Michael Elliott
Senior HTF Member
Paul McCartney’s Get Back
:star:1/2/:star::star::star::star:
Studio: Lions Gate
Year: 1991
Rated: PG
Film Length: 92 minutes
Aspect Ratio: Standard (4:3)
Audio: Dolby Digital 2.0 Stereo Surround
Subtitles: English (cc)
Retail Price: $19.95
I guess I should admit right from the start that I’ve never been a huge fan of The Beatles but I can certainly understand their appeal. Without starting a war in this thread, I’ve always enjoyed the later day songs but some of the early albums never really struck a core with me. I should probably also go on to admit that I actually prefer Paul McCartney solo and when I do listen to The Beatles, it’s often from the live DVD of Paul’s 2002 world tour, which I was lucky enough to see in person at the April 11th show in Chicago.
Since I haven’t followed the group too closely, my brief bit of research on Get Back is that this was the first time Paul had toured in thirteen years and this video was taken from forty-five different cities in thirteen countries and that includes 184,368 people in Rio de Janeiro, which is in the Guiness World Records for the most people in attendance for a concert. Having just recently watched A Hard Day’s Night, I was interested that Richard Lester also filmed this concert, which contains plenty of classics from The Beatles as well as work from Wings and McCartney’s current (at the time) album.
As a smaller fan, I was really letdown by this film not only in the actual filmmaking aspect but I also felt the concert itself was really disappointing especially after loving the Back in the U.S. disc. Right from the start it appeared McCartney’s voice wasn’t in the greatest shape but this here didn’t sound too bad. Again, it was just disappointing compared to that 2002 tour. The biggest problem I had with McCartney was the performance itself. I’m not sure how this tour was looked at but this film really leads to a boring performance and it appears through the track that the singer really isn’t into the thing.
Band on the Run is a personal favorite of mine and it would seem like a good opener but the lack of energy really set a slow pace for the rest of the show. Another favorite from that 2002 tour was The Long and Winding Road, which was full of wonderful emotion yet here it appears McCartney is simply singing by the numbers and it appears he’s tired of singing the thing, which is strange since this was his first tour in thirteen years. Other Beatles favorites like Back in the USSR and I Saw Her Standing There don’t fare any better.
The concert (and Paul) picks up a bit of steam with Let it Be and Hey Jude but I think these are two songs that not even a drunk could mess up. Throughout the twenty-one tracks these two were the only once that got me moving in the slightest bit. Outside the rather shaky performance, director Richard Lester really doesn’t do anyone any favors by cutting up the concert with some of the dumbest footage I’ve seen in a concert film. The Beatles footage is certainly nice to see but other stuff like the astronauts on the moon is just pointless and really doesn’t add anything to the song. For some strange reason Lester seems to think people want to see clips over McCartney.
I was really looking forward to this film but sadly I was left disappointed at each and every turn. I really loved McCartney in concert but this here really left a bad taste in my mouth. Again, I’m not an expert on The Beatles or their solo tours but this was one of the most disappointing concerts I’ve seen. Perhaps it was just the timeframe this thing was recorded because even my favorite Bob Dylan was going through a bad period during this time. Get Back will certainly be getting back in its case and won’t get another play from me.
VIDEO---The film is presented full frame but I’m really not sure if this is the correct ratio or not. If this thing played theatrically then it should have been matted here but I’m not certain about this so perhaps a fan of the film will speak up on this issue.
Aspect ratio aside, we’ve got a fairly ugly transfer here. The darker scenes appear way too dark and there’s small amounts of dirt on the print, which can clearly be seen on bigger display systems. I’m going to guess this was originally a very colorful concert but the lack of any detail really drowns that out here. The colors are all very muted and faded, which adds to the ugliness. I didn’t see one strong bit a detail anywhere through the film, which will disappoint most. Another issue is some minor bleeding, which occurs throughout the film. I think it can easily be said this was taken directly from a VHS source and while I haven’t seen the VHS, I might take a guess a say it would offer better quality.
AUDIO---We get a Dolby Digital 2.0 Stereo Surround track, which I’m unhappy to report is the worst sounding track that I’ve heard in a very long time. We could look at this in various ways but no matter which way you look at it you’re going to be severely disappointed in this thing. Some might say you can’t expect too much from something made in 1991 but that excuse can’t be made anymore especially after the brilliant sounding Live Aid. I really don’t know where to start with this track but I guess the opening song of “Band on the Run” would be a good place. As soon as the music starts up things are so low sounding that I actually thought I had accidentally turned the volume all the way down. I normally listen to concert DVDs set at 20 but I had to crank this thing up to 30 and I still couldn’t feel any punch. McCartney’s voice is very low throughout, which sometimes makes the lyrics hard to understand. The musical instruments aren’t in any better shape because they all bleed together and nothing comes off sounding very fresh. The worst part is when McCartney and the band go to punch things up and jam. The “louder” parts of the concert sound just as quiet as the dead space in between the songs. This was my first time viewing this film but I can’t help but think that even a VHS would sound better than this thing.
EXTRAS---We get trailers for Buena Vista Social Club and The Five Heartbeats, which still carry the Artisan logo. The funny thing is that the previous are advertising these as “now on VHS”.
OVERALL---I’m not sure how die-hard Beatles fans look at this show but I was really letdown by the entire thing from start to finish. If I enjoy an artist I’ll usually listen to whatever they do but this thing here won’t go back into my player. If you’re a fan then I’d recommend the Back in the U.S. disc long before this thing here. Sadly, if you are a fan then you’re going to be bitterly disappointed with this transfer, which looks horrid. Even worse is the incredibly bad Stereo track, which adds no life to the concert. From the “now on VHS” clips on the trailers, I think I can fairly say this thing was taken from a VHS source and no added work was done. In other words, if you own the VHS then there’s no need to upgrade here.
Release Date: Out Now