https://static.hometheaterforum.com/imgrepo/f/fe/ronsreviews_covers_85186.jpg">
[b][SIZE=5]The Santa Clause 3: The Escape Clause (Blu-ray)[/SIZE][/b]
[SIZE=3]Directed by Michael Lembeck
Studio: Disney
Year: 2006
Aspect Ratio: 1.85:1 1080p VC-1 codec
Running Time: 92 minutes
Rating: G
Audio: PCM 5.1 English; Dolby Digital 5.1 English, French, Spanish
Subtitles: SDH, French, Spanish
MSRP: $34.99
Release Date: November 20, 2007
Review Date: November 17, 2007[/SIZE]
[b][u]The Film
[/u][/b]
3/5
Tim Allen returns to his role as the replacement Santa Claus in [I]The Santa Clause 3: The Escape Clause.[/I] It’s a familiar adventure with many of the regular cast from previous installments along with a few new additions. As a family film, you’re on very safe ground (the naughtiest the film gets is a couple of reindeer fart jokes), but if you’re looking for a really funny comedy for the holiday season, this film won’t be it. It’s mildly pleasant and passes quickly, but there really isn’t much substance here.
Santa Claus’ wife Carol (Elizabeth Mitchell) is pregnant with their first child, and while they’re both excited about the upcoming event, her delivery date is dangerously close to Christmas Eve when Papa Claus will be occupied elsewhere. Feeling apprehensive and a bit homesick, Carol convinces Scott/Santa to allow her parents (Alan Arkin, Ann-Margret) to come for a visit. Of course, they don’t know anything about Scott’s new life, so elaborate preparations must be made to keep his new identity secret from them. Also at the North Pole is the very frustrated Jack Frost (Martin Short), disgusted that all the other legendary figures present (Cupid, Easter Bunny, Tooth Fairy, Mother Nature, Father Time) have either holidays or celebrations of some kind surrounding their activities. He connives to get the Santa gig for himself which can only happen if Scott/Santa invokes “the escape clause”; hence the subtitle of the movie.
Martin Short really works hard to make something out of the flimsy material furnished by screenwriters Ed Decter and John J. Strauss. He makes faces, does impressions, and generally weasels his way around the North Pole looking for an opportunity to do his dirty work. But it just never takes off. Tim Allen and Elizabeth Mitchell are okay leads and genuinely agreeable folks while the cameo appearances by the likes of Aisha Tyler, Kevin Pollak, Jay Thomas, Peter Boyle (his last film), and Michael Dorn are nice but not substantial. Alan Arkin looks like he’d rather be anywhere rather than making the film, and Ann-Margret seems to be along for the ride but not much more.
I did enjoy Short’s Liza Minnelli impression to a reworked version of “New York, New York,” (and he did win a Best Actor in a Musical Tony Award for [I]Little Me[/I] so he can pull off this kind of over-the-top musical moment with aplomb) and the various children who play the elves get a few bright lines here and there though some aren‘t very convincing actors. I was looking for director Michael Lembeck to infuse the proceedings with some really madcap sight gags and set-ups, and they just aren’t there. The film is a moderately pleasing trifle stuffed with bright color and lots of Christmas music, but look elsewhere if you want big laughs.
[b][u]Video Quality
[/u][/b]
4.5/5
The 1.85:1 theatrical aspect ratio is presented in 1080p using the VC-1 codec. The color is extremely bright and deeply saturated but never to the point of over saturation (though some reds come close), and the image is very sharp with superb flesh tones. The image’s sharpness and consistency are much more commendable than that of the standard definition disc. Blacks are solid, and there is very good shadow detail. The film has been divided into 20 chapters.
[b][u]Audio Quality
[/u][/b]
4/5
The PCM 5.1 soundtrack (48 kHz/24 bit, 6.9 Mbps) spreads the generous assortment of Christmas music and original score throughout the sound field in an expansive manner. Elsewhere, however, the surrounds aren’t used for as many sound effects as one would expect for the busy toy-building moments, the crowded street scenes, and those minor action sequences. These opportunities are not exploited by the film’s sound designers.
[b][u]Special Features
[/u][/b]
4/5
All of the DVD bonus material has been brought over to the Blu-ray disc and is presented in 1080i with the exception of the music video which is 480i.
Director Michael Lembeck contributes an [b]audio commentary[/b] that covers everything you’d want to know about the filming of the picture, down to the exact number of the various toys used on the soundstages and the several continuity errors in the movie. It’s an upbeat track (he obviously loved everyone working on the picture) with almost no pauses.
