-

Jump to content



Photo
- - - - -

are those power conditioners really worth it?


This topic has been archived. This means that you cannot reply to this topic.
31 replies to this topic

#1 of 32 TimZ

TimZ

    Agent

  • 33 posts
  • Join Date: Apr 17 2004

Posted May 01 2004 - 07:11 AM

i don't have a big setup but my HT is about 5 grand. just wondering if i should spend the extra $300-500 on getting one or not.
i was looking at the monster 5100

#2 of 32 Chu Gai

Chu Gai

    Lead Actor

  • 7,270 posts
  • Join Date: Jun 29 2001

Posted May 01 2004 - 07:22 AM

what is it that you want to achieve and as an aside, do you own your own house?

#3 of 32 Mark C.

Mark C.

    Supporting Actor

  • 558 posts
  • Join Date: May 21 1999

Posted May 01 2004 - 07:24 AM

I have one of those Monster power "conditioners,'' a HTS2500. It's a great power strip (with cool lights), but that's about it.

#4 of 32 TimZ

TimZ

    Agent

  • 33 posts
  • Join Date: Apr 17 2004

Posted May 01 2004 - 07:28 AM

i was just wondering if they help. with anything. i know a guy who got one who said his tv receeption improved with one.
No i don't own the house.

#5 of 32 NickScott

NickScott

    Stunt Coordinator

  • 53 posts
  • Join Date: Jan 23 2004

Posted May 01 2004 - 10:50 AM

I have the monster hts3500 mk2 and my HT is worth about $15000can. and I would highly recommend one for anybody that has dumpy wiring in their house. My place sucks really bad for wiring, and with the conditioner my hd tv has a better picture, my HK AVR 630 really shines and when dvds (Denon dvd-5900) are being played everybody that has seen my setup are really surprised with how good everything works/sounds.
I got mine on ebay I paid under $350can and at local stores the want to charge me $750can for the same one. Check it out. Good luck.

Scott.

#6 of 32 Paul S

Paul S

    Stunt Coordinator

  • 93 posts
  • Join Date: Nov 01 2003

Posted May 01 2004 - 11:17 AM

A standard surge suppressor should work just fine. All modern electronic equipment is designed to handle voltage fluctuations.

I seriously doubt that you would see any type of performance improvement in your equipment by spending an extra $500.00 or more for any type of electrical conditioning.

#7 of 32 Kevin. W

Kevin. W

    Screenwriter

  • 1,546 posts
  • Join Date: Oct 27 1999

Posted May 01 2004 - 12:13 PM

Quote:
i don't have a big setup but my HT is about 5 grand. just wondering if i should spend the extra $300-500 on getting one or not.


We spend the money on the equipment, we spend it on the interconnects and wire, so why not spend the money on a piece of equipment designed to protect and improve performance. The Monster HTS5100 is a nice piece. Worth the investment.

Kevin

#8 of 32 ross ish

ross ish

    Stunt Coordinator

  • 162 posts
  • Join Date: Nov 18 2002

Posted May 01 2004 - 12:33 PM

The HTS 5100 is a great unit. Personally, I would not go any lower than the 5100. Pop open the hood and you would find the interior chock full of electronics. The lower end units have a lot of empty spaces. With 5 figures of electronics plugged into it, the price of the unit is not out of line. Also, being able plug everything into it, helps reduce ground loop problems. The power conditioner may not do everything that Monster claims, but if only does 10% of the marketing hype, I am a happy camper.

Yes, televisions and dedicated power amps have robust power supplies that can handle minor voltage fluctuations, but it is the spikes that I am concern with. Fine digital circuit boards will deteriate over time with constant bombarments from minute voltage spikes.

I work in the insurance industry and see how useless basic surge protectors are. We constantly paid out in claims on computers, tvs, stereos that were plugged into surge protectors.

