-

Jump to content



Photo
- - - - -

Westerns - A Dying Art Form


This topic has been archived. This means that you cannot reply to this topic.
35 replies to this topic

#1 of 36 dana martin

dana martin

    Screenwriter

  • 1,862 posts
  • Join Date: Oct 28 2003
  • Real Name:Dana Martin
  • LocationNorfolk, VA

Posted February 13 2006 - 03:58 AM

what would it take to infuse life into this genre again, besides story, possible that a great director could make a great Western, be it contemporary or period piece, i would love to see Spielberg or Martin Scorsese tackle this.
Playing at the Drive In

Quote:Welles, Kubrick, Hitchcock, Spielberg, Jackson, Wood ?? a true Auteur should be one who follows his artistic vision
 

 


#2 of 36 Robert Crawford

Robert Crawford

    Studio Mogul

  • 24,489 posts
  • Join Date: Dec 09 1998
  • Real Name:Robert
  • LocationMichigan

Posted February 13 2006 - 04:02 AM

Eastwood would do another western before Spielberg or Scorsese.

Crawdaddy

 

Blu-ray Preorder Schedule

 


#3 of 36 Amy Mormino

Amy Mormino

    Supporting Actor

  • 537 posts
  • Join Date: Jan 16 2004

Posted February 13 2006 - 04:11 AM

Quentin Tarentino is a huge fan of Rio Bravo, so perhaps he might make a western someday.

I think the problem with modern westerns (including films like Unforgiven, Dances with Wolves and even Brokeback Mountain) is that they seem to be obsessed with "de-mythologizing" the West. Granted, such films can be very interesting, but a genre can't be sustained if the people making the films don't believe in what they're working with.

I would like to see a modern Western that shows the epic grandeur of the West and that has a sense of adventure and fun. Filmmakers can be realistic about issues like racism during the period while still showing why the Old West can be a great setting for movies with wide audience appeal.

#4 of 36 dana martin

dana martin

    Screenwriter

  • 1,862 posts
  • Join Date: Oct 28 2003
  • Real Name:Dana Martin
  • LocationNorfolk, VA

Posted February 13 2006 - 04:13 AM

Actually i believe i read somewhere after Open Range came out that Costner said that while they are not his favorite things that he could see himself in more. and actually he dose a good job of telling them, also would be happy to see another one from Eastwood. what i was trying to state is that so few directors do attempt to do them, Carpenter is a director who always stated that he wanted to do westerns, but is known for horror,is a huge Hawks fan. I cant argue that Red River isn't a great western.
Playing at the Drive In

Quote:Welles, Kubrick, Hitchcock, Spielberg, Jackson, Wood ?? a true Auteur should be one who follows his artistic vision
 

 


#5 of 36 Adam_S

Adam_S

    Producer

  • 6,105 posts
  • Join Date: Feb 08 2001

Posted February 13 2006 - 05:18 AM

I don't think there's any need for another Eastwood western because Unforgiven was so tremendous anything else would be seen as a let down. Sort of like Harper Lee and To Kill a Mockingbird.

On the other hand there has been a non-demythologizing western in the last decade. Tombstone. Open Range also falls into this as well.

The problem is combining the appeal of the western tropes with modern filmmaking while treading a balance in representation. Westerns are particularly problematic for modern thoughtful filmmakers (you mentioned Spielberg and Scorsese) because they take place during an era of manifest destiny as national policy, something seen as imperialistic, genocidal and generally very problematic by today's standards and policies.

That doesn't preclude stories akin to Naked Spur from being told. Not everything has to engage the Indians or the white man's relationship to the famed wide open spaces of the west, nor does it require an essential primitivism (see Unforgiven), but stories about white males being very alpha-male and on an arc of heroism or destruction are not seen as viable market forces in a western. In general these have transitioned into science fiction (Neo, Captain Mal Reynolds, Anakin) or fantasy (Aragorn, Samwise, Pippin)--perhaps because decent heros are no longer seen as realistic but there's still a strong desire for them nevertheless.
 