A 3-minute [b]blooper reel[/b] goes along with some bloopers which play over the closing credits (some are repeated). Most feature actors breaking up or losing lines while the camera rolls.
A 3½-minute [b]alternate opening sequence[/b] features Elizabeth Mitchell narrating clips from the original [I]The Santa Clause[/I]. This sequence is clearly inferior to the version used in the theatrical release which gets the movie moving much more quickly.
[b]“Jack Frost and Mrs. Claus”[/b] is a 4½ minute discussion of the original looks for these two characters in the film and why the director ultimately chose another look for each. We get to see outtakes of both original looks along with the way they eventually look in the movie.
[b]“The New Comedians: On the Set with Tim and Marty”[/b] is a disappointing 3½ minute look at Tim Allen and Martin Short cutting up on the set, narrated by director Michael Lembeck. And after so many years in the business, can Tim Allen and Martin Short actually be considered "new
“Creating Movie Magic” is an entirely too brief (4 minutes) look at the special effects used in the film focusing particularly on the Snow Globe Room and Santa’s Fireplace.
“Christmas Carol-oke” serves up seven traditional Christmas carols with karaoke lyrics (a bouncing ornament points them out) and clips from the movie and its prequels in the background.
“The Greatest Time of the Year” is a 3-minute music video of a song sung over the closing credits by Aly and AJ.
A couple of features are exclusive to this Blu-ray disc release.
The disc offers Deck the Halls, a holiday decorating game in which the viewer can decorate a virtual family room using dozens of ornaments by placing them on the tree and around the room, selecting stockings and monogramming them, and making a holiday play list for the jukebox.
Tour Elfsberg is a 1080p virtual tour of the main screen menu. The camera moves the viewer around a 360 degree arc and offers a couple of surprises along the way.
The movie showcase is a now standard feature where three scenes thought to be reference quality material are selected for instant access.
In Conclusion
3/5 (not an average)
The Santa Clause 3 is an innocuous Christmas picture which the family can safely watch in preparation for the upcoming holiday season. Neither great nor terrible, the Blu-ray release offers an outstanding video presentation, adequate audio, and a varied if slightly undernourished series of extras.
Matt Hough
Charlotte, NC
[b][SIZE=5]The Santa Clause 3: The Escape Clause (Blu-ray)[/SIZE][/b]
[SIZE=3]Directed by Michael Lembeck
Studio: Disney
Year: 2006
Aspect Ratio: 1.85:1 1080p VC-1 codec
Running Time: 92 minutes
Rating: G
Audio: PCM 5.1 English; Dolby Digital 5.1 English, French, Spanish
Subtitles: SDH, French, Spanish
MSRP: $34.99
Release Date: November 20, 2007
Review Date: November 17, 2007[/SIZE]
[b][u]The Film
[/u][/b]
3/5
Tim Allen returns to his role as the replacement Santa Claus in [I]The Santa Clause 3: The Escape Clause.[/I] It’s a familiar adventure with many of the regular cast from previous installments along with a few new additions. As a family film, you’re on very safe ground (the naughtiest the film gets is a couple of reindeer fart jokes), but if you’re looking for a really funny comedy for the holiday season, this film won’t be it. It’s mildly pleasant and passes quickly, but there really isn’t much substance here.
Santa Claus’ wife Carol (Elizabeth Mitchell) is pregnant with their first child, and while they’re both excited about the upcoming event, her delivery date is dangerously close to Christmas Eve when Papa Claus will be occupied elsewhere. Feeling apprehensive and a bit homesick, Carol convinces Scott/Santa to allow her parents (Alan Arkin, Ann-Margret) to come for a visit. Of course, they don’t know anything about Scott’s new life, so elaborate preparations must be made to keep his new identity secret from them. Also at the North Pole is the very frustrated Jack Frost (Martin Short), disgusted that all the other legendary figures present (Cupid, Easter Bunny, Tooth Fairy, Mother Nature, Father Time) have either holidays or celebrations of some kind surrounding their activities. He connives to get the Santa gig for himself which can only happen if Scott/Santa invokes “the escape clause”; hence the subtitle of the movie.
