branching features on the documentary that allows the viewer to “dig deeper” and get more detailed behind-the-scenes information.
“Underdog Raps” is a video by Kyle Massey for the Underdog Rap. It’s actually, surprisingly, not terrible. It is non Anamorphic, however. This set is so confusing.
“Safe Waif” is the first episode of the Underdog cartoon program. Itself a whole lot better than the entire film.
Not since “Broken Flowers” have I gotten so mad at a film for being bad. There was potential here, but the story is boring, the acting poor, and the tone off. The filmmakers claim reverence for the original film, but they don’t seem to understand the nature of the Underdog character. Just avoid this mess.
Posted February 02 2008 - 03:11 AM
Justin - you are right on every point the movie is a mess and was destined to be a mess from the start. Amazingly you think the producers and Disney would have learned from messes like Rocky and Bullwinkle in live action. I actually submitted to the rights holders two treatments for a film and natural sequel and Classic Media loved it and Bob Higgins' Assistant rushed it to him, Spyglass turned it down because although I had a published book on the market at the time that also happened to feature the Macy's Underdog balloon! I grew up on the old show and felt it could have been a great little film. Now not to make you all think I am just showing ego and boasting lets go one step further. Joe Harris the great artist you actually designed the character and was one of the 4 original creators of the character and show actually submitted a script and was turned down flat. Now here is a man who created the show which was very successful for 10 years in syndication and Network. Who knows what will work for the character and what the fans would have loved to see and they did not immediately bring him on board! That was the first indication of the mess that resulted. Maybe the producers will take a Underdog Super energy sign up Joe Harris make the film that should have been made!!!!!!!