Jump to content



Sign up for a free account to remove the pop-up ads

Signing up for an account is fast and free. As a member you can join in the conversation, enter contests and remove the pop-up ads that guests get. Click here to create your free account.

Photo
- - - - -

Do different amps sound different?


This topic has been archived. This means that you cannot reply to this topic.
57 replies to this topic

#1 of 58 OFFLINE   John Roger

John Roger

    Stunt Coordinator



  • 119 posts
  • Join Date: May 12 2004

Posted June 09 2004 - 04:01 AM

As far as amps are concerned the power output is the key factor.Apart from speakers do amps have any role in sound quality?Are brands different in sound quality or is it just about the power and drive?

#2 of 58 OFFLINE   Mike SJ

Mike SJ

    Supporting Actor



  • 718 posts
  • Join Date: Nov 10 2003

Posted June 09 2004 - 04:13 AM

Since you asked, ill ask you to find that out for yourself. this is one of the most debated issues (and spinoffs from this question) with any regards to steereo's, amps, music, etc...

go buy a 200 watt plate power amp and hook it to one speaker while you have a krell 200 watt monoblock attatched to the other speaker.

EDIT: then, since Philip has found a hole in my scientific experiment, put them all in an anechoic to remove room reflections/conditions from tghe equasion...Better philip? "I'll let others tackle that subject" well wHY are you disecting my post for?

all else being exactly the same, which sounds better?

#3 of 58 OFFLINE   BrianWoerndle

BrianWoerndle

    Supporting Actor



  • 794 posts
  • Join Date: Feb 19 2002

Posted June 09 2004 - 05:06 AM

Well the difference between the Denon's internal amps and my Marantz monoblocks is very noticable.
The only way to safely double your money is to fold it over once and place it back in your pocket.

http://www.cube17576.com

#4 of 58 OFFLINE   RobWil

RobWil

    Supporting Actor



  • 733 posts
  • Join Date: Mar 17 2003

Posted June 09 2004 - 05:37 AM

Cool! A new subject that hasn't been discussed yet! Woo-hoo!
that's my story and I'm stickin' to it!

#5 of 58 OFFLINE   Philip Hamm

Philip Hamm

    Lead Actor



  • 6,885 posts
  • Join Date: Jan 23 1999

Posted June 09 2004 - 05:46 AM

Quote:
go buy a 200 watt plate power amp and hook it to one speaker while you have a krell 200 watt monoblock attatched to the other speaker.
all else being exactly the same, which sounds better?
Since you've got two different speakers, "all else" will never be "exactly the same". You'll have two different room reactions to the speakers.

Theoretically, if amplifiers are designed well, they all should sound the same since they all have the same mission, simply amplify an electrical signal. In practice do they sound the same? I'll let others tackle that subject.

I just went from $2000+ MSRP separates to a 7 year old receiver which I bought refurbished for $160 about 3 years ago (that originally MSRPed $700). I kept my speakers the same.

I'll never go back.

You not only have to decide if the amps "sound the same", but also address the more important question is "is the percieved difference worth it to me?". I decided that it's not. Others are willing to pay for that difference. Used gear like my old stuff can be a real bargain.
Philip Hamm
Moderator Emeritus

#6 of 58 OFFLINE   RobertR

RobertR

    Lead Actor



  • 9,532 posts
  • Join Date: Dec 19 1998

Posted June 09 2004 - 06:13 AM

Quote:
Apart from speakers do amps have any role in sound quality?Are brands different in sound quality or is it just about the power and drive?

If you're talking about modern solid state amps, then if neither amp's power capability is exceeded, and neither amp is driven into a load it has a hard time with, then it's unlikely you'll hear a difference, the silly hyperbole of High End writers notwithstanding.

#7 of 58 OFFLINE   Mike SJ

Mike SJ

    Supporting Actor



  • 718 posts
  • Join Date: Nov 10 2003

Posted June 09 2004 - 06:17 AM

phil, I edited above just for you.