Martin Short really works hard to make something out of the flimsy material furnished by screenwriters Ed Decter and John J. Strauss. He makes faces, does impressions, and generally weasels his way around the North Pole looking for an opportunity to do his dirty work. But it just never takes off. Tim Allen and Elizabeth Mitchell are okay leads and genuinely agreeable folks while the cameo appearances by the likes of Aisha Tyler, Kevin Pollak, Jay Thomas, Peter Boyle (his last film), and Michael Dorn are nice but not substantial. Alan Arkin looks like he’d rather be anywhere rather than making the film, and Ann-Margret seems to be along for the ride but not much more.
I did enjoy Short’s Liza Minnelli impression to a reworked version of “New York, New York,” (and he did win a Best Actor in a Musical Tony Award for [I]Little Me[/I] so he can pull off this kind of over-the-top musical moment with aplomb) and the various children who play the elves get a few bright lines here and there though some aren‘t very convincing actors. I was looking for director Michael Lembeck to infuse the proceedings with some really madcap sight gags and set-ups, and they just aren’t there. The film is a moderately pleasing trifle stuffed with bright color and lots of Christmas music, but look elsewhere if you want big laughs.
[b][u]Video Quality
[/u][/b]
4.5/5
The 1.85:1 theatrical aspect ratio is presented in 1080p using the VC-1 codec. The color is extremely bright and deeply saturated but never to the point of over saturation (though some reds come close), and the image is very sharp with superb flesh tones. The image’s sharpness and consistency are much more commendable than that of the standard definition disc. Blacks are solid, and there is very good shadow detail. The film has been divided into 20 chapters.
[b][u]Audio Quality
[/u][/b]
4/5
The PCM 5.1 soundtrack (48 kHz/24 bit, 6.9 Mbps) spreads the generous assortment of Christmas music and original score throughout the sound field in an expansive manner. Elsewhere, however, the surrounds aren’t used for as many sound effects as one would expect for the busy toy-building moments, the crowded street scenes, and those minor action sequences. These opportunities are not exploited by the film’s sound designers.
[b][u]Special Features
[/u][/b]
4/5
All of the DVD bonus material has been brought over to the Blu-ray disc and is presented in 1080i with the exception of the music video which is 480i.
Director Michael Lembeck contributes an [b]audio commentary[/b] that covers everything you’d want to know about the filming of the picture, down to the exact number of the various toys used on the soundstages and the several continuity errors in the movie. It’s an upbeat track (he obviously loved everyone working on the picture) with almost no pauses.
A 3-minute [b]blooper reel[/b] goes along with some bloopers which play over the closing credits (some are repeated). Most feature actors breaking up or losing lines while the camera rolls.
A 3½-minute [b]alternate opening sequence[/b] features Elizabeth Mitchell narrating clips from the original [I]The Santa Clause[/I]. This sequence is clearly inferior to the version used in the theatrical release which gets the movie moving much more quickly.
[b]“Jack Frost and Mrs. Claus”[/b] is a 4½ minute discussion of the original looks for these two characters in the film and why the director ultimately chose another look for each. We get to see outtakes of both original looks along with the way they eventually look in the movie.
[b]“The New Comedians: On the Set with Tim and Marty”[/b] is a disappointing 3½ minute look at Tim Allen and Martin Short cutting up on the set, narrated by director Michael Lembeck. And after so many years in the business, can Tim Allen and Martin Short actually be considered "new
“Creating Movie Magic” is an entirely too brief (4 minutes) look at the special effects used in the film focusing particularly on the Snow Globe Room and Santa’s Fireplace.
“Christmas Carol-oke” serves up seven traditional Christmas carols with karaoke lyrics (a bouncing ornament points them out) and clips from the movie and its prequels in the background.
“The Greatest Time of the Year” is a 3-minute music video of a song sung over the closing credits by Aly and AJ.
A couple of features are exclusive to this Blu-ray disc release.
The disc offers Deck the Halls, a holiday decorating game in which the viewer can decorate a virtual family room using dozens of ornaments by placing them on the tree and around the room, selecting stockings and monogramming them, and making a holiday play list for the jukebox.
Tour Elfsberg is a 1080p virtual tour of the main screen menu. The camera moves the viewer around a 360 degree arc and offers a couple of surprises along the way.
The movie showcase is a now standard feature where three scenes thought to be reference quality material are selected for instant access.
In Conclusion
3/5 (not an average)
The Santa Clause 3 is an innocuous Christmas picture which the family can safely watch in preparation for the upcoming holiday season. Neither great nor terrible, the Blu-ray release offers an outstanding video presentation, adequate audio, and a varied if slightly undernourished series of extras.
Matt Hough
Charlotte, NC