#6 of 36 dana martin

dana martin

    Screenwriter

  • 1,862 posts
  • Join Date: Oct 28 2003
  • Real Name:Dana Martin
  • LocationNorfolk, VA

Posted February 13 2006 - 06:25 AM

The problem is combining the appeal of the western tropes with modern filmmaking while treading a balance in representation. Westerns are particularly problematic for modern thoughtful filmmakers (you mentioned Spielberg and Scorsese) because they take place during an era of manifest destiny as national policy, something seen as imperialistic, genocidal and generally very problematic by today's standards and policies.

so that makes it even more interesting, i can see Scorsese doing something like this, with a level of artistry that he brought to Gangs of New York, i mentioned Spielberg, because well he is Spielberg, and can tell a story. The idea that it needs to be a Mythos buster aside, who said it needs to be white alpha male; Buffalo soldiers leaves a lot of room for inspiration.
even if it was to be a modern western, trucks instead of horses, rodeo circuit, i could see something there.

Playing at the Drive In

Quote:Welles, Kubrick, Hitchcock, Spielberg, Jackson, Wood ?? a true Auteur should be one who follows his artistic vision
 

 


#7 of 36 Ted Todorov

Ted Todorov

    Screenwriter

  • 2,865 posts
  • Join Date: Aug 17 2000

Posted February 13 2006 - 08:12 AM

The genre is far from dead -- what about Deadwood? (Yes, not a movie obviously, but quality wise can stand up to most big screen Westerns).

Ted
Hold on tightly, let go lightly.
My Twitter page

#8 of 36 Brook K

Brook K

    Lead Actor

  • 9,468 posts
  • Join Date: Feb 22 2000

Posted February 13 2006 - 09:40 AM

Also check out The Claim from British director Michael Winterbottom. It's a highly mythologized story that brings Thomas Hardy's novel, "The Mayor of Casterbridge" into a western setting.

There's also the defunct Firefly series which had several episodes based around standard western scenarios and used western archetypes and culture with sci-fi trappings.

And while not completely successful, Ron Howard's The Missing from a couple of years ago was an interesting film that embraced western mythos.

Also coming this year is The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford. I believe it is set for a summer release.

Though Adam is probably correct in the reasons we see very little of the genre these days. Like bell bottoms and Izod, perhaps the western will come back in vogue sometime in the future.
2002 Sight & Sound Challenge: 321  Last Watched: L'enfance Nue
Last 8 Films Watched: In the Loop - A- / It Might Get Loud - B+ / What Just Happened? - B / Cloudy With a Chance of Meatballs - C- / Drums Along the Mohawk - A- / Punisher War Zone - B+ / Moon - C+ / A Man For All Seasons - B+

#9 of 36 Simon Howson

Simon Howson

    Screenwriter

  • 1,779 posts
  • Join Date: Feb 18 2004

Posted February 13 2006 - 11:55 AM

Quote:
I think the problem with modern westerns (including films like Unforgiven, Dances with Wolves and even Brokeback Mountain) is that they seem to be obsessed with "de-mythologizing" the West.
I think The Searchers did more to demythologise the west than a lot of mediocre 1970s and 80s Westerns.

It wasn't like John Ford made Stagecoach 50 times. I think even just watching the progression of his Westerns shows you that his ideas about the time changed a great deal in the space of just 10 or 15 years.

Ford was able to hone his craft, and learn about the genre, and have different takes on it as he went on. A lot of 70s/80s/90s Westerns to me look like tributes to the genre, rather than real examinations of the time. The Western genre had some of the best Hollywood directors ever working in it, so you can be assured that they got every ounce there was out of it. They didn't leave much for less talented film makers to say.

#10 of 36 Nathan V

Nathan V

    Supporting Actor

  • 960 posts
  • Join Date: Jul 16 2002

Posted February 13 2006 - 05:29 PM

Is the modern western ever going to be widely accepted in the postmodern era? I don't know.
The Tree of Life / Brad Pitt / Sean Penn / Directed by Terrence Malick / 2010

#11 of 36 Simon Howson

Simon Howson

    Screenwriter

  • 1,779 posts
  • Join Date: Feb 18 2004

Posted February 13 2006 - 08:03 PM

Quote:
Is the modern western ever going to be widely accepted in the postmodern era? I don't know.
Are we in a post-modern era? I don't think so.

