Gruson
Second Unit
- Joined
- Sep 20, 2000
- Messages
- 494
Bad news guys, as others have said, the audio on SW: The Phantom Menace is VERY low and VERY lacking.
I own the LD and have always been amazed at the quality of the sound. I finally found the DVD yesterday and put it into my player.
I read reports about the DVD being lower than the LD but I also found the LFE channel not nearly as strong and the whole front sound stage sounds "muffled", you could say, when compared to the LD.
The laserdisc sound really brings you into the movie. I even turned the volume up REALLY loud on the DVD but it did not have the same effect as the LD.
Please do not get me wrong, the DVD sounds good but it is like comparing the Jurassic Park DTS LD to the old Jurassic Park DTS DVD.
I even had a friend and my brother come over and compare the 2 and the agree with me.
Now, the anamorphic picture looks much better than the LD but the sound just pales in comparison.
Thumbs down. Major dissapointment here. I will be watching the LD when I watch Episode 1.
I can only hope there is a better release down the road.
Why would they not use the same kick ass LD audio track?!?!?!
My equipment is below.
------------------
Equipment:
Mitsubishi 65907 65" HDTV ISFd Steve Martin
Yamaha RX-V1000 6.1
Paradigm PW2200
Paradigm Studio CC
Paradigm Studio 40s
CV LS-15s
CV LS-8s
Toshiba 6200 Progressive
Pioneer CLD704 LD
Aura Bass Shakers
1080i DirecTV
See it:
Link Removed
I own the LD and have always been amazed at the quality of the sound. I finally found the DVD yesterday and put it into my player.
I read reports about the DVD being lower than the LD but I also found the LFE channel not nearly as strong and the whole front sound stage sounds "muffled", you could say, when compared to the LD.
The laserdisc sound really brings you into the movie. I even turned the volume up REALLY loud on the DVD but it did not have the same effect as the LD.
Please do not get me wrong, the DVD sounds good but it is like comparing the Jurassic Park DTS LD to the old Jurassic Park DTS DVD.
I even had a friend and my brother come over and compare the 2 and the agree with me.
Now, the anamorphic picture looks much better than the LD but the sound just pales in comparison.
Thumbs down. Major dissapointment here. I will be watching the LD when I watch Episode 1.
I can only hope there is a better release down the road.
Why would they not use the same kick ass LD audio track?!?!?!
My equipment is below.
------------------
Equipment:
Mitsubishi 65907 65" HDTV ISFd Steve Martin
Yamaha RX-V1000 6.1
Paradigm PW2200
Paradigm Studio CC
Paradigm Studio 40s
CV LS-15s
CV LS-8s
Toshiba 6200 Progressive
Pioneer CLD704 LD
Aura Bass Shakers
1080i DirecTV
See it:
Link Removed