Jump to content



Sign up for a free account!

Signing up for an account is fast and free. As a member you can join in the conversation, enter contests to win things like this Logitech Harmony Ultimate Remote and you won't get the popup ads that guests get. Click here to create your free account.

Photo

HTF REVIEW: Star Trek - The Complete First Season

DVD Reviews TV Reviews

This topic has been archived. This means that you cannot reply to this topic.
213 replies to this topic

#1 of 214 Scott Kimball

Scott Kimball

    Screenwriter

  • 1,500 posts
  • Join Date: May 08 2000

Posted August 20 2004 - 01:09 AM

Posted Image

Star Trek: The Complete First Season





Studio: Paramount

Year: 1966-67

Rated: NR

Length: 24 hours, 21 Minutes

Aspect Ratio: 1.33:1

Audio: Dolby Digital 5.1 English; English Dolby Surround

English subtitles; Closed Captioned in English

Special Features: 5 featurettes, Text commentary on 4 episodes, Original trailers, Photo gallery, Easter eggs

Expected Street Price: Around $100 USD
Release Date: August 31, 2004





As a Star Trek fan, I have long been dismayed at the cost of collecting my favorite television show in the best consumer video medium available. Between the high cost of the two-episode discs, the agonizingly slow release schedule, and the amount of space required to store all the discs, I took a pass on collecting this series in it’s initial DVD release. Oh, the pain, the pain...

To be fair, in the early days of DVD, studios never thought to release television shows by the season. Who knew that there was such an eager audience awaiting expensive boxed sets?

Twentieth Century Fox Home Entertainment broke the season barrier on DVD with the release of X-Files season one. The show flew off of store shelves, even with a price tag exceeding $100USD for the season. TV on DVD was changed forever.

Fans of the original Star Trek have had a long wait. That wait is over. Finally, a chance to see Kirk’s swagger, Spock’s arched brow, McCoy’s crankiness, Scotty’s protestations about over-taxing his engines... all in one season set. Okay, okay... bring on season two!

Star Trek: The Complete First Season beams to a store near you on August 31, 2004.


Packaging
Posted Image

Star Trek: The Complete First Season arrives on DVD in some fancy packaging. About the size and shape of your average tricorder (I can only imagine), this rugged plastic, golden box contains a set of 8 discs, packaged in jewel-case sized page-bound digipaks. The entire package takes up the same amount of shelf space as a 7-disc set of Star Trek: The Next Generation. When I first saw photographs of this set, I feared a severely oversized package. On the contrary, this set takes up a minimum of shelf space.

The outer plastic shell seems very rugged. It is hinged at the bottom and splits open the long way, down the center, to reveal the paper-sleeved digipaks. The cover art of the digipak sleeve can be viewed through a small window on the front of the box, and the words “Season One” can be viewed through small windows on either spine.

Posted Image

Posted Image

The outer case opens up very easily, revealing the sparse vault-like interior. There is no artwork inside, once the digipak and inserts are removed. The interior is entirely utilitarian in nature.

The sleeve on the digipak fits rather snugly, making it a challenge to remove and replace at first... though it does seem to loosen up with use. Given that the cover art on the sleeve is integral to the outer packaging design, it would have been nice if a more durable plastic sleeve was used, such as a smaller version of that which was used on DS9. For me, this is the weakest link of the package design - and the most vulnerable to damage.

A two-sided, six panel, jewel-case sized fan-fold insert is included, which has a capsule review of each episode, and some Star Trek history.

As for the disc art, each disc has a headshot of a principle cast member, along with original airdates and stardates for each episode on the disc.

All in all, the packaging is attractive, inventive, and space conscious. Kudos to Paramount for coming up with an unusual design that is attractive, durable and small. They would have scored a bulls eye with a more durable inner sleeve.

Menus and Navigation

Here’s an area where, no matter the design, some people will be unhappy. I’m talking about menu animations. These animations are well done, and ride that fine line of an animation which takes too long to get out of the way. From the moment the menu fades in (after the copyright screen) until you can make an episode selection, twenty unskippable seconds will have passed. Compare that to about twenty-five seconds for a TNG menu. If the entire animation could be skipped by hitting the “menu” key, I’m sure that few would complain.

The animation from the episode selection screen to the next screen is only five seconds, and shouldn’t be an issue for most people.