#9 of 32 TimMc

TimMc

    Stunt Coordinator

  • 220 posts
  • Join Date: Dec 30 2002

Posted May 01 2004 - 02:58 PM

Well, if you don't own the house then a whole house unit is less attractive (I'd guess that's one way Chu was heading). If you have the bug to spend some $$$ on something, then maybe think about the lightening experience and noticable power fluctuations in your area. If you have brown-outs or power drops, then you might want something else for that condition. It really does depend on what you perceive the "problems" to be and what you want.

If you really want on spend on something that might help for a while then maybe something like a unit from Brickwall? They should be at most 1/2 your $500 top end limit and they do work (if you have the problem they address). They're really just for surge suppression, but their technology probably does that much better that anything else near your price range.

#10 of 32 Jon_Welker

Jon_Welker

    Second Unit

  • 404 posts
  • Join Date: Apr 29 2003

Posted May 01 2004 - 03:25 PM

Like someone posted, you really only need one if the current electric in your house is bad. Otherwise, they are a great profit center for both the retailer and Monster.
DJ_JonnyV

#11 of 32 Drew_W

Drew_W

    Screenwriter

  • 1,718 posts
  • Join Date: Jul 02 2003

Posted May 01 2004 - 04:50 PM

This has been discussed perhaps ad nauseum in the forum where this thread *SHOULD* have gone, which is the Tweaking, Connections, and Acccessories forum...

Buy it from somewhere you can return it if it doesn't give you what you want. Simple as that.
I gave up on tracking my collection and actually started watching what I have.

#12 of 32 TimZ

TimZ

    Agent

  • 33 posts
  • Join Date: Apr 17 2004

Posted May 01 2004 - 04:55 PM

sorry i didn't know it was supposed to go there drew. i am kinda new to these forums

#13 of 32 Drew_W

Drew_W

    Screenwriter

  • 1,718 posts
  • Join Date: Jul 02 2003

Posted May 01 2004 - 04:58 PM

It happens all the time so not to worry. I have a 3600, and I use it as a glorified power bar, and it enables me to "fake" a 12V trigger since my Yamaha RXV630 lacks one. It's an excellent feature, and one that I'm extremely happy I have.

But since YMMV, as I said, you'll have to see for yourself.
I gave up on tracking my collection and actually started watching what I have.

#14 of 32 Jeremy Little

Jeremy Little

    Supporting Actor

  • 772 posts
  • Join Date: Jun 09 2001

Posted May 01 2004 - 05:03 PM

How well it works varies by location to location. I have crappy wiring and the filtering that it does worked wonders for my equipment. Others have noticed almost no improvement at all. Like it has been said before, buy it from somewhere that has a return policy and give it a whirl. If it doesn't improve anything, return it. Whether you get a "clean power" center or not, a good surge-protector is a no-brainer.
If it wasn't for my horse, I wouldn't have spent that year in college.

#15 of 32 Thomas P.

Thomas P.

    Stunt Coordinator

  • 123 posts
  • Join Date: May 20 2002

Posted May 02 2004 - 03:20 AM

TimZ, you will learn more here -

http://www.hometheat...i.com/main.html

Do an advanced search under "power conditioners".
"It would be a shame not to enjoy the humor".

#16 of 32 matt*ms

matt*ms

    Extra

  • 16 posts
  • Join Date: Jan 27 2003

Posted May 02 2004 - 04:59 AM

I received the Monster 3600 for a Holiday gift. I heard significant improvement in my fm music right away. Everything is plugged into the back. With 10 outlets, it has room to spare. You can watch the amps changing up and down

#17 of 32 LanceJ

LanceJ

    Producer

  • 3,168 posts
  • Join Date: Oct 26 2002

Posted May 02 2004 - 09:55 AM

After years of hearing depressing stories about fried electronics when I sold audio and combined with advice from electrical/electronics repairman, I decided that the ultimate surge protector to use is.......The Pull-The-Plug-From-The-Wallsocket-System.

Not very elegant or hi-tech but this 100% guarantees my system will work after one of my state's extremely numerous & lightning-filled thunderstorms finally dissipates.