#8 of 58 OFFLINE   Andrew Pratt

Andrew Pratt

    Producer



  • 3,813 posts
  • Join Date: Dec 08 1998

Posted June 09 2004 - 06:36 AM

From my findings different amps do sound different...for example my HK amp sounds more "dull" then my Rotel and its not a subtle change at all (i.e. my wife notices the differences)

#9 of 58 OFFLINE   Yogi

Yogi

    Screenwriter



  • 1,741 posts
  • Join Date: Jul 25 2002

Posted June 09 2004 - 06:56 AM

The differences between amps is subtle but there nevertheless. Ideally amps should only amplify signals just like speakers should only convert electrical signals into sound waves, so ideally if an amp was well designed it shouldn't add to the orignal signal just like a speaker if was well designed shouldn't add to the orignal signal. But the world is not ideal and neither are amps and speakers. That being said differences between speakers are much more pronounced (because speakers are much more poorly designed in the 'ideal' sense) than amps which are quite well designed (at least these days) so unless you know what to hear for you won't hear much difference between two amps when playing with in their limits (as specified by Bob) and esp in HT. Again that being said for normal movie watching at reference or close to reference levels most receivers and even most separate amps will clip or at least go close to that point of non-linearity and so most often you will be able to hear a difference between them in terms of dynamic impact and compression. For example some time ago I was watching Monsters Inc. at a store with Monster power amps (what a coincidence) with digital power meters and during most of the movie the power consumption was in the range of 5-10 watts per channel, but when ever there was a moderately loud scene like choppers flying, thumps, thuds etc the power consumption would jump up in the 100W range and on the explosion scenes, like the sock detonation scene the power consumption jumped up to more than 500W!. Now during these scenes the speaker impedance probably drops into the 4ohm range and most receivers wont be able to deliver those kinds of power and will certainly clip and you will be able to hear that. So when ever someone says that their movie watching experience improved dramatically after adding separate amps, what they are hearing is these improvements in dynamic impact and headroom. So even though its true that most amps will sound the same in their linear range it is also true that most amps are often asked to deliver more than what they are capable of in their linear range. And certainly not all amps clip the same and certainly not all amps have similar power supply headroom to deliver the demanding scenes. So even though amps could sound the same in the first few watts its the last few watts that separate the boys from the men. So not all amps are the same when it comes to performance in real home theater environments. If you dont believe me take a $100 Sony (for example) receiver to any of the stores like Tweeter or GoodGuys and hook it up in their main theater room and try watching a high impact movie at moderate loud level (not reference level).

Remember DD mandates 20db dynamic headroom for movies, so if your speakers are moderate sensitivity (86-89db) and you dont live in a shoe box you would be listening at 2-3 watts most of the time but you need 100 times more power (200-300W) for those high impact scenes without compression. Most receivers dont deliver those kinds of power even for fractions of second.
The truth is not out there but within you.

#10 of 58 OFFLINE   Claude M

Claude M

    Stunt Coordinator



  • 240 posts
  • Join Date: Jan 18 2001

Posted June 09 2004 - 07:01 AM

speakers have alot to do with it too. I have a pair of Phase Linear P580 speakers http://www.phaseline...es_speakers.htm that no matter what I hook them up to they sound great. An old Technics 60W/channel receiver at normal volume (and not telac's1812) sounded much the same as an MCA 3 Anthem and an old Soundcraftsmen MA5002. The same tests with a pair of marble Norhs and each amp had its own distinct sound.

#11 of 58 OFFLINE   Mike SJ

Mike SJ

    Supporting Actor



  • 718 posts
  • Join Date: Nov 10 2003

Posted June 09 2004 - 07:07 AM

"speakers have alot to do with it too"

Claude, speakers are not apart of this equation. what is being discussed here is how much a power amp ALONE could create a different signal than other AMPS.

"Apart from speakers do amps have any role in sound quality"
that was the original ?

understandibly the speakers will inevitably change the sound too, but lets give Mr. John Roger some benefit of doubt and assume he already knows this.

#12 of 58 OFFLINE   John Roger

John Roger

    Stunt Coordinator



  • 119 posts
  • Join Date: May 12 2004

Posted June 09 2004 - 07:08 AM

I've heard some people saying this amp is brighter than the other etc.Maybe it has a better equalizer.
I haven't compared amps on same speakers.Just wanna know if this quality stuff is to be considered when i upgrade.

And of course speaker quality does affect sound quality.Question is do amps?