The menu layout is logical and easy to navigate, with a main menu that lists the episodes vertically, in airdate order, but also provides the production number for reference.

Once you click on an episode title, you’ll be brought to the episode screen, which is simply laid out on a graphic of the Enterprise bridge console. The “Play” option is highlighted by default.

Other options on the episode screen include Communications, Chapter Log, Preview Trailer and Return. Those episode that feature a text commentary offer the option to turn the feature on or off after you select “Play.”

The only variance from this layout is on disc 8, in the Special Features menu. There are three easy-to-find easter eggs, called “Red Shirt Logs,” which can be accessed from this menu.

See a 684KB Quicktime capture of the menus in action (3fps)


The Episodes

What matters most isn’t the packaging, or the menus, or even the special features. What we really want is the episodes. The classic, original Star Trek is illustrative of the rare sci-fi television show that didn’t have to rev up for a whole season before delivering quality episodes. Some of the finest episodes of the series’ run appear right here, in season one.

For this review, I screened: Where No Man Has Gone Before, The Naked Time, The Enemy Within, Tomorrow is Yesterday, Space Seed, and The City on the Edge of Forever. That’s six episodes, and I didn’t see half of my “favorites.”

It is beyond the scope of this review to give a summary of each of the episodes. I imagine that most people interested in buying this set are intimately familiar with the episodes, anyway.

Here is a list of the episodes in season one, in broadcast order, as they appear on DVD:

Disc One: The Man Trap, Charlie X, Where No Man Has Gone Before, The Naked Time.

Disc Two: The Enemy Within, Mudd’s Women, What Are Little Girls Made Of?, Miri

Disc Three: Dagger of the Mind, The Corbomite Maneuver, The Menagerie Part 1, The Menagerie Part 2

Disc Four: The Conscience of the King, Balance of Terror, Shore Leave, The Galileo Seven

Disc Five: The Squire of Gothos, Arena, Tomorrow is Yesterday, Court Martial

Disc Six: The Return of the Archons, Space Seed, A Taste of Armageddon, This Side of Paradise

Disc Seven: The Devil in the Dark, Errand of Mercy, The Alternative Factor, The City on the Edge of Forever

Disc Eight: Operation Annihilate!, Special Features: The Birth of a Timeless Legacy, Life Beyond Trek: William Shatner, To Boldly Go... Season One, Reflections on Spock, Sci-fi Visionaries, Photo Log

If I had to pick three favorites... well, it would be a tough choice. Here are three possibilities:

Balance of Terror
Humans have never seen a Romulan in person, despite skirmishes with the race over the years. The Enterprise, in pursuit of a Romulan ship that had made incursions into Federation space, makes a startling discovery about this enigmatic race. The episode features guest star Mark Lenard as a Romulan captain, before he took on the role of Spock’s father, Sarek.

Space Seed
The Enterprise encounters the S.S. Botany Bay, a twentieth century Earth sleeper ship. Only after reviving the leader from his suspended animation do they discover that he and his crew are a renegade band of genetically engineered humans... who intend to take over the Enterprise.

The City on the Edge of Forever
After an accidental overdose causes McCoy to become mentally unstable, he leaves the ship and passes through The Guardian of Forever, a time portal on an alien planet. After going through, he inadvertently alters the timeline. Kirk and Spock go back to stop him, in 1930’s Earth.


The Transfers

For those of you who have (or have seen) Paramount’s previous two-episode releases of the series, by all appearances the video and audio quality is identical in this season set. I was unable to do a side-by-side comparison, but that seems to be the case, and is the consensus of those who have previewed the set.

For those of you who haven’t seen Star Trek on DVD, read on for the details.

Video

The transfers are in the original, 1.33:1 aspect ratio. They are remarkably sharp, especially when comparing them to transfers of newer Star Trek series. The only notable exception to the sharpness is the intentional use of soft-focus photography that is well-known on Star Trek, and the occasional accidental off-focus camera negative. Grain is variable, as on the original film elements, and shows up with great frequency on optical effects shots (no surprise there). There is no overt evidence of sharpening artifacts.