#12 of 36 David Rogers

David Rogers

    Supporting Actor

  • 723 posts
  • Join Date: May 15 2000

Posted February 14 2006 - 12:11 AM

What westerns need to to come back is a western that does mega bucks. Money talks to studio heads, so we need one to get greenlit that then soars to staggering heights of cash. Then they'll greenlight half a dozen more. Etc...

Shame really. Westerns are our versions of Samurai movies, and I've always thought we could stand with more of both here in the states. Certain kinds of stories and certain kinds of heroes are good in those genres. Good in ways they can't be in another type of story.

I disagree about the demystifying of westerns though. Not that there've been all that many over the past 10-15 years, but which are supposed to have done this?

Unforgiven is a phenomenal movie, and it's a true hearted western through and through; surely this isn't in that category?
-----

Dave's World
-No matter where you go, there you are-

#13 of 36 Ted Todorov

Ted Todorov

    Screenwriter

  • 2,865 posts
  • Join Date: Aug 17 2000

Posted February 14 2006 - 12:28 AM

Quote:
I disagree about the demystifying of westerns though. Not that there've been all that many over the past 10-15 years, but which are supposed to have done this?

Unforgiven is a phenomenal movie, and it's a true hearted western through and through; surely this isn't in that category?

Unforgiven is and isn't in that category: it spends most of its running time deconstructing the western -- and then in the last act it gloriously reconstructs it from its ashes. It is indeed a great movie, but it is very much a (post) modern take on the genre.

Ted
Hold on tightly, let go lightly.
My Twitter page

#14 of 36 Jeff Gatie

Jeff Gatie

    Lead Actor

  • 6,529 posts
  • Join Date: Aug 19 2002

Posted February 14 2006 - 12:48 AM

Quote:
Westerns are our versions of Samurai movies

This is the second time I've posted this in the last week or so (lots of western threads lately). When talking influences, it is really the other way around; Samurai movies are the Japanese version of Westerns, not vice versa. Kurosawa and others borrowed from the American western much more than Leone and others borrowed from him. The fact that two of the best westerns ever were based on Kurosawa films is a fine tribute to how well Kurosawa studied the genre; but make no mistake, the American Western came first.

#15 of 36 Joseph Bolus

Joseph Bolus

    Screenwriter

  • 2,188 posts
  • Join Date: Feb 04 1999

Posted February 14 2006 - 12:56 AM

The popular dirty, gritty, "anti-hero" "Spaghetti" Westerns of the '60's, in combination with the scathing generic Western satire movie "Blazing Saddles" in the early 70's, probably forever killed the concept of the familiar cowboy-on-a-horse hero in the minds of the general public.

It's just difficult now to find the allure of a movie based around a Cattle Drive, or a Stagecoach, or a land feud between the cattlemen and the sheep herders, or a shootout on main street at High Noon, or revenge against a typical outlaw of the Old West. Heck, "Silverado" was probably the last Hollywood attempt at a generic Western (and pretty much mixed all of the above traditional western storylines within its plot) and it just couldn't quite capture the imagination of the majority of the public.

About the only thing that *might* have a chance to kick-start the Western genre again would be a compelling story based around a more modern genre that just happens to be set against a Western facade. Something like "Back to the Future III" but executed better. Obviously, something like that will be very hard to find.

In the meantime, many of the great Westerns of the past("Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid", "The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly", "My Darling Clementine", "The Magnificent Seven", "True Grit", and on and on) are available for us to enjoy on DVD. I can't imagine modern Hollywood being able to make a Western that can approach the great ones of the '50s and '60s on a consistent basis.
Joseph
---------------

#16 of 36 Quentin

Quentin

    Screenwriter

  • 2,492 posts
  • Join Date: Feb 04 2002
  • Real Name:Quentin H
  • LocationLos Angeles

Posted February 14 2006 - 04:52 AM

David is right. Money talks, and right now, the western is barely a whisper.