LJ

#18 of 32 David Judah

David Judah

    Screenwriter

  • 1,479 posts
  • Join Date: Feb 11 1999

Posted May 02 2004 - 12:12 PM

They do a good job of reducing noise on your line in addition to the surge protection. I have a model a couple down from the 5100 and I measured the noise with and without it. It cut it down by about 90%.

Of course, you may not be getting alot of interference, but if it's there, it's one less thing you gotta be concerned about with the performance of your system.

DJ

Lecktor: Then how did you catch me?
Graham: You had disadvantages.
Lecktor: What disadvantages?
Graham: You're insane.

#19 of 32 Chu Gai

Chu Gai

    Lead Actor

  • 7,270 posts
  • Join Date: Jun 29 2001

Posted May 02 2004 - 12:50 PM

Well Tim, seeing as it's not your own house, the next best thing to protect (hopefully) your system is some sort of point of use device. Had you your own house, then the recommedations would have been to spring for having a whole-house surge protector installed.

Let's break this power conditioner thing down a bit into a sort of Reader's Digest version of things.

First let's look at the surge protection aspect. The vast majority of surge protection devices that you're likely to come in contact with are based on MOV's (Metal Oxide Varistors) and/or SAD's (Silicon Avalanche Diodes) with the former being more prevalent. They work on the principal of shunting the excess voltage to ground. In other words they work like a dike whereby they divert the excess instead of trying to dam it up. The effectiveness of any surge protector, and that includes the BrickWall type devices, is directly related to the proximity to earth ground. A surge is not simply a large voltage swing or spike. A surge, especially due to lightning is a high voltage, high current, and high frequency (ies) phenomenon. As a result, although the overall resistance of your ground wire may be low, to a surge, it looks like a high impedance device. The shorter the distance to earth ground, the lower the impedance.

Surge protectors based on MOV's will typically be rated with a number called joules. The greater the joules, the more hits the MOV can take before it dies. Hence, if that's your only protection, and you're in a quandry between which two devices to pick, go with the higher numbers. Now one might think that a number like 900 joules is a lot. Well if it were located at your breaker, it would be. However for a point-of-use device, that number needs to be broken down. A surge can come in on any of the lines and as a result, one must protect all three scenarios: H-G (hot-ground), H-N (hot-neutral), and N-G (neutral ground). As a result, that 900 joules gets split among the three points of entry. Further, as mentioned above, due to the signficantly high impedance that results from the distance to earth ground, those numbers need to be derated signficantly to arrive at an effective joules. Somewhere around 30-40% less protection is actually available.

Now if you're looking to protect your HT system, then all points of ingress need to run through your point of use device. That includes all plugs and the cable. If you haven't addressed them all, then you leave open the possibility that a surge comes in the back door. Shit happens you know.

So what then is power conditioning? It means different things to different people. If you need voltage stabilization, then a voltage stabilizer becomes a power conditioner. If you've got components that have problems with ground leakage, then a balanced power unit becomes a power conditioner. You can see with just these two examples that it's a loose definition.

Most devices always include some sort of emi/rfi filtering. This is achieved by things like inductors, capacitors, and other types of devices. They're intended to remove high frequency junk that might be on your AC line. Regretfully, there is no standard when reporting this quantitatively. Some companies specify it as dB (50 db FWIW is about 99.7% reduction) or as a percentage. Some further tell you over what frequency range they're talking about. Some only tell you at one particular frequency. Monster, as far as I know, doesn't say much about it other than they have it. Panamax is bit better. You'll find devices that are also sold for computer applications to be quite a bit more forthcoming and generally one or two emails gets you some fairly detailed information if that's what you're looking for.

Now this emi/rfi filtering can be achieved in a number of ways. It can come right after the power cord or it can exist between pairs of outlets. The reason for the latter configuration is to address the concerns of people who are worried about Electronic Component #1 dumping some rfi back down the power cord. In the latter scenario, the further away you are from any one component, the greater the emi/rfi filtering is. It's cumulative if you will. Hence if one's got a device with that incorporates some high frequency switching like an SACD player, then you'd put that on the first pair of outlets after the power cord and stick your TV on the furthest one. Make sense?