The colors are beautiful, vibrant and deeply saturated, but are slightly variable from one episode to the next. The red channel sometimes seems slightly oversaturated by my eyes, and this is verified when looking at a chroma histogram of some still captures. It’s hard to fault the high saturation, since saturation was pushed purposefully at the request of NBC when the series was shot, in an effort to show off new color television technology. While the saturation pushes the limits of some displays, it is rare that channels are actually clipped.

Dust and scratches are present to a minor degree, but the prints were nicely cleaned before the transfer. You’ll notice the dust much more in the multilayered optical effects shots. Short of digital removal of these artifacts, there is only little room for improvement in this area.

Unfortunately, an issue that cropped up on the last release of the episode, City on the Edge of Forever, is still present in this release. There is some vertical jitter present intermittently throughout the episode. The jitter is minor, but tolerance for such a defect varies by person. I can see it clearly on my 32” display, and found it a bit of an annoyance. Furthering this annoyance, this defect has spoiled one of the most loved episodes in all of Star Trek. Why couldn’t this have happened to Spock’s Brain instead of this classic episode?

That one defect aside, the video on this season release is impressive, and stands up well against many more modern TV on DVD releases.

Audio

There are two tracks available for your listening pleasure: a Dolby Digital 5.1 English remix, and a Dolby Surround English remix. Unfortunately, the original monaural tracks are not included.

The 5.1 remix is quite well done, only calling attention to itself occasionally. Stereo and surround effects are fairly subtle, as they should be. You’ll hear the Enterprise whoosh by in the opening credits, which is kind of cool... and the music takes on new life with the additional channels. The one thing that caught my attention was the LFE track. Mostly silent, the subwoofer comes alive during key sequences (explosions and the like). While the LFE isn’t overpowering, it is so unexpected for me to hear low frequency response while watch classic Trek episodes, that it gave me an occasional start. I may have to consider viewing the rest of these episodes with my subwoofer powered off, to more closely approximate the way it’s supposed to be. At least, it’s not the way I remember watching Star Trek in early syndication runs in the 1970’s.

I would have been happier if Paramount had included restored mono tracks as an option, but the 5.1 track delivers good fidelity without overdoing the effects (for the most part).


Special Features

Text Commentary by Michael and Denise Okuda these episodes:
Where No Man Has Gone Before
I watched this episode with the commentary on. Those who are familiar with Okuda’s text commentaries know what to expect, here. This text commentary felt a little “watered down” compared to some others that Okuda has done, probably, in part, because he didn’t have the first-hand knowledge that he had with his commentaries from the other Star Trek discs. There are some interesting factoids in here, amongst the obvious “Captain Kirk is played by William Shatner” type of comments. It’s worth a look.
The Menagerie, Part 1
The Menagerie, Part 2
The Conscience of the King


Featurettes

The Birth of a Timeless Legacy
(24:14)
This featurette tells us how Star Trek began - and how it almost died twice before it ever aired. Featuring archival interviews with Gene Roddenberry, and new interviews with William Shatner, Leonard Nimoy, Robert Justman, Nichelle Nichols, George Takei, James Doohan, D.C. Fontana, and others.

The featurette begins with a meandering monologue by a laryngitis afflicted William Shatner... but stay tuned, it gets better...

Leonard Nimoy talks for a couple minutes about his ears.

There is discussion of the two pilots for the show and selling the show to the network. Star Trek got a greenlight on a second chance after being rejected by NBC once - almost unprecedented for the time. We learn about the changes in casting and style that were made in order to get the show on the air.

It was good to see some of the minor cast members involved in this, though they don’t get much screen time. They do each have very relevant contributions to the documentary.

DeForest Kelley is not forgotten... D.C. Fontana speaks about him for a bit.

It’s an interesting documentary, although many serious fans will learn little that they didn’t already know.

Life Beyond Trek: William Shatner (10:27)
Unless you like horses, you will probably have little interest in this fluff piece about Shatner’s love for the animals, and his involvement in riding and reigning competitions. Shatner does most of his talking from atop his horse, and demonstrates some moves.

“To Boldly Go”... Season One (18:59)
Most of this featurette involves cast and crew reflecting on the episodes of season one. Leonard Nimoy, Robert Justman and William Shatner talk about the gamble that DesiLu took in making this series, and the fact that the entire shooting budget wouldn’t pay for the catering for many of today’s television shows.