Even OPEN RANGE (an excellent western) did not make much money. Though, Costner is reportedly working on another western now.

When people like Ron Howard make crappy westerns that bomb (THE MISSING), it doesn't help matters.

I don't think we're likely to see a BIG western again for some time. Thank God for DEADWOOD and indy films like THREE BURIALS OF MELQUIADES ESTRADA.

#17 of 36 RobertR

RobertR

    Lead Actor

  • 9,491 posts
  • Join Date: Dec 19 1998

Posted February 14 2006 - 05:42 AM

Quote:
It's just difficult now to find the allure of a movie based around a Cattle Drive, or a Stagecoach, or a land feud between the cattlemen and the sheep herders, or a shootout on main street at High Noon, or revenge against a typical outlaw of the Old West.
You left out the other "classic Western" conflict - Cowboys vs. Indians. In today's politically correct climate, Indians can't be shown as the antagonists, and I think people can only take so much of the "see what lying cheating European white male bastards did to the noble natives" storylines as well.

#18 of 36 Peter M Fitzgerald

Peter M Fitzgerald

    Screenwriter

  • 1,606 posts
  • Join Date: Mar 21 1999
  • Real Name:Peter Fitzgerald

Posted February 14 2006 - 05:45 AM

Westerns are particularly problematic for modern thoughtful filmmakers (you mentioned Spielberg and Scorsese) because they take place during an era of manifest destiny as national policy, something seen as imperialistic, genocidal and generally very problematic by today's standards and policies.

So, just have John Milius script and Mel Gibson direct an oater. Problem solved. Posted Image

My Current Damage at DVD Aficionado

Wanted in R1: UNEARTHLY STRANGER ('63) / IF I HAD A MILLION ('32) / THE FACE BEHIND THE MASK ('41) / IT CONQUERED THE WORLD ('56) / TERROR ABOARD ('33) / DANGER ROUTE ('68) / THE BLISS OF MRS. BLOSSOM ('68) / GUNN ('67) / ZOO IN BUDAPEST ('33) / THE SEA WOLF ('41) / DAY OF THE TRIFFIDS ('63, restored) / ALAKAZAM THE GREAT ('60) / DARKER THAN AMBER ('70) / THEY WON'T BELIEVE ME ('47) / CROSSWINDS ('51) / JIVARO ('54)

Wanted TV-on-DVD: T.H.E. CAT (1966-67) / SUSPICION (1957-58) / WAY OUT (1961) / ALFRED HITCHCOCK HOUR (1962-65) / PANIC! (1957-58) / CORONET BLUE (1965) / DRAGNET ('50s) / NEW ADVENTURES OF HUCK FINN (1968) / BUS STOP (1961-62) / THE WESTERNER (1960) / THE IMMORTAL (1970) / BLUE LIGHT (1966) / TERRIERS (2010) / THE MAN WHO NEVER WAS (1966)


#19 of 36 Andy Sheets

Andy Sheets

    Screenwriter

  • 2,371 posts
  • Join Date: Aug 06 2000

Posted February 14 2006 - 06:36 AM

I think a major issue is that a lot of the good guys vs. bad guys conflicts that drove the old westerns have been co-opted by modern day cop and gangster movies. The genres aren't precisely the same, but it seems like a lot of the essence overlaps. I remember when Tombstone came out and I was chatting with a co-worker of mine who said she hated westerns but loved Tombstone because it reminded her of gangster movies.

#20 of 36 Nathan V

Nathan V

    Supporting Actor

  • 960 posts
  • Join Date: Jul 16 2002

Posted February 14 2006 - 07:22 AM

Quote:
Are we in a post-modern era? I don't think so.


Care to explain that, Simon? Are you saying it's over, or do you think it never happened and we're still in the modernist period?

Regards,
Nathan
The Tree of Life / Brad Pitt / Sean Penn / Directed by Terrence Malick / 2010


Back to Movies (Theatrical)



Forum Nav Content I Follow