Price is no indicator of effectiveness here. Numbers are. One can spend hundreds for a 1250 joule unit and $30 for a 3000 joule one. Which one do you think has a better chance of protecting your equipment over the long run? On the other hand, which accountant do you think is smiling more?

Protected Equipment Warranties are useless in my opinion. If you don't have renter's insurance you ought to get it and make sure it includes provisions for Full Equipment Replacement in the event of surge damage (theft, accident, water, etc. too) instead of this prorated stuff. Maybe you'll toss some business ross ish's way Posted Image With a good policy, if a surge trashes your stuff, you'll be back here laughing and talking about how you need to upgrade and be asking for suggestions.

The more expensive Monster and Panamax units provide features which you may or may not find useful. Some have been touched upon by other posts in this thread. Appearance, large # of outlets, triggers, switched and unswitched outlets, delay turn ons, etc. may or may not have importance to you. If they are, then be prepared to pay accordingly for your needs...errrr...wants...errrr...you know Posted Image

Now comes the question. Why do some people observe an improvement in their display when using such a device and other don't? First of all, I don't think it has to do with large voltage swings. If that was happening, then you'd notice it with your lights and unless those are dimming and/or running bright, then you can say with reasonable assurance, that your power is fairly constant. So we scratch that.
What about RFI/EMI on the lines? That's "possible" but you'd have to have extraordinarily large amounts that simply overwhelmed your power supply. Fairly unlikely but seeing as how virtually any device you buy is going to have such protection then one can reasonably expect that to be dealt with fairly effectively by anything you buy.
The most likely reason, in my opinion, is that by running everything through one device, you largely address the problems with ground loops. Sometimes these ground loops are severe enough that even running them through one device still doesn't deal with things like hum coming out of your subwoofer or speakers. In those cases, Calrad sells a video isolation transformer that renders that a non issue. As a side benefit it also cleans up the video.

I don't have any specific recommendations for products. If you need the additional features then look at the Panamax or Monster units. I happen to lean towards Panamax but that's mostly because I think they're more forthcoming with specs. Monster just confuses everything and trying to get information by email or phone is like trying to score with a girl while her father sits with a shotgun looking at you. It just ain't going to happen.

If you don't need those capabilities, then a host of products are out there. For around $20 the Stratitec looks good. Doesn't have the in-between-outlet emi/rfi but the rest of the specs look good. Trip Lites Isobar series is very nice. Priced in the vicinity of $60, you get in-between-outlet emi/rfi, decent joules, and a very nice feature called sine wave tracking. This limits the let through voltage by constantly tracking the AC waveform. For a unit based on SAD's, the DPS series from Transtector is nice. Quicker response time than MOV's and quite excellent at catching little baby transients...call them spikes. That's around $100 straight from the manufacturer which happens to be a sister company to Polyphaser, probably the industry yardstick when it comes to serious protection from lightning.

Things you can do if you're renting would be to check your outlets with an outlet tester (around $4 at Home Depot) to make sure you're wired correctly. Also, if you have access to the breakers, kill them in the room where your HT is, remove the outlet, pull the wires out, clean them, and wrap them around the screws instead of stabbing them through those little holes. It's a better, more robust connection. Then also add the Calrad unit which is around $10. That, to me, will give you the greatest bang for the buck and save you some cash at the same time.

Best of luck. Time for some coffee Posted Image

#20 of 32 LanceJ

LanceJ

    Producer

  • 3,168 posts
  • Join Date: Oct 26 2002

Posted May 16 2004 - 09:45 AM

Just wanted to add something to my above post: I do use a basic ($40) power bar w/spike protection when I'm not around to pull the plug on my system.

Ahhhhh, now I feel better. Posted Image

Bye! Posted Image

LJ