Brief discussion is made of NBC choosing The Man Trap as the first show to air, and how few shows were complete at the time the decision was made.

Justman talks about running seriously behind on scripts for the season, and so the “envelope” show, the two part The Menagerie was written quickly to fill the gap, using a large amount of footage from the unseen pilot.

Ricardo Montalban and William Campbell are interviewed about their contributions as guest stars, and mention is made of Harlan Ellison’s City on the Edge of Forever.


Reflections on Spock (12:13)
Leonard Nimoy discusses his character, Spock, in depth. Much of this piece is centered around his controversial and much misunderstood book, “I Am Not Spock,” and how the misperceptions in the book endangered his future in the franchise. Nimoy also mentions his followup book, “I Am Spock.”


Sci-Fi Visionaries (16:39)
D.C. Fontana, John D. F. Black and others talk about Star Trek’s famous writers, including: Harlan Ellison, Richard Matheson, George Clayton Thomas, Gene Roddenberry and others. The producers of the show sought out famous name sci-fi writers during the first season, in hopes they would draw in a loyal viewership.


Photo Log
40 or so stills from different episodes.

“Red Shirt Logs” (easter eggs)
#1 (4:17)
George Takei defends his honor with the sword... sets us straight on the rumors on the convention circuit. An amusing story involving he and James Doohan while filming “The Naked Time.”

#2 (1:55)
Robert Justman talks about a “forced perspective” shot in “The Cage”


#3 (1:36)
Robert Justman talks about the casting of Clint Howard in “The Corbomite Maneuver.”


Preview Trailers are available for each episode, on each episode menu.


Final Thoughts


Paramount has put out a nice boxed set here, with innovative packaging and good A/V quality on the episodes. The special features are interesting, for the most part... though a bit lacking in substance. Most Trekkies will want to check them out, but few will really learn anything new. If only those elusive blooper reels could have made there way in as a special feature...

Every Star Trek fan deserves to have Star Trek in their DVD collection. I recommend this season set without reservation to Trek fans who haven’t purchased a significant number of the previously released discs.

For those who have collected all or most of the previous releases on DVD, I really can’t see an overly compelling reason to upgrade. Yes, the special features are interesting, the packaging is nice... but the meat of the set is the episodes themselves, and they are apparently unchanged from the previous releases.

#2 of 214 Joseph J.D

Joseph J.D

    Screenwriter

  • 2,686 posts
  • Join Date: Dec 04 2001

Posted August 20 2004 - 01:21 AM

Nice review.....as I only picked up the final disc from the previous collection (The Cage), I will definitely pick these season sets up. Too bad about the vertical jitter problem you mentioned though.
Recently watched- Basic Instinct 2, Taken 2, Maverick(1994), After Earth, The Girl With The Dragon Tattoo(2009), The Hobbit: The Desolation Of Smaug 3D, The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey EE 3D, Star Wars: Return Of The Jedi, Star Wars: The Empire Strikes Back, Star Wars: A New Hope, Star Wars: Revenge Of The Sith, Star Wars: Attack Of The Clones

Currently watching- Planet Earth, The Twilight Zone: Season 1, Cheers: Season 6, True Blood: Season 2, Gatchaman: The Complete Series, Simon & Simon: Season 3
 

"If this is to end in fire...then we will all burn together."


#3 of 214 Todd Hostettler

Todd Hostettler

    Second Unit

  • 285 posts
  • Join Date: Jun 07 1999

Posted August 20 2004 - 02:29 AM

Quote:
Oh, the pain, the pain...

Wrong show. Posted Image



Glad I stuck to my self-imposed "no double dip" moratorium, and just held onto my original cherry-picked twofer discs. The few so-so eps, such as The Omega Glory and The Gamesters of Triskelion that I originally skipped, I just picked up on eBay for on average of $3 apiece.

In the end, I'll have slightly less than 30 out of the 40 released volumes. No Spock's Brain or Lights of Zetar... but I think I can deal.

#4 of 214 Bill Williams

Bill Williams

    Screenwriter

  • 1,699 posts
  • Join Date: May 28 2003

Posted August 20 2004 - 02:41 AM

Quite an excellent review, Scott! Definitely looking forward to picking up this set!