#13 of 58 OFFLINE   Mike SJ

Mike SJ

    Supporting Actor



  • 718 posts
  • Join Date: Nov 10 2003

Posted June 09 2004 - 07:24 AM

John, let me reiterate,
This is abaout THE most debated subject in audio circles.
It deals in different material (paper or polypropelyne, etc) for resistors, capacitors... within the amp, differences in amp classes (a a/b b d g i....)
Differences in amp design (push pull or not)
and so on and so on and so on. People even spend over $1000
on a power "cleaner" to make sure they have "clean power" going to the amps.

What makes what sound differently, how much different and is it worth $XX? im sure Jim Lansing is still thinking about those questions.


"I've heard some people saying this amp is brighter than the other etc.Maybe it has a better equalizer."

{amps dont have eq's, thats the pre-amp stage.}

warm sounding - highs have been rolled off (tube gear is said to be warm sounding)
bright sounding - a more "in your face" type of sound, (typical of horn tweeters)

as far as where the line of quality vs $ or how much is too much to spend, or will a $20000 system bring me 10 times as much musical/movie pleasure as a $2000 system, is, well thats totally up to you? sucks dont it Posted Image

#14 of 58 OFFLINE   RobertR

RobertR

    Lead Actor



  • 9,532 posts
  • Join Date: Dec 19 1998

Posted June 09 2004 - 07:26 AM

Quote:
I've heard some people saying this amp is brighter than the other etc.Maybe it has a better equalizer.
Competently designed amps don't equalize anything. That is, they don't emphasize or deemphasize any part of the frequency spectrum to any significant degree. So there's no basis (other than a psychological one) for saying that one amp sounds brighter than another.

An example would be listening to a black colored amp vs. a white colored one. People will say that the black colored one sounds "darker", even though the internal design is the same.

#15 of 58 OFFLINE   Mike SJ

Mike SJ

    Supporting Actor



  • 718 posts
  • Join Date: Nov 10 2003

Posted June 09 2004 - 07:30 AM

"That is, they don't emphasize or deemphasize any part of the frequency spectrum to any significant degree. So there's no basis (other than a psychological one) for saying that one amp sounds brighter than another."

some would disagree

"People will say that the black colored one sounds "darker", even though the internal design is the same"

RobertR, are you one of these people? I certainly am not.

#16 of 58 OFFLINE   Chris Brock

Chris Brock

    Second Unit



  • 328 posts
  • Join Date: Sep 13 2003

Posted June 09 2004 - 07:35 AM

IMO the onyl reason I would decide to upgrade my amps, which I plan to do in the future, is to gain increased dynamic headroom and decreased distortion. in its purest form amps should not have any "sound" at all associted with them. they should simply reproduce the recorded material as it appears on the media.

#17 of 58 OFFLINE   Yogi

Yogi

    Screenwriter



  • 1,741 posts
  • Join Date: Jul 25 2002

Posted June 09 2004 - 07:50 AM

Quote:
An example would be listening to a black colored amp vs. a white colored one. People will say that the black colored one sounds "darker", even though the internal design is the same.


Posted Image

Who are these 'people'. I'd like to meet some of them. If you are talking about the folks at Stereophool then I hear ya.
The truth is not out there but within you.

#18 of 58 OFFLINE   Yogi

Yogi

    Screenwriter



  • 1,741 posts
  • Join Date: Jul 25 2002

Posted June 09 2004 - 08:00 AM

Take a look at the power output curves of these two amps:

Posted Image


and this one:


Posted Image

Now consider them hooked to moderate sensitivity Maggies in a moderate sized room (22x18) and you are trying to watch a movie and trying to recreate the theater experience (frankly we all want to bring the theater home). Do you think these amps will sound different? You betPosted Image
The truth is not out there but within you.

#19 of 58 OFFLINE   Claude M

Claude M

    Stunt Coordinator



  • 240 posts
  • Join Date: Jan 18 2001

Posted June 09 2004 - 08:39 AM

yes I know, but I was comparing amps at the time. to me not much difference between a receiver, the anthem and the old ma5002 on the P580s.

#20 of 58 OFFLINE   RobertR

RobertR

    Lead Actor



  • 9,532 posts
  • Join Date: Dec 19 1998

Posted June 09 2004 - 08:39 AM

Quote:
RobertR, are you one of these people?

I'm certainly not someone who thinks the color of an amp affects its sound. My point was that the perception of the sound of an amp can be affected by psychological factors.


Back to Receivers/Separates/Amps



Forum Nav Content I Follow