- Joined
- Jul 3, 1997
- Messages
- 66,705
- Real Name
- Ronald Epstein
Many of us have noted here that the advent of these new high
definition formats has rekindled our interest in Home Theater.
After all, the DVD format had become dulled over recent years --
especially with studios cranking out multiple new editions of the
same tired titles and transfers. Where DVD was once a format
that seemed new and fresh to all of us, it has now been dumbed
down to cater to the Walmart crowd who wants their image to fill
their television screen.
Despite the fact there is a raging format war between HD-DVD and
Blu-ray, those of us that have invested in either format are very
much reaping its benefits. These days I find myself very much
immersed in this new technology that is providing a breathtaking
audio and video experience.
Animation is the one genre that really brings these high definition
formats home. Since most of the recent animation films have been
created in the digital realm, it's not difficult to understand how they
integrate into a perfect marriage with the new optical formats. To
sit and watch an explosion of colors and deep textures come to life
in 1080p is an experience that cannot be easily translated into words.
The problem with Shrek The Third is that while it qualifies
itself as being worthy of joining the ranks of other animated features
that look stupendous in high definition, the film itself is about as dull
as a normal DVD presentation.
For years, Hollywood has run out of original ideas and has relied
upon sequels to keep the profit machine running. Unfortunately, it's
a proven fact that a sequel rarely captures the charm of the original
film, and in the case of Shrek The Third, it seems the well
has run completely dry.
While the HD-DVD format has provided a wonderful medium to
showcase gorgeous animation, the entire viewing experience is
dulled by a lackluster storyline and jokes that fall flat. The charm
that we so much enjoyed in Shrek's kingdom has outstayed its
welcome.
On a visual level, the transfer on HD-DVD is as perfect as it
gets. To watch animation in its purest form without any background
noise whatsoever is nirvana! On the other hand, I found it odd that
the supporting audio was less than impressive as the soundtrack
seemed to be very heavy within the front channels. I found there
to be very little use of the surrounds, and thus, I was less immersed
in the presentation.
I'm very interested to hear your comments about watching Shrek The
Third on HD-DVD to see if your conclusions are in agreement with
or not with mine.