I myself got only four of the 2-episode single discs the first time around, Vol. 1, 8, 34, and 40, so for me it won't be much of a double-dip from the previous DVDs as it will be from the original VHS tapes and the mid-80's telecasts on my local Fox station. I may still keep the original discs, though.
"I have in my heart what it takes to run with the big dogs in this life, and nobody can say otherwise."

"Attention all personnel. Tonight's movie is a holdover from last week and will be shown right after supper, which is also a holdover from last week."

#5 of 214 Tony Whalen

Tony Whalen

    Producer

  • 3,150 posts
  • Join Date: Jan 29 2002

Posted August 20 2004 - 03:07 AM

Great review!!! Thanks!

While I'm certain I'll pick this up, I'm still waiting to hear what Paramount has in mind for the December box-set release. It's getting painful. (PAIN!)

However, as I only ever bought one of the original disks, I'm in either way! (Even though I'm a huge fan, I just couldn't justify 40 disks.)

Look forward to getting this! Posted Image

#6 of 214 Gary Seven

Gary Seven

    Screenwriter

  • 1,380 posts
  • Join Date: Aug 15 2003
  • Real Name:Gaston
  • LocationLake Worth, Florida

Posted August 20 2004 - 03:11 AM

I won't be double dipping on this set but I'm curious when season 3 hits whether "The Tholian Web" has been restored correctly. If so, I may be forced to double dip on what is widely considered the worst season.

#7 of 214 Jack Briggs

Jack Briggs

    Executive Producer

  • 16,725 posts
  • Join Date: Jun 03 1999

Posted August 20 2004 - 03:59 AM

I want to hear from someone who has done a comparo with this release and the earlier releases.

A concern of mine: four episodes per disc as opposed to the earlier releases' two. How might this affect picture quality?

Frankly, I think the earlier TOS releases are the finest Star Trek has ever looked on a home-video format. They are far better than any of the TNG or DS9 releases. Like film, with sharp color and good contrast.

In fact, I've seen some episodes on 16mm film ("I, Mudd," "The Man Trap," etc.). I like the DVDs more.

#8 of 214 Colin Jacobson

Colin Jacobson

    Producer

  • 5,200 posts
  • Join Date: Apr 19 2000

Posted August 20 2004 - 05:55 AM

Quote:
A concern of mine: four episodes per disc as opposed to the earlier releases' two. How might this affect picture quality?


Since they old discs were single-layered and the new ones are dual-layered, it shouldn't - it's not like they crammed all four shows onto one layer...
Colin Jacobson
http://www.dvdmg.com

#9 of 214 Doug Otte

Doug Otte

    Supporting Actor

  • 692 posts
  • Join Date: Jun 20 2003

Posted August 20 2004 - 07:06 AM

I'm on the fence so far with these sets. I've also got about 20 of the 2-fors w/ my favorite episodes (hmmm...nothing from season 3, although I enjoyed some of them). The fact that the small problems are still there (I never noticed the jitters in City, but I bet I will when I get a big HDTV!), and the anemic nature of the extras makes me pause. However, that package is cool and would look nice on the shelf.

Why does Paramount continue to be so sloppy w/ errors? The picture inside the case isn't from season one, is it? Isn't it from Day of the Dove? I bet the pictures of the actors on the discs aren't all from season one, either. And on the BB bonus disk (not that I ever buy Trek sets from BB): Romance in the 24th Century? Oy.

Cheers,
Doug

#10 of 214 JoSAN

JoSAN

    Second Unit

  • 433 posts
  • Join Date: Aug 08 2004

Posted August 20 2004 - 07:11 AM

.

#11 of 214 Scott Kimball

Scott Kimball

    Screenwriter

  • 1,500 posts
  • Join Date: May 08 2000

Posted August 20 2004 - 07:30 AM

Quote:
Why does Paramount continue to be so sloppy w/ errors? The picture inside the case isn't from season one, is it? Isn't it from Day of the Dove? I bet the pictures of the actors on the discs aren't all from season one, either.


Now, don't be too quick to jump on Paramount. I believe they got it right, this time. I think the cover picture is from "A Taste of Armageddon."

The disc art is very generic headshots... virtually impossible to tell what episode they came from. And, they DON'T have Chekov on a disc... so they got that right. The disc art is of: Kirk, Spock, McCoy, Scott, Sulu, Uhura, Rand, and disc 8 has a picture of the Enterprise

Quote:
1) About this "jitter problem" on City on the Edge of Forever... Is it something that was filmed originally -- or is it due to a transfer problem to DVD?


It certainly doesn't look like an original film problem... it looks more like a mis-calibrated telecine or some other mishap during the transfer. As for the duration of the jitter, I didn't time it. It comes and goes, and is on the order of minutes, not seconds.

Quote:
2) Are the discs easily removed from the hubs of the digipak trays?


Yes.

-Scott

#12 of 214 Ronald Epstein

Ronald Epstein

    Studio Mogul

  • 38,954 posts
  • Join Date: Jul 03 1997

Posted August 20 2004 - 07:33 AM

Jack,

You have been asking the same questions over
and over again. I can understand why. You
are a huge fan and you want to know if it is
worth double-dipping on this set.

Every review I have read thus far -- from
THE DIGITAL BITS to Scott Kimball to my very own
review -- all say the same thing.....

The difference in picture quality is almost
negligable. I saw no difference in picture
quality. Scott and Bill Hunt saw minor
improvement, with Hunt commenting on a slightly
sharper picture due to better compression.

I would bet you play these side-by-side to
most ordinary spectators and they will find very
little difference in the picture quality.

In my opinion, even if someone sees the slightest
improvement in this new set, it still does not
justify double-dipping if all you are interested
in is the transfer quality of the shows.

Those shows looked awesome in their original
DVD release and there is very little that could
be done to improve them today outside of a massive
Lowry-type restoration to remove dirt and scratches.

Now....

If the supplements (which don't seem that great)
or the fact that you can free up some shelve space
are your top priority, then perhaps it is worth
double-dipping.

What I am getting at, based on my personal experience
and all I have read thus far, the improvement in
transfer is not enough to justify double-dipping.

Ronald J Epstein
Home Theater Forum co-owner

 

gallery_269895_23_10043.jpg Click Here for the latest/hottest Blu-ray Preorders gallery_269895_23_1316.jpg Click Here for our complete Blu-ray review archive

gallery_269895_23_773.jpg Click Here for our complete 3D Blu-ray review archive gallery_269895_23_992.jpgClick Here for our complete DVD review archive

gallery_269895_23_7246.jpg Click Here for Blu-Ray Preorder Release Schedule gallery_269895_23_3120.jpg Click Here for forum posting rules and regulations


#13 of 214 Ric Easton

Ric Easton

    Screenwriter

  • 2,812 posts
  • Join Date: Feb 06 2001

Posted August 20 2004 - 09:12 AM

Of course I bought all of these when Paramount was saying they would not be releasing box sets.

I'm really on the fence, I love extras, but don't expect to learn anything new from them. Still, the pull is strong. I'm also irritated by the fact that to have the complete extras, I gotta go with Best Buy's bonus discs.

I suppose I can sell my originals on Ebay in my special packaging. That should save me a few bucks.

Ric

#14 of 214 Britton

Britton

    Supporting Actor

  • 904 posts
  • Join Date: Jun 03 2001

Posted August 20 2004 - 09:25 AM

Well, I made a post in the Studio/Manufacturer feedback forum about "The City on the Edge of Forever". It probably won't make a difference, but I'd really hate to see this vertical jittering show up whenever this episode is released on whatever future video format there may be. I only hope I didn't come across as too much of a whiner. Posted Image

Anyway, here's a link to the forum:
http://www.hometheat....38#post2345336

#15 of 214 Ric Easton

Ric Easton

    Screenwriter

  • 2,812 posts
  • Join Date: Feb 06 2001

Posted August 20 2004 - 09:40 AM

Oops, sorry Scott... I forgot to mention... EXCELLENT REVIEW!

Ric

#16 of 214 Daron

Daron

    Agent

  • 34 posts
  • Join Date: Jul 25 2001

Posted August 20 2004 - 10:54 AM

Scott and Ron,

Thank you for your excellent reporting on this new set! I just thought of something that could help us determine if Paramount is fixing those mastering problems on the original 40 DVD set for this new release, and I'm wondering if you two could check some of these episodes out to investigate.

The problems I recall from first season episodes in the original set were:

1. Use of different opening theme music in episodes 3-13. I believe they used the music from "Where No Man Has Gone Before", with Shatner's narration added, for these episodes... but fans posting on the internet complained on this very message board, so Paramount went back to using the original music from episodes 14 on.

2. In "The Menagerie" (part 1 I believe) there's a shot of Spock and Pike grabbing an alien plant shortly after beaming down to Talos IV. When Spock grabs the plant, the background sound effect is supposed to stop, then start again when Spock lets go. On the first DVD release, the sound doesn't do that. The DVD producers did fix this later in the same scene from "The Cage" (on Volume 40.)

3. You may not be able to distinguish this, but also on "The Menagerie" (both parts I believe) the DVD producers used different music in some scenes... music that actually came from a 1980's rerecording of the music sold in record stores!! I thought it sounded great... but purists may not like it.

Anyway, if you're able to check these out briefly, it could make for an interesting discussion! Some of us are curious about this because we're hoping more serious mastering errors on "The Doomsday Machine", and especially "The Tholian Web" are repaired for the new releases.

Again, thank you for your thorough reporting (and thanks as well for the in-depth review from Bill Hunt at the Digital Bits.) I am planning to buy these new sets, even though I bought the original 40. I'm just such a fanboy...

#17 of 214 Joseph Bolus

Joseph Bolus

    Screenwriter

  • 2,181 posts
  • Join Date: Feb 04 1999

Posted August 20 2004 - 11:08 AM

* Sigh * ...

I was hoping for more from the extras ...

Irregardless, I've just got to have this box, even though I purchased the original two-ep discs ...

When it comes to Star Trek: TOS "Resistance is Futile!"

(Oh ... Wait ...)
Joseph
---------------

#18 of 214 Rob Gardiner

Rob Gardiner

    Screenwriter

  • 2,950 posts
  • Join Date: Feb 15 2002

Posted August 20 2004 - 11:37 AM

First I'd like to offer a big thumbs up to Scott Kimball, Ron Epstein, and Bill Hunt for their various reviews. Posted Image Posted Image Posted Image

I found this other review several days ago but didn't think it would be appropriate to "scoop" the HTF's official review. Note this review is of the R2 version:

http://sci-fi-online....30_ST-TOS1.htm

It appears that, while the shows look better than they have previously (even a tiny bit better than the previous DVDs) there is still plenty of room for improvement. (Emphasis is mine):

Quote:
And now the bad news. The transfer to DVD is bright, colourful and sharp - but peppered with dust, scratches and sparkle. Worse still, every optical shot is crawling with hairs and printed-in muck. The reason this debris is there in the first place is well known - rushed optical houses back in the 60s working against impossible deadlines - but in an age when technology exists to automatically remove the worst of these problems there really is no excuse. It’s not as if this DVD set won’t make back the investment.

Watching the Enterprise orbit a planet in a swarm of fly-like dust and scratches is distracting enough but when great scars of film emulsion slash across the picture it becomes very hard indeed to watch. Shoddy hardly starts to explain how bad some of this looks.

...the transfers used on this set look to be the same ones used on the original region 1 discs - the transfers the BBC said weren’t broadcast standard. And frankly you can see the corporation’s point.

Posted Image

Posted Image

Posted Image

Let's hope that the eventual HD release of this series includes a full video restoration, the original mono soundtracks, fixing of all the miscellaneous errors mentioned by Daron, the true original version of "The Cage" (assuming the season 3 set contains the same reconstructed versions as found on the old discs), and substantial supplements that do this TV show justice.

#19 of 214 ScottR

ScottR

    Screenwriter

  • 2,650 posts
  • Join Date: Apr 01 2000

Posted August 20 2004 - 12:39 PM

So, is the original Desilu logo on the black background with no Paramount copyright on here, or is it the red Desilu logo with the 1978 Paramount copyright plastered on it?

#20 of 214 Dave Scarpa

Dave Scarpa

    Producer

  • 5,274 posts
  • Join Date: Apr 08 1999

Posted August 20 2004 - 01:46 PM

I still say the price of this set warrants the type of digital restoration done for DS9's Tribble show.

Also does anyone else would've preferred the type of packaging they released Happy Days with?

Basically thinpaks with a carboard box, I think I would have
My DVD Collection

The Megaplex


Back to DVD, Blu-ray & Digital Reviews



Forum Nav Content I